Best Roof Repair in Madison, IN — Top Roofers (2026)
Top Roofers in Madison, IN
Filter by service:
Full Guard Roofing is led by owner Sam, who customers consistently praise for his professionalism, responsiveness, and hands-on approach to every project. The team is known for their work ethic and attention to detail—completing jobs efficiently while thoroughly cleaning up and ensuring customer satisfaction, even going above and beyond such as fighting with insurance companies on behalf of clients. Customers appreciate Sam's honest communication, flexible pricing options, and genuine care in addressing urgent issues like roof leaks, making Full Guard a trusted choice for both repairs and full roof replacements.
"I already had a roofing company lined up to do the job, well it didn't work out and I was beyond stressed out because I have leaks all in my house from my roof. That's when a friend mentioned about Full Guard Roofing, and I contacted Sam immediately. For a small business, and doesn't have paid advertisements, This company is the best. Sam reassured me, stood behind me when I was stressed out and made sure they moved me to the top of the list…" — Amber R.
+1 502-939-1983
Mengel Exteriors, LLC
Mengel Exteriors earns consistent praise from customers for exceptional installation quality, competitive pricing, and outstanding customer service that extends well beyond the initial sale. Customers highlight the expertise of their installers—many with 30+ years of experience—who pay meticulous attention to detail and leave homes spotless, while the team's responsiveness and willingness to follow up on any concerns demonstrate a genuine commitment to customer satisfaction. The company's lifetime warranty on windows, combined with transparent pricing that prioritizes product quality over advertising costs, makes Mengel a trusted choice for homeowners seeking reliable, professional window replacement.
"Thanks to the team at Mengel, especially to the installers and Robert for such a fantastic job on our 16 windows. We met about 5 companies for windows and I couldn’t wait for the process to be over. I can tell you Mengel’s price was the best, and as far as windows go I figured the lifetime warranty speaks for itself. All my research said if the window is good it comes down to the installers. Turns out the people working on our house have been…" — Evan C.
+1 502-228-4400
1st Choice Construction
1st Choice Construction earns consistent praise from customers for their professional workmanship, responsive communication, and honest service across roofing and related projects. Clients particularly appreciate Matt's team's reliability—including their ability to expedite schedules during emergencies, thorough cleanup, and attentive follow-up care. The company has built a strong reputation for standing behind their work and resolving issues that other contractors have abandoned, making them a trusted choice for homeowners seeking quality craftsmanship and dependable service.
"Just recently had my roof replaced, had a small leak and Matt was so quick to move us up on the schedule to prevent further damages. We are so very thankful and appreciative of him and his team. The roofers were fantastic very polite and did an excellent job cleaning up. House was reroofed in record time as well. I couldn’t ask for a better experience during this whole process beginning with the first phone call of getting a quote to a follow up…" — Megan G.
+1 812-346-7663
Masters Roofing is a family-owned, legacy business known for exceptional professionalism, reliability, and prompt service—with customers consistently praising their ability to handle everything from emergency leak repairs to full roof replacements with minimal disruption. Owner Matt and his team are recognized for their expertise in navigating the insurance claims process, clear communication throughout projects, and meticulous cleanup, earning strong recommendations from both homeowners and local real estate professionals. Their commitment to quality workmanship and customer satisfaction has built a solid reputation in the Louisville community for being trustworthy, knowledgeable, and genuinely compassionate.
"I will use them again! After some terrible storms we needed to replace our roof. Thank you Masters Roofing Co. Bill was amazing to work with. I’ve never had to get a roof and was worried about the process knowing after that storm so many people needed roofs. But it was an easy process and done in a timely manner. Not to mention my yard was completely cleared of any mess. Thank you again Bill and Masters roofing" — Katie G.
+1 502-241-0982
Prime Roofing
Prime Roofing consistently earns praise for exceptional communication and responsiveness, with customers highlighting how Project Manager Zac Phillips and the team keep clients informed at every stage—from claim approval through project completion. The crew is known for efficient, detail-oriented work completed on schedule, paired with professional service and thorough cleanup that leaves properties spotless. Customers particularly appreciate the company's quick turnaround on estimates and scheduling, as well as the friendly, attentive approach their teams bring to each job.
"We are so pleased with the roofing and siding replacement recently completed by Prime Roofing. Project Manager Zac Phillips worked tirelessly with me to get the claim approved always keeping me informed and responding in a timely manner. Once scheduled the job was completed on time. The crew was responsive to my questions and were very detailed with the work. Finally once completed my property was left spotless. I only wish Google offered a 10…" — Robert U.
+1 502-236-9051
Lyons Roofing receives strong praise from customers for the quality of their roof replacements and the professionalism of their team, particularly salesman Dave. Many customers highlight the company's reliability in meeting scheduled timelines and their thorough cleanup after completing projects. However, some customers have reported communication inconsistencies and debris management issues during the roofing process, suggesting areas where service delivery could be more consistent across all jobs.
"We had some hail damage earlier this year and we chose Lyons Roofing among several possible businesses to do a roof replacement. Our salesman Dave was very good and knowledgeable and I would recommend him. The roughing project went well. We love our new roof and I was especially impressed with the cleanup that they performed. I would recommend Lyons Roofing. Thanks." — David W.
+1 812-294-3595
Royalty LLC delivers reliable roofing solutions with exceptional craftsmanship and professional service from start to finish. Customers consistently praise their responsive communication, efficient work crews, meticulous cleanup, and willingness to assist with insurance claims and tight deadlines. The company's commitment to quality workmanship and responsible service has earned strong recommendations from homeowners across multiple projects.
"Three years ago, a friend recommended a local renovation company to replace my roof. A little over a year later, the roof started leaking continuously and was damaged in several places. I could no longer contact that company. Now, whenever I need repairs, I search online to avoid being scammed again. Last month, I saw employees of Royalty LLC replacing roofs for residents in the neighborhood, so we contacted them. After inspecting my house, their…" — massage m.
+1 812-523-8392
Why Hire a Local Roofer in Madison?
Local Climate Knowledge
Madison roofers understand Indiana's specific weather patterns and choose materials built to last in local conditions.
Building Code Compliance
Local contractors know Madison's permit requirements and code standards, ensuring your repair passes inspection.
Faster Response Times
A local company can respond to emergencies quickly and follow up easily if issues arise after the repair.
Typical Roof Repair Costs in Madison
| Repair Type | Typical Cost Range |
|---|---|
| Minor Leak Repair | $150 – $400 |
| Shingle Replacement (small area) | $300 – $900 |
| Flashing Repair | $200 – $600 |
| Gutter Repair / Replacement | $150 – $500 |
| Section Repair (large area) | $1,500 – $5,000 |
| Emergency Repair | $500 – $1,500 |
| Full Roof Replacement | $8,000 – $25,000+ |
* Estimates only. Actual costs vary by scope, materials, and contractor. Get at least 3 quotes.
FAQ: Roof Repair in Madison, IN
Roof repair costs in Madison typically range from $150–$400 for minor leak repairs to $1,500–$5,000 for extensive section repairs. Emergency repairs can cost more. The exact price depends on the extent of damage, roofing material, roof pitch, and the contractor you choose. Always get 3 quotes before committing.