Best Roof Repair in Amherst, OH — Top Roofers (2026)
Top Roofers in Amherst, OH
Filter by service:
Customers consistently praise Mateosgutters for their responsiveness and professionalism, with multiple reviewers highlighting same-day or next-day service availability and thorough communication throughout the process. The team is noted for their expertise in identifying issues like wood rot, explaining work clearly to homeowners, and delivering quality results on gutter cleaning and maintenance jobs. However, one customer reported significant concerns with a coping installation project, citing poor workmanship, lack of follow-up, and unresponsive customer service when issues arose.
"A called for a quick quote for a damaged gutter. Within an hour they were assessing it in person. I also received 3 other quotes and they were the most reasonable. Then to really provide 5 star customer service they informed me they could do the job the following day at 9am. The job was completed the next morning with no issues. I would recommend Mateosgutters to anybody and use them again without hesitation." — D M.
+1 216-713-5292
Coates Bros Roofing
Coates Roofing consistently earns five-star reviews for their professionalism, competitive pricing, and thorough workmanship on both repairs and full installations. Customers particularly appreciate the crew's reliability and efficiency—completing projects on tight timelines, protecting homes during weather threats, and leaving job sites clean—along with their courteous, down-to-earth approach that avoids high-pressure sales tactics. The company's attention to detail extends beyond roofing itself, with customers noting quality work on gutters, ventilation, and additional features, backed by clear communication and fair estimates throughout the process.
"We had an amazing experience with Coates Bros Roofing, the estimate was fair & the people/works were so down to earth. There is nothing worse than a sales guy in your house pushing this that & the other and they did not do that to us! They also fixed our corner gutter that was creating an ice rink on our front porch, vented all 3 of our vents (kitchen, 2 bathrooms) properly out of our attic instead of into our soffits, & cut & installed our sun…" — Samantha B.
+1 440-595-4675
Bill Jackson Roofing earns consistent praise from customers for their combination of quality craftsmanship, fair pricing, and exceptional professionalism. Clients appreciate the team's thoroughness—from taking time to research optimal solutions and explain work to customers, to completing jobs efficiently without cutting corners and conducting final walk-throughs. The company is known for building lasting customer loyalty through reliable, knowledgeable service across both residential and commercial projects.
"Had full tearoff, wood replaced, new roof and new gutters and we are extremely happy with it all. The roofers were extremely hard working and job was done in 1 day. Brendan Jackson are salesmen was very helpful throughout the entire process. Going above and beyond answering questions and coming by our home. Very happy with final price , no surprises! Thank you again! Would definately recommend!" — Laura H.
+1 440-577-5082
Smart Fix Roofing earns consistent praise from customers for their exceptional craftsmanship, professional communication, and reliable service throughout the roofing process. Owner Alin and his team are noted for their expertise, attention to detail in explaining complex roofing issues, and willingness to guide customers through insurance claims and material selections. Customers appreciate their prompt response times, clean workmanship, competitive pricing, and manufacturer-backed warranties that reflect their commitment to quality installations and lasting results.
"We had a new roof installed from Smart Fix roofing last fall and could not be more pleased. The roof looks fantastic and the service was wonderful. Alin, the owner, walked us through the entire process, answered all of our questions and provided expert insight from his many years of expertise in the roofing industry. The quality of materials used and the quality of craftsmanship by Alin and his team are very evident in the final result. I highly…" — Sam S.
+1 440-782-1231
Franciscus Roofing is praised by customers for its honesty, integrity, and competent workmanship, with multiple reviewers noting that the company provides straightforward assessments rather than recommending unnecessary replacements. Customers consistently highlight the professionalism and responsiveness of the team, particularly project managers who communicate clearly about timelines, processes, and expectations while ensuring quality installation and thorough cleanup. The company has earned strong recommendations from homeowners and professionals alike for combining reasonable pricing with reliable, respectful service from initial assessment through project completion.
"My husband and I had a nice experience with Franciscus with our leaky roof. They were highly recommended from 2 of my coworkers so I decided to give them a try. We had the pleasure of meeting Albert when he came out to check our roof issue. He went up on the roof and took pictures of the area that needed attention. He was able to seal the problem area and done! We were worried that we would need a whole new roof. I feel the company is honest and…" — Judy M.
+1 440-200-0491
Hinckley Roofing earns consistent praise from customers for their exceptional professionalism, clear communication, and high-quality workmanship across roofing, skylights, and gutter projects. Customers particularly appreciate the company's knowledgeable team members—including sales representatives like Tony and installers like Ray—who take time to educate homeowners, provide regular updates, and deliver meticulous work even on complex jobs completed in a single day. The company's fair pricing, transparent process, and thorough cleanup have made customers confident recommending Hinckley Roofing to friends and family.
"From the first call, Tony Ricco was a fantastic representative of the business! We were thrilled with his professionalism and insight as he worked through the initial quote and Hinckley’s process. Unfortunately due to it being right smack in the middle of winter m, we had to wait a few months for them to install the new roof but once they started, they worked their tails off to complete not only the tear off, but replacement of decking and the…" — Jeff R.
+1 330-273-2979
Paul Davis stands out for assembling highly skilled teams that execute complex water damage and restoration projects with surgical precision and meticulous attention to detail. Customers consistently praise the company's professionalism, transparent communication, and attentive project management—with team members checking in regularly, answering questions thoroughly, and keeping clients informed at every step. The company reliably completes projects efficiently without compromising quality, often finishing substantial damage restoration in under a week while carefully matching finishes and salvaging important items whenever possible.
"Drew Anderson has assembled an unbelievable team. Our issue arose on a Saturday, Drew accompanied his team after Jeremy performed an initial assessment. Working together we patched together a thoughtful strategy to keep the mitigation and assessment as surgical as possible. They assessed extent of damage on all floors. Jonathan and Ashley then went to work implementing the plan. Jonathan was surgical with how and where drywall was cut. He…" — Maged R.
+1 330-220-2002
Horvath Roofing earns consistent praise from customers for their exceptional communication, responsiveness, and professional workmanship. Clients particularly appreciate the team's ability to diagnose and solve complex roofing issues confidently, deliver timely quotes and repairs, and maintain meticulous attention to detail and cleanliness throughout projects. The company's combination of quality craftsmanship, reliable follow-through, and courteous service has built strong customer loyalty and repeat business.
"Last October, I contacted 6 different roofing companies to look into repairing a roofing job with a unique issue. We had water coming in through a door into the house and another leak in our living room. Out of the 6 roofing companies, Horvath Roofing was the only company that came out and confidently said they could fix both issues no problem. They showed up on time on Friday and provided a quote by Monday morning. It has now been 4 months, and…" — Suzanne C.
+1 419-656-7663
Triple Peaks Roofing & Construction consistently delivers exceptional service and quality craftsmanship, with customers praising the knowledgeable and responsive team—particularly sales consultants Kevin and owners Jeff and Angela—who thoroughly explain options and keep clients informed throughout the project. The skilled installation crews complete projects efficiently (often in just one to two days) while maintaining high standards and meticulous cleanup, with customers noting that work quality exceeds expectations and represents excellent value. Beyond new installations, the company's technicians demonstrate expertise in diagnosing and solving complex roofing problems, earning strong recommendations from homeowners seeking reliable, professional roofing solutions.
"Jeff and Brandie are great. They really helped us to figure out what we needed to repair the leaks in our roof. Robert was our roof technician. He was very good. He was able to identify several problems that needed attention even beyond what was originally thought to be the problem. Both he and Brett worked hard to get our situation rectified. They were very helpful and a joy to work with. We have yet to see how the repairs went. But, we feel…" — Deejartist
+1 440-925-0386
North Coast Masonry is highly regarded for exceptional communication, with customers praising owner Tim's responsiveness via text and detailed updates throughout projects. The team consistently delivers professional, quality workmanship—from chimney repairs to masonry restoration—while maintaining clean job sites and going above and beyond with protective measures and cleanup. Customers appreciate Tim's hands-on approach, fair pricing, and willingness to tackle complex jobs that other contractors declined, with many becoming repeat clients.
"This is the forth job North Coast Masonry has completed for me and by far the largest and most labor intensive. Tim and his crew removed failing stucco, ground out old mortar and repointed all the cinder block on the sides of garage. They replaced cinder blocks and reset bricks that had popped out due to water. Repointed the entire front of the brick garage. Tim is easy to work with, friendly, fair and honest. He is great to communicate with…" — Bonnie F.
+1 216-326-8174
Why Hire a Local Roofer in Amherst?
Local Climate Knowledge
Amherst roofers understand Ohio's specific weather patterns and choose materials built to last in local conditions.
Building Code Compliance
Local contractors know Amherst's permit requirements and code standards, ensuring your repair passes inspection.
Faster Response Times
A local company can respond to emergencies quickly and follow up easily if issues arise after the repair.
Typical Roof Repair Costs in Amherst
| Repair Type | Typical Cost Range |
|---|---|
| Minor Leak Repair | $150 – $400 |
| Shingle Replacement (small area) | $300 – $900 |
| Flashing Repair | $200 – $600 |
| Gutter Repair / Replacement | $150 – $500 |
| Section Repair (large area) | $1,500 – $5,000 |
| Emergency Repair | $500 – $1,500 |
| Full Roof Replacement | $8,000 – $25,000+ |
* Estimates only. Actual costs vary by scope, materials, and contractor. Get at least 3 quotes.
FAQ: Roof Repair in Amherst, OH
Roof repair costs in Amherst typically range from $150–$400 for minor leak repairs to $1,500–$5,000 for extensive section repairs. Emergency repairs can cost more. The exact price depends on the extent of damage, roofing material, roof pitch, and the contractor you choose. Always get 3 quotes before committing.