Best Roof Repair in Carnegie, PA — Top Roofers (2026)
Top Roofers in Carnegie, PA
Filter by service:
MY Pittsburgh Roofing earns consistent praise for exceptional craftsmanship, with customers highlighting the quality of installations completed efficiently and with meticulous attention to detail—including careful debris management and thorough post-installation inspections by owner Gino. Clients particularly value the company's transparent communication and expertise, noting that the team explains work clearly, provides reasonable pricing relative to quality delivered, and maintains responsiveness throughout projects. The company's reliability is evident through on-time completion, proactive project management with regular updates, and a willingness to address any follow-up issues promptly.
"My wife and I recently moved into a new home, and during the inspection, we were told the roof was in the second half of its life. We assumed that meant we had five years—not five weeks—before needing a replacement. After reading several positive reviews, I reached out to My Pittsburgh Roofing for a quote. The salesperson, a former roofer himself, walked me through the issues with our current roof in a way that was easy to understand. We ended…" — Matthew B.
+1 412-218-7082
McCormick Renovations
McCormick Renovations earns consistent praise for their efficient, high-quality workmanship and meticulous attention to detail, completing projects quickly while maintaining clean job sites and leaving customers thoroughly satisfied. Customers particularly appreciate the professionalism and friendliness of the entire team—from sales representatives like Rob and Robby to office staff Alexa and project managers Stephen—who communicate clearly, address concerns promptly, and handle insurance claims expertly. The company demonstrates strong product knowledge, fair pricing, and reliability, whether handling emergency storm damage, standard installations, or repairs, making them a trusted choice for roofing and siding projects.
"This review is a long time coming! The McCormick team replaced our vinyl siding with Everlast siding back in April of 2024 and WE LOVE IT SO MUCH. After going through spring, summer, fall, and now winter with this siding, I feel confident in saying McCormick did an absolutely EXCELLENT job installing it for us!! There hasn’t been a single issue that we had to call back to have fixed and the only downside of that is that we don’t get to hang out…" — Kelly B.
+1 412-271-5770
Resnik Roofing earns consistent praise for their knowledgeable and professional team, with customers particularly highlighting honest consultations, thorough inspections, and clear explanations of options without pressure. The company stands out for exceptional communication throughout projects, reliable timelines, and meticulous attention to detail—with crews completing work efficiently while maintaining clean job sites and remaining patient and available to answer customer questions. From initial consultation through installation and repairs, customers appreciate the team's expertise, professionalism, and genuine care in delivering high-quality roofing solutions.
"We recently had our roof replaced by Resnik Roofing and couldn’t be happier with the entire experience. From the very beginning, our initial consultation with Mark was fantastic. He clearly walked through all of our options and explained the pros and cons of each. There was zero pressure, just honest, knowledgeable guidance. Communication throughout the project was excellent. The team kept us well informed about timelines and what to expect on…" — sarah d.
+1 412-946-8300
Madden Brothers Roofing earns consistent praise for exceptional craftsmanship, competitive pricing, and outstanding customer service from start to finish. Customers highlight the owners' responsiveness—returning calls and providing quotes the same day—along with their crew's efficiency, professionalism, and respect for property, often completing full roof replacements in a single day. The company stands out for going above and beyond, from prioritizing emergency leaks to assisting customers through insurance claims and providing transparent communication via calls, texts, and photo updates throughout projects.
"We recently moved to a new home and were looking for a roofing contractor. It's hard these days to find someone to even return your call. George not only called the same day, but he and his brother, Brian, came out that same day to access our project. They had a quote sent over the following day and called to talk us through it. We selected our products with the help of a representative from their supplier. She brought samples to the house. …" — K S.
+1 412-537-9589
Rabbit Roofing earns consistent praise for exceptional professionalism, responsiveness, and quality craftsmanship across all project types—from full roof replacements to inspections and gutter work. Customers particularly appreciate the team's quick turnaround, fair pricing, attention to detail, and reliability, with many returning for additional projects and recommending them without hesitation. Led by owner Egor, the company is known for punctuality, clear communication, and going above and beyond, such as completing work in a single day or making unexpected repairs with materials on hand.
"I have hired Rabbit Roofing twice for my house and have been very happy with his work. First was just for a quick gutter clean and the second time was to install gutter guards which were very much needed. Both times I found Egor to be very professional, tidy and he was on time too. He even patched my shed roof because he had a spare shingle on his truck! If I ever have any roofing problems, this is my roofer now!" — Erin D.
+1 412-512-4610
Gerger Construction earns consistent praise from customers for their exceptional craftsmanship, responsive communication, and professional crew. Homeowners particularly appreciate owner Matt's personalized approach—from providing product samples and design plans to the daily progress updates provided by lead crew members like Hunter—that make the decision-making process convenient and transparent. The company's flexibility, attention to detail, and thorough job site cleanup demonstrate a commitment to customer satisfaction that has resulted in numerous recommendations for both deck and roofing projects.
"Gerger Construction recently completed a project at our home. Matt was great to work with. He provided all product samples making it convenient for us to make decisions and also had design plans drawn according to our wishes. Our back porch was transformed by installing new decking to extend our existing porch and a new roof to cover the space. Matt’s crew performed exceptional work. The crew was lead by Hunter who has a phenomenal work ethic…" — Daniel
+1 412-843-5096
A Plus Roofing & Exteriors consistently earns praise for exceptional craftsmanship, with customers highlighting the superior quality and attention to detail in every project from roof replacements to custom exterior work. Owner Joe and his skilled team members are recognized for outstanding communication and professionalism throughout projects, keeping customers informed of timelines, delays, and custom details while maintaining clean, organized job sites. The company is also valued for fair pricing, efficient project completion—often faster than competitors—and a personal, relationship-focused approach that transforms large-scale construction projects into positive experiences.
"We purchased our home in 2018 and we hated the front of the house. The giant white piece of metal on top of the porch looked so out of place, the old rusted rod iron railings, the corrugated metal porch roof with the leaking internal gutter system just made the house look so blahhh, dated, and was in dire need of a refresh. In April we had damage to the main roof of the home from a bad storm and we found out we needed a whole new roof. This gave…" — Toni P.
+1 412-515-5466
365 Gutters earns consistent praise for responsive, professional service and quality workmanship. Customers consistently highlight the company's reliability—including same-day and emergency response times—combined with fair pricing and efficient, detail-oriented work. The team is known for excellent communication throughout the process, with owner Andrew and technicians like Anthony demonstrating friendliness, politeness, and a commitment to making customers feel taken care of from first call to project completion.
"Had a nice size ice dam around my gutter so I got on my step ladder and chipped away at the ice (next time I will leave it to the professionals) I poked holes in my gutter. I called and spoke to Anthony explained what I did and he was so nice and polite on the phone, we set up a time for him to come to put a new gutter up. He kept me updated on how long he was going to be, when he arrived he was professional and very friendly, got the job done…" — Christine W.
+1 412-909-9990
Buccos Roofing consistently earns five-star reviews for their professionalism, competitive pricing, and exceptional communication throughout every project. Customers particularly praise project manager Nathan Paras and his team for arriving on time, maintaining clean work sites, completing jobs efficiently, and keeping homeowners informed at each step. The company's highest-level Owens Corning certification and willingness to handle additional work like fascia and soffit installation demonstrate their commitment to quality craftsmanship and comprehensive service.
"My wife and I replaced our roof using Buccos and are very happy with the experience. I obtained mulitple quotes and found that Buccos offered the best price for the Owens Corning shingled roof that I wanted. As it turns out, Buccos has the highest level O/C certification which gave me confidence that they know how to do it. Everyone with whom I worked with at Buccos was polite and helpful. Our project manager, Nathan Paras, was great to work…" — John C.
+1 724-973-3101
Pro Home and Roofing consistently delivers exceptional value and quality craftsmanship, with customers praising their competitive pricing that undercuts competitors without sacrificing results. The team is known for outstanding professionalism, responsive communication through multiple channels, efficient project completion, and meticulous job-site cleanup that exceeds industry standards. Customers repeatedly highlight the reliability and friendliness of the entire crew, from initial consultation through final invoice, making them a trusted choice for roof replacement projects.
"We just had a brand new roof put on by Pro Home and Roofing. From start to finish, the whole process was seamless!! My favorite part was being able to text them whenever I had a question, comment or concern. Sometimes calling is such a hassle with some places so I loved that flexibility! They always got back to me ASAP! The workers were very professional and had our old roof taken off and the new one put on in one day - amazing! I was also…" — Danielle M.
+1 412-818-0289
Why Hire a Local Roofer in Carnegie?
Local Climate Knowledge
Carnegie roofers understand Pennsylvania's specific weather patterns and choose materials built to last in local conditions.
Building Code Compliance
Local contractors know Carnegie's permit requirements and code standards, ensuring your repair passes inspection.
Faster Response Times
A local company can respond to emergencies quickly and follow up easily if issues arise after the repair.
Typical Roof Repair Costs in Carnegie
| Repair Type | Typical Cost Range |
|---|---|
| Minor Leak Repair | $150 – $400 |
| Shingle Replacement (small area) | $300 – $900 |
| Flashing Repair | $200 – $600 |
| Gutter Repair / Replacement | $150 – $500 |
| Section Repair (large area) | $1,500 – $5,000 |
| Emergency Repair | $500 – $1,500 |
| Full Roof Replacement | $8,000 – $25,000+ |
* Estimates only. Actual costs vary by scope, materials, and contractor. Get at least 3 quotes.
FAQ: Roof Repair in Carnegie, PA
Roof repair costs in Carnegie typically range from $150–$400 for minor leak repairs to $1,500–$5,000 for extensive section repairs. Emergency repairs can cost more. The exact price depends on the extent of damage, roofing material, roof pitch, and the contractor you choose. Always get 3 quotes before committing.