Best Roof Repair in New Philadelphia, OH — Top Roofers (2026)

Canton Roofing earns consistent praise from customers for exceptional communication throughout every project stage, transparent explanations of complex processes like insurance claims, and impressive speed of service—with multiple reviewers noting faster turnarounds than expected. Customers particularly highlight the professionalism and attentiveness of the team, including office staff and crew members, along with quality workmanship and attention to detail on roofing installations. Many clients appreciate the company's value proposition, with several noting competitive pricing that came in significantly under initial estimates.

Hall of Fame Roofing earns consistent praise for their speed, professionalism, and customer-focused service. Customers particularly appreciate Christian and his team's ability to navigate insurance claims efficiently, complete projects quickly (often in a single day), maintain clear communication with progress updates, and leave properties spotlessly clean. The company is recognized for honest pricing, knowledgeable staff, and genuine care in delivering quality workmanship while keeping customers informed and stress-free throughout the process.

Country Roofing & Exteriors consistently earns praise for exceptional communication, professionalism, and efficiency throughout every project phase. Customers highlight the team's responsiveness, attention to detail, respect for properties, and willingness to go above and beyond—whether completing full roof replacements in a single day or assisting with insurance claims—while delivering competitive pricing and superior workmanship. The company's friendly, knowledgeable crew and transparent approach have made them a trusted choice for roofing, gutters, and exterior projects.

Shane Fisk Roofing earns consistent praise for professional workmanship, efficient project completion, and meticulous cleanup, with customers highlighting the quality of finished roofs and the team's pride in their work. The company stands out for exceptional communication and customer service throughout the entire process, particularly during complex insurance claims and lengthy projects, with team members like Jake and Luke receiving specific recognition for their knowledge, honesty, and dedication to keeping customers informed every step of the way. Customers also appreciate the company's willingness to work directly with insurance companies, often resulting in minimal out-of-pocket costs for homeowners.

Asbury Roofing & Siding consistently delivers high-quality workmanship with expert product knowledge, as evidenced by customers praising their skilled crews and beautiful finished results. The team stands out for their professionalism and communication, keeping customers informed throughout projects, advocating on their behalf with insurance companies, and accommodating changes with flexibility. Customers appreciate the company's commitment to value, working with homeowners to find affordable solutions without compromising quality, along with their respectful service and meticulous cleanup.

Pine Ridge Roofing consistently earns praise from customers for exceptional communication, professionalism, and high-quality craftsmanship across roofing, siding, gutters, and exterior renovation projects. Clients appreciate the company's transparency in pricing—delivering quotes without hidden surprises—and the personal attention from team members like Jonathan, Alan, Kevin, and Joel, who remain engaged throughout each project from initial inspection to final cleanup. With multiple five-star reviews highlighting reliability, fair pricing, and results that exceed expectations, Pine Ridge Roofing has established itself as a trusted contractor that genuinely invests in customer satisfaction.

663 Roofing & Exteriors consistently earns praise from customers for exceptional professionalism, swift project completion, and meticulous attention to detail across roofing and exterior work. The team, led by owner Jimmy, is recognized for courteous communication, thorough explanations of the process, and efficient execution—completing jobs like full roof replacements in hours rather than days while maintaining high-quality craftsmanship. Customers particularly appreciate the company's work ethic, knowledge of insurance claims, and ability to exceed expectations, with multiple reviews highlighting the minimal disruption and pristine clean-up left at job sites.

J&J Roofing consistently delivers exceptional results with fast turnaround times and competitive pricing that customers find hard to beat. The team is praised for their professionalism, responsiveness, and ability to complete full roof replacements in a single day, even on larger homes. Customers particularly appreciate their friendly demeanor, thorough communication from estimate through completion, and meticulous cleanup, making them a trusted choice for roofing projects of any size.

Anthony Roofing earns consistent praise for their exceptional professionalism, reliability, and quality craftsmanship across all roofing projects. Customers particularly appreciate their efficiency—completing complex jobs in one to two days without cutting corners—combined with transparent communication that keeps homeowners informed throughout the entire process. The company consistently delivers outstanding results at fair, competitive pricing, with meticulous cleanup and a dedicated crew that treats each project with care and attention to detail.

Keim Quality Roofing earns consistent praise for exceptional craftsmanship, competitive pricing, and unwavering professionalism throughout every project. Customers highlight owner Jonathan's honesty, attention to detail, and commitment to delivering pristine results—whether through thorough explanations of options, responsive adjustments after installation, or seamless coordination with insurance claims. The team's reliability, efficiency, and meticulous cleanup further set them apart, making them a trusted choice for residential roofing work.