Best Roof Repair in Lima, OH — Top Roofers (2026)

6 Verified Contractors 4.9 Avg Rating 992 Total Reviews AI-Analyzed Reviews

Top Roofers in Lima, OH

Filter by service:

Sort by:

Roszman Roofing and Remodeling Inc

5(77 reviews)
Online Estimates
AI Review Summary

Roszman Roofing earns consistent praise for their professionalism, clear communication, and honest pricing throughout every project stage. Customers consistently highlight the crew's meticulous attention to detail, respectful work practices, daily cleanup, and ability to complete projects efficiently—from minor repairs to full roof replacements—while maintaining competitive and fair costs. The company's commitment to treating every home with care and providing knowledgeable guidance has made them a trusted choice for both roofing installations and repairs.

"This company is GREAT! I had a small job where I only needed 4 down spouts replaced and and tile/down spout caps because I had some foundation work done on my home. Two months ago I got an estimate from another company for $400 which I thought was fair but that company kept putting me off. I got 2 other estimates from different companies for the same job with one being $1000 and another being $1200. I called this company and Justin promptly…" — Scott L.
1501 Lima Ave
Licensed - Not confirmedInsured - Not confirmed✓ 25 yrs in business

+1 419-310-2195

AI Review Summary

Buckeye Roofing consistently delivers exceptional workmanship and professionalism, with customers praising the quality of materials, attention to detail, and outstanding finishing results. Owner Steve and his crew are known for their honesty, clear communication, efficient project completion, and meticulous cleanup—often exceeding customer expectations despite competitive pricing. Customers repeatedly recommend Buckeye Roofing as a reliable, trustworthy company they would confidently hire again for any roofing needs.

"Update 7.19.22 We are beyond happy with Buckeye Roofing!!! Steve and his crew were without a doubt fun, and professional at the same time. Their workmanship is outstanding and beat other quotes. The quality of materials they use are the best around. Even with their lowest quote, they exceeded our expectations and the price was a bonus! They worked from 6-2pm two days in a row and they cleaned up as they went along, leaving no trace of materials…" — Shannon R.
4563 Elida Rd
Licensed - Not confirmedInsured - Not confirmedYears - Not confirmed

+1 419-979-4745

Evans Home Improvement

4.9(407 reviews)
Online EstimatesVeteran-Owned
AI Review Summary

Evans Roofing is praised by customers for their exceptional craftsmanship, competitive pricing, and reliable communication throughout projects. Clients consistently highlight the team's professionalism, punctuality, and attention to detail—from identifying structural issues to completing work on schedule and budget. The company is also recognized for their responsiveness in emergencies, willingness to coordinate with insurance companies, and thorough cleanup, making them a trusted choice for roofing and home improvement needs.

"The worked performed buy Evans Roofing on our little lake house was truly outstanding. The Atlantic Blue roofing beautifully complements our blue vinyl siding. Devon kept me well-informed throughout the project. The team consistently demonstrated punctuality and worked diligently to complete the project. Furthermore, I obtained three estimates, and they were more competitive than their rivals. I highly recommend Evans Roofing for your roofing…" — Tony J.
704 North St
Licensed - Not confirmedInsured - Not confirmed✓ 50 yrs in business

+1 419-394-6326

Nitro Roofing & Construction

4.9(203 reviews)
24/7 EmergencyOnline EstimatesOpen Weekends
AI Review Summary

Nitro Roofing earns consistent praise for exceptional professionalism, transparent communication, and meticulous workmanship from start to finish. Customers particularly appreciate the team's responsiveness—with sales representatives arriving same-day and crews completing complex projects efficiently—as well as their thorough cleanup and willingness to address any issues immediately. The company is also recognized for skillfully navigating insurance claims and staying within budget, making them a trusted choice for homeowners investing in their most valuable asset.

"From day one Connor and Nitro Roofing were nothing short of being professional. We had storm damage to our roof from the march tornados, Connor worked with us and our insurance company to make the claim seamless. Once the claim was approved Nitro was able to schedule the work to be done within less than two weeks. The crew got to work early in the morning and was able to do a complete removal and replacement within the same day. They did a very…" — Tom M.
5356 Southland Rd
Licensed - Not confirmedInsured - Not confirmedYears - Not confirmed

+1 419-557-8498

AI Review Summary

Legacy Roofing and Construction earns consistent praise for their professionalism, responsiveness, and quality craftsmanship, with customers highlighting how quickly the team responds to requests, thoroughly explains projects, and completes work ahead of schedule. The crew is noted for exceptional cleanup after jobs and for working diligently even in challenging conditions, with multiple customers specifically commending team members like Matt and their ability to coordinate complex projects from estimate through completion. Customers appreciate the company's friendly demeanor, clear communication throughout the process, and attention to detail in both roofing and siding work.

"Legacy Roofing and Construction replaced the roof on my Mother's house a week ago. Adam came out, very professional, and showed my Mom the work to be done plus a hole in the roof where critters may have been. Then, Mike and his crew, again very professional, tore off the old roof and worked till dark to put on the new roof due to rain projection in forecast and completed the project in one day. They cleaned up very well like they were no there.…" — Robin T.
4320 Harding Hwy
Licensed - Not confirmedInsured - Not confirmedYears - Not confirmed

+1 419-230-0196

Swartz Restoration & Emergency Services

4.7(142 reviews)
24/7 EmergencyOpen Weekends
AI Review Summary

Swartz Restoration consistently earns praise for their rapid emergency response, transparent communication throughout projects, and exceptional professionalism from leadership to field staff. Customers particularly appreciate their meticulous, detail-oriented approach—explaining each step before proceeding—and their genuine commitment to treating homes with care and respect. Their ability to transform challenging situations like water damage and emergency repairs into positive outcomes has made them a trusted recommendation among satisfied clients.

"I could not recommend anyone more than Swartz Restoration. Their team and leadership continued to go beyond my expectations at every turn. They were extremely in depth with everything they did, they communicated every step before it was done along with a thorough explanation as to why. The level of respect and kindness they showed through out the job was incredible. They take pride in their work and it shows at the end of the job. They took an…" — Chandler B.
2622 Baty Rd
Licensed - Not confirmedInsured - Not confirmedYears - Not confirmed

+1 419-331-1024

Why Hire a Local Roofer in Lima?

Local Climate Knowledge

Lima roofers understand Ohio's specific weather patterns and choose materials built to last in local conditions.

Building Code Compliance

Local contractors know Lima's permit requirements and code standards, ensuring your repair passes inspection.

Faster Response Times

A local company can respond to emergencies quickly and follow up easily if issues arise after the repair.

Typical Roof Repair Costs in Lima

Repair TypeTypical Cost Range
Minor Leak Repair$150 – $400
Shingle Replacement (small area)$300 – $900
Flashing Repair$200 – $600
Gutter Repair / Replacement$150 – $500
Section Repair (large area)$1,500 – $5,000
Emergency Repair$500 – $1,500
Full Roof Replacement$8,000 – $25,000+

* Estimates only. Actual costs vary by scope, materials, and contractor. Get at least 3 quotes.

FAQ: Roof Repair in Lima, OH

Roof repair costs in Lima typically range from $150–$400 for minor leak repairs to $1,500–$5,000 for extensive section repairs. Emergency repairs can cost more. The exact price depends on the extent of damage, roofing material, roof pitch, and the contractor you choose. Always get 3 quotes before committing.