Best Roof Repair in Plymouth, WI — Top Roofers (2026)

Wisconsin Roofing LLC earns consistent praise for exceptional craftsmanship and efficient project completion, with customers highlighting their ability to finish complex jobs in a single day while maintaining meticulous cleanup standards. The team, led by owners Jake and Jed, is renowned for their professionalism and responsiveness—from the estimate phase through project completion—with on-site leads like Alex ensuring every detail is addressed and crews maintaining clean work areas. Customers also appreciate Wisconsin Roofing's competitive pricing and willingness to communicate thoroughly, with team members taking time to answer questions and guide clients through insurance approval processes.

Superior Waterproofing earns consistent five-star praise for their expert craftsmanship, comprehensive problem-solving, and exceptional customer service. Customers particularly value the team's thorough assessments, transparent communication throughout projects, and willingness to collaborate on cost-saving solutions. With a reputation for timely, professional work backed by responsive ongoing support, Superior Waterproofing has built strong client loyalty, with many returning for additional projects and maintenance services.

Wrightway consistently delivers exceptional craftsmanship and professionalism, with customers praising their installation teams for meticulous, efficient work completed on time and in all weather conditions. The company's skilled installers are known for being knowledgeable, personable, and thorough—paying attention to details like cleanup and weatherproofing—while offering competitive pricing and the convenience of multiple services under one contractor. Customers frequently become repeat clients, citing the company's reliable five-star service and the quality results that improve both the appearance and energy efficiency of their homes.

Irish Roofing is highly regarded for their efficient, professional workmanship and meticulous attention to detail, with customers consistently praising their timely project completion and thorough cleanup. The crew's reliability and fair pricing have earned strong loyalty, with multiple customers returning for additional projects including roofing, siding, windows, and gutter work. Clients particularly appreciate their comprehensive solutions and lasting results, with many reporting that their homes are now leak-free and worry-free for years to come.

CustomCraft Roofing consistently delivers exceptional results, with customers praising the professionalism and expertise of their teams across all project phases. Reviewers highlight the company's clear communication throughout projects, reliable project management, and meticulous attention to detail—even on complex installations—combined with hardworking crews who maintain clean job sites and often complete work ahead of schedule. Customers appreciate receiving fair pricing for quality workmanship backed by experienced crew leaders who ensure jobs are done right to maximize roof longevity.

Gellings Roofing earns consistent praise for exceptional communication, professional crews, and meticulous attention to detail throughout every project phase. Customers particularly appreciate the company's reliability in addressing post-completion issues promptly, accurate cost estimates with no surprises, and the personal involvement of ownership and dedicated project managers who ensure work meets expectations. The team's courteous, productive approach combined with thorough cleanup and competitive pricing makes them a trusted choice for roofing, siding, windows, and exterior home projects.

West Bend Construction earns consistent praise from customers for their professionalism, meticulous attention to detail, and exceptional communication throughout every project phase. Homeowners particularly appreciate the team's responsiveness—from same-day scheduling to thorough explanations of work and options—along with their reliable, timely completion of both simple inspections and major roof replacements. The crew's friendly demeanor, organized approach, and commitment to leaving clean job sites make customers feel confident recommending them as an honest, customer-focused alternative to larger companies.

CAB Construction earns consistent praise for their professional, efficient crews who complete projects quickly—often in a single day—while maintaining exceptional cleanliness and attention to detail. Customers particularly appreciate the expertise and responsiveness of owner John Montag, who skillfully navigates insurance claims and ensures clients receive fair settlements from their insurance companies. The team is known for reliable communication, flexible scheduling, and a commitment to customer satisfaction from initial estimate through project completion.

AM Construction earns consistent praise from customers for their skilled craftsmanship, attention to detail, and exceptional responsiveness throughout projects. Clients particularly appreciate the crew's professionalism and personable approach, along with their willingness to go above and beyond—such as color-matching materials and thoroughly explaining the installation process. The company's reliability and quality work have made them a trusted choice for repeat business across window, door, and carpentry projects.