Best Roof Repair in Beech Grove, IN — Top Roofers (2026)

138 Verified Contractors 5.0 Avg Rating 653 Total Reviews AI-Analyzed Reviews

Top Roofers in Beech Grove, IN

Filter by service:

Sort by:

Proshield Roofing

5(74 reviews)
Open Weekends
AI Review Summary

Proshield Roofing earns consistent praise for exceptional professionalism, clear communication, and reliability across all project types. Customers particularly appreciate owner George's hands-on approach—from thorough inspections and transparent pricing to personally guiding clients through insurance claims and walking them through each step of the work process. The team consistently delivers high-quality results on time, handles complex projects efficiently, and treats customer homes and belongings with care, making them a trusted choice for roofing, siding, gutters, and comprehensive home repairs.

"After a recent hailstorm in Sullivan, Indiana, our roofs and gutters were severely damaged. George and Andrew with ProShield Roofing visited our home and provided a memorable experience unlike any other. George was very hands-on during the inspection, thoroughly examining our property and carefully documenting all storm-related damage. Using his expertise, George initiated our insurance claim with us present, speaking directly with our insurance…" — Brandy S.
5508 Elmwood Ave Ste 313
Licensed - Not confirmedInsured - Not confirmedYears - Not confirmed

+1 317-764-9811

Single Play Restoration Services LLC

5(72 reviews)
Open Weekends
AI Review Summary

Single Play Restoration earns consistent praise from customers for their professionalism, punctuality, and transparent communication throughout projects. Clients particularly appreciate the team's attention to detail, thorough problem-solving abilities, and commitment to quality workmanship—whether replacing roofs, making repairs, or completing custom builds—all delivered at reasonable prices. The company stands out for its respectful approach to customers' homes, reliable follow-up communication, and willingness to explain options without pressure or cutting corners.

"We recently had Mike from Single Play Restoration come out to inspect our roof after weeks of hearing squirrels wreaking havoc in our attic. We have a tri-level home with vaulted ceilings, and with the cold winter weather, our resident oak tree squirrels apparently decided our house was the perfect place to stay warm. They chewed straight through the wood siding near the roofline and made themselves at home. Before calling Single Play, we had…" — Lauren P.
863 Massachusetts Ave
Licensed - Not confirmedInsured - Not confirmedYears - Not confirmed

+1 317-482-7658

Watergate Roofing

5(71 reviews)
Women-Owned
AI Review Summary

Watergate Roofing consistently delivers exceptional customer experiences through responsive communication, professional workmanship, and fair pricing. Customers particularly praise team members like Max and Millie for their availability, expertise, and willingness to go above and beyond—whether guiding clients through insurance claims or answering detailed questions throughout projects. The company's commitment to quality extends beyond installation to meticulous cleanup and follow-up, with management personally checking on completed work to ensure customer satisfaction.

"This is the only google review I’ve ever left because it’s the first place I’ve felt compelled to write one for! After getting several quotes from different companies (including a close friend’s) we were very confident in choosing Watergate. They were honest, not trying to overcharge on anything, and willing to be flexible with some of our more specific needs. Max was amazing at communicating (and genuinely delightful to talk to) and made sure…" — Naptown F.
3209 W Smith Valley Rd Ste 217-2
Licensed - Not confirmedInsured - Not confirmedYears - Not confirmed

+1 317-207-9712

Metal Roofing Indianapolis

5(65 reviews)
Open Weekends
AI Review Summary

This roofing company earns consistent praise for skilled, professional workmanship and efficient project execution, with customers highlighting well-organized crews who complete installations ahead of schedule and deliver durable, attractive results. Homeowners appreciate the company's attention to detail, clear communication about materials and timelines, and commitment to thorough cleanup. Customers report that the finished roofs are built to last and significantly enhance their homes' appearance and value.

"This roofing company is really great. They showed me how to install everything, from the materials to the time frame. The workers worked tirelessly and finished the roof replacement sooner than planned. My house has never looked better. Very professional crew!" — Andres M.
4826 W 34th St
Licensed - Not confirmedInsured - Not confirmedYears - Not confirmed

+1 463-231-3049

Miller Construction

5(65 reviews)
Online EstimatesOpen WeekendsSpanish Speaking
AI Review Summary

Miller Construction earns consistent praise from customers for their honest, fair-priced approach to roofing and seamless gutter work, with owner Rubin Miller personally overseeing projects to ensure quality and customer satisfaction. Clients particularly appreciate their reliability and punctuality—completing jobs on schedule and efficiently—combined with transparent communication and a willingness to tailor solutions to individual budgets rather than overselling unnecessary services. The team's commitment to quality craftsmanship and pride in their work, along with their professional and courteous demeanor, has made them a trusted choice for residential and rental property owners throughout Indianapolis.

"I am a small business owner leasing rental properties on the East Side of Indianapolis. I have used Miller Construction for my roof repair needs for several years now, and have always been satisfied with their work. Rubin has taken care of jobs both big and small, and always fixes the issues in a timely and cost-effective manner. They will not over-sell you on services if you do not need it, and will tailor solutions to fit your needs and your…" — Ethan H.
7641 Swails St
Licensed - Not confirmedInsured - Not confirmedYears - Not confirmed

+1 317-457-5151

No. 1 Exteriors

5(64 reviews)
Online EstimatesOpen WeekendsWomen-Owned
AI Review Summary

No. 1 Exteriors consistently earns praise for their professionalism, punctuality, and exceptional communication throughout every project stage—from initial consultation through completion. Customers highlight owner Armando's attentiveness to their concerns, his crew's reliability in meeting deadlines and arriving on time, and their commitment to quality craftsmanship on projects ranging from roof replacements and siding to repairs and gutter work. The company's competitive pricing, thorough photo documentation, and willingness to go above and beyond have made them a trusted choice for homeowners seeking reliable exterior services.

"I received 3 quotes to have our house re-sided with vinyl siding. No. 1 Exteriors was competitive with their pricing and I went with them primarily due to my interaction with Armando. He and his crew were nothing but professional, polite, considerate, and hardworking. They did a fantastic job, and we couldn’t be more pleased and satisfied with the results. I would not hesitate to give a wholehearted recommendation to No. 1 Exteriors for any of…" — Ed S.
804 Phi Delta Kappa Dr
✓ Licensed✓ InsuredYears - Not confirmed

+1 317-426-0315

Mister Quik Home Services

5(63 reviews)
Open Weekends
AI Review Summary

Mister Quick Handyman, led by Michael Taylor, earns consistent praise for exceptional craftsmanship and meticulous attention to detail on projects ranging from siding replacement to drywall repair. Customers particularly appreciate Taylor's professionalism, punctuality, and efficient work style, combined with his genuine care for customer satisfaction and willingness to explain work thoroughly. The company is praised for combining high-quality workmanship with friendly, reliable service that consistently exceeds expectations.

"I recently hired Mister Quick Handyman, and I couldn’t be more pleased with the experience—especially working with Michael Taylor. Michael was professional, punctual, and extremely knowledgeable. He took the time to explain the work that needed to be done, made sure everything was completed correctly, and paid attention to the small details that really make a difference. The quality of the workmanship was excellent, and the job was finished…" — Antonio
8435 Georgetown Rd #1100
✓ Licensed✓ Insured✓ 26 yrs in business

+1 317-452-4727

AY Remodeling & Restoration LLC

5(62 reviews)
Online Estimates
AI Review Summary

AY Remodeling and Restoration LLC consistently delivers exceptional quality work backed by outstanding professionalism and communication, with customers praising the team's efficiency, attention to detail, and ability to solve complex challenges while maintaining fair pricing. Owner Ayman is noted for his transparency, compassion, and commitment to holding his crew to rigorous standards, resulting in projects completed on time or ahead of schedule. Customers across residential and commercial projects—from ADA-compliant home additions to full kitchen renovations—highlight the team's reliability, respectful demeanor, and willingness to go above and beyond to exceed expectations.

"Working with AY Remodeling and Restoration LLC was an exceptional experience for my husband and I. Ayman built an addition to our home which had to be ADA compliant as well as meeting vigorous requirements from the VA. My husband has ALS and this room was very important. Every encounter we had with Ayman and his crew was professional, courteous, informative and compassionate. Ayman, the owner, was completely transparent and took the time to…" — Shannon S.
14300 Whitworth Dr
Licensed - Not confirmedInsured - Not confirmedYears - Not confirmed

+1 317-828-1191

Spotless Exterior, LLC

5(61 reviews)
Online EstimatesOpen WeekendsMinority-Owned
AI Review Summary

Spotless Exterior, led by owner Jevon, consistently delivers exceptional exterior cleaning services with remarkable speed and professionalism. Customers praise the company's quick response times, punctual scheduling, and high-quality workmanship that leaves homes looking pristine, with results that often last years between cleanings. The combination of reasonable pricing, efficient service, and thorough attention to detail has earned Spotless Exterior strong loyalty, with customers repeatedly returning and enthusiastically recommending the company to friends and family.

"I don't remember how I found Jevon, but he has come to our home twice now to clean the exterior of our home. His first job left us not needing him for another couple of years. He always is able to book us quickly, shows up on time, and does a fantastic job. I will always be calling him as long as he is in business. No one else like Spotless Exterior!" — Carmen J.
411 E Northfield Dr #466
Licensed - Not confirmedInsured - Not confirmedYears - Not confirmed

+1 317-670-0058

Indy Legacy Builders Roofing

5(56 reviews)
Open WeekendsWomen-Owned
AI Review Summary

Indy Legacy Builders earns consistent praise for exceptional workmanship, fair pricing, and outstanding customer advocacy—particularly their willingness to work directly with insurance adjusters to help customers obtain claim approvals. Customers highlight owner David Felton's professionalism, attention to detail, and reliability throughout the entire process, from initial consultation to seamless project completion. The company uses high-quality GAF shingles and delivers results that significantly enhance home curb appeal, with customers expressing long-term satisfaction and confidence in recommending the company to others.

"We had an incredible experience with Indy Legacy Builders roofing company from start to finish. After our insurance company denied our roof claim multiple times, David stepped in and worked directly with the insurance adjuster to advocate on our behalf. Thanks to his persistence and expertise, the claim was finally approved, which was such a huge relief for us. Beyond handling the insurance process, they also helped us choose the perfect color…" — Keith K.
11555 Eller Rd
✓ Licensed✓ InsuredYears - Not confirmed

+1 317-981-3923

Why Hire a Local Roofer in Beech Grove?

Local Climate Knowledge

Beech Grove roofers understand Indiana's specific weather patterns and choose materials built to last in local conditions.

Building Code Compliance

Local contractors know Beech Grove's permit requirements and code standards, ensuring your repair passes inspection.

Faster Response Times

A local company can respond to emergencies quickly and follow up easily if issues arise after the repair.

Typical Roof Repair Costs in Beech Grove

Repair TypeTypical Cost Range
Minor Leak Repair$150 – $400
Shingle Replacement (small area)$300 – $900
Flashing Repair$200 – $600
Gutter Repair / Replacement$150 – $500
Section Repair (large area)$1,500 – $5,000
Emergency Repair$500 – $1,500
Full Roof Replacement$8,000 – $25,000+

* Estimates only. Actual costs vary by scope, materials, and contractor. Get at least 3 quotes.

FAQ: Roof Repair in Beech Grove, IN

Roof repair costs in Beech Grove typically range from $150–$400 for minor leak repairs to $1,500–$5,000 for extensive section repairs. Emergency repairs can cost more. The exact price depends on the extent of damage, roofing material, roof pitch, and the contractor you choose. Always get 3 quotes before committing.