Best Roof Repair in Rittman, OH — Top Roofers (2026)

Buckeye Guys Roofing is a local operation known for exceptional craftsmanship, reliability, and outstanding customer service. Customers consistently praise their professionalism, timely completion of projects, and skilled team that takes pride in quality work while handling insurance coordination to maximize customer benefits. The brothers behind the company are recognized for their trustworthiness, responsiveness, and genuine care for their clients, often tackling challenging projects that others refuse and going above and beyond expectations.

Division 1 Roofing earns consistent praise for professional workmanship, clear communication, and knowledgeable team members who guide customers through every step of their projects. Customers appreciate the crew's efficiency, attention to detail, and willingness to address concerns—from insurance claim questions to unexpected issues—often going above and beyond to ensure satisfaction. The company is recognized for fair pricing, quality results, and a friendly, trustworthy approach that gives homeowners confidence in their roofing investments.

Pring & Son Roofing consistently delivers exceptional craftsmanship and fair pricing, with customers praising their quick turnaround on quotes, meticulous attention to detail, and thorough cleanup. Owner Kurtis is commended for his hands-on involvement, clear communication, and willingness to thoroughly explain the work and address customer concerns throughout the project. The team's reliability in meeting timelines and completing jobs to perfection has made them a trusted choice for customers who received multiple competing estimates.

R Hammond Construction earns consistent praise from customers for exceptional craftsmanship, attention to detail, and thorough communication throughout projects. Clients appreciate Rick's team's professionalism—including punctuality, daily cleanup, responsiveness to mid-project requests, and the crew's willingness to answer questions and offer thoughtful suggestions. The company's commitment to quality work, reliability, and customer satisfaction has resulted in homeowners recommending them for roofing and remodeling projects of all sizes.

Craig Roofing consistently earns praise for owner Jeff Craig's exceptional responsiveness, integrity, and hands-on involvement in every project, often going above and beyond by honoring quotes, upgrading materials at no extra cost, and providing detailed communication throughout the job. Customers particularly appreciate the crew's thoroughness and attention to detail, from adjusting installations to ensure perfect alignment to identifying discontinued shingles and guiding clients through insurance claims. The company is recognized for delivering quality workmanship efficiently, with fast turnaround times and meticulous cleanup, making it a trusted choice for roofing repairs and replacements.

Erb's Construction earns consistent praise for exceptional craftsmanship, professional service, and outstanding communication throughout every project stage. Customers particularly highlight project manager Edwin's expertise, responsiveness, and ability to clearly explain options and keep clients informed from initial consultation through completion. The team is commended for efficient work, meticulous attention to detail, competitive pricing, and courteous on-site conduct, with multiple clients noting they plan future projects with the company.

Pro Con Exteriors consistently earns praise from customers for their reliability, professionalism, and quality craftsmanship across roofing and exterior projects. Clients particularly appreciate their responsive communication, punctual scheduling, thorough cleanup, and reasonable pricing, with multiple customers returning for additional projects. The company's crews are noted for working efficiently, paying meticulous attention to detail, and maintaining a courteous, helpful approach throughout the job.

Winding River Construction earns consistent praise for exceptional customer service and reliability. Customers particularly appreciate the team's expertise in navigating insurance claims—with staff like Kyle and Tom handling adjuster meetings, documentation, and negotiations on their behalf—as well as their transparent communication throughout the entire process, from material selection to installation timelines. The crew is noted for efficient, high-quality workmanship, meticulous cleanup, and genuine care in treating each home as their own.

Customers consistently praise Steve and his crew for their exceptional professionalism, punctuality, and thorough communication throughout every project phase—from initial estimates to final cleanup. Reviewers highlight the quality craftsmanship of their insulation work, noting that the team goes above and beyond expectations by identifying and addressing issues customers weren't aware of, all at reasonable prices. The company earns strong recommendations for treating customer satisfaction as a priority while maintaining the personable service of a trusted small business.

Division 1 Roofing earns consistent praise for their expert handling of insurance claims, with owners Andrew and David Sabota personally guiding customers through every step of the process with transparency and support. Customers appreciate the team's professionalism, quality workmanship, and efficiency—completing most roofs in a single day while maintaining meticulous cleanup standards, including magnetic nail sweeps. Their commitment to customer service shines through in their willingness to accommodate appointments at customers' homes, answer detailed questions, and provide follow-up visits to ensure quality, making them a trusted choice for both storm damage and new roof installations.