Best Roof Repair in Carlisle, PA — Top Roofers (2026)
Top Roofers in Carlisle, PA
Filter by service:
American Remodeling Enterprises earns consistent praise from customers for professional and knowledgeable service, particularly highlighting staff expertise in explaining products, warranties, and project processes with clarity and confidence. Clients appreciate the company's responsiveness to questions and willingness to work within budgets to meet customer needs from initial consultation through installation. However, potential customers should carefully review contract details and material specifications before work begins, as there have been instances where ordered products differed from final installations.
"American Remodeling Enterprises did an excellent job on our wimdiw replacement project. From our initial meeting to discuss our needs and obtain a job quote to the final installation, the process was professional and pleasant. They worked with us to get what we needed within our budget and were responsive to all of our needs and questions. I would highly recommended them for your next project." — Robert P.
+1 717-268-9020
Carter & Sons Roofing consistently earns praise from customers for exceptional craftsmanship, meticulous attention to detail, and thorough cleanup on every job. Customers particularly value the professionalism and expertise of project manager Douglas, who takes time to educate homeowners on options, explain each step of the process, and provide flexible solutions—from guiding clients through financing and insurance claims to going beyond the scope of work to ensure complete satisfaction. The team's reliability, responsive communication, and commitment to protecting property during installation have made customers confident in their investment and eager to recommend the company to others.
"We recently had our roof replaced in Stewartsville and the whole experience was fantastic. After we signed with the design team on a Saturday, a crew of six roofers arrived just a few days later to start the job. The project manager, Douglas, was already there to handle the delivery and make sure everything was ready to go. Once they removed the old shingles, they even took care of some wood repairs under the roof before installing the new…" — Alexander6 W.
+1 908-829-9020
Martin's Roofing LLC
Martin's Roofing earns consistent praise for their knowledgeable and friendly staff combined with competitive pricing that delivers exceptional value. Customers highlight the company's quick turnaround times and efficient service, with one noting their barn project will "look amazing and last for years." The team is recognized for understanding customer needs and making the buying experience straightforward and hassle-free.
"Friendly knowledgeable Staff. Great pricing. Quick turnaround on our order. Would definitely recommend them and buy from Martin's Roofing again. Barn will look amazing and last for years." — Kathy W.
+1 717-532-3460
Bella Concepts earns consistent praise for exceptional craftsmanship, attention to detail, and honest pricing—customers repeatedly note that final costs matched initial quotes with no surprises. The team, led by Jeremy, is recognized for outstanding communication, responsiveness, and professionalism, with crew members Dylan, Nate, Travis, Chris, and Josh regularly commended for their courteous demeanor and respect for customers' homes and privacy. Clients highlight the company's ability to handle complex projects—from custom additions and window installations to historic home renovations—while maintaining meticulous quality standards and taking time to explain their work throughout the process.
"I had Bella Concepts remodel my mud room which was an add-on to my home. It was meant to cover the exterior access to the basement and it was in a pretty terrible state. I had several contractors out to look at it and provide quotes. Jeremy was the only one that seemed actually interested in providing feedback. He came back to me pretty quickly with a fair quote and actually had drawings of what the mudroom would look like when completed, which…" — Romier S.
+1 717-462-6551
This roofing company earns consistent praise for their straightforward, honest approach and exceptional quality of work that customers trust to protect their homes. Clients particularly appreciate the friendly, helpful team who go above and beyond in customer service, creating a positive experience from start to finish. With a track record of excellent projects and strong recommendations from satisfied customers, this company delivers both reliable craftsmanship and professional, personable service.
"I was truly impressed with the customer service I received from this company…they went above and beyond leaving me highly satisfied….the team was very friendly and helpful I recommend these guys if your in search of a quality buying experience" — Rand
+1 717-853-1344
R & R Roofing earns consistent five-star ratings for their exceptional combination of quality craftsmanship, reliability, and outstanding customer service. Customers appreciate their use of premium materials, honest estimates, quick scheduling (often completing jobs within days rather than months), and meticulous cleanup. The team is praised for their professionalism, responsiveness, reasonable pricing, and willingness to address small issues promptly—making them a trusted choice for both residential and commercial roofing projects throughout central and south-central Pennsylvania.
"These folks at R&R Roofing are fantastic. We had a couple of estimates, but we went with R and R because they use the best materials, are the most responsive, and had the best price by far. From the time that we selected our roof and made the down payment, the job was done in less than a week, and it only took a day and a half to install the actual roof and skylight. The team did a fantastic job of cleaning up the property after they were…" — Sgt. J.
+1 717-532-2053
Ace Handyman Services consistently earns praise from customers for their exceptional professionalism, reliability, and attention to detail. Clients particularly appreciate the company's quick scheduling, punctual arrivals, and the expertise of their technicians—especially Jeff—who communicate clearly about procedures, work meticulously, and leave spaces cleaner than they found them. Beyond quality craftsmanship, customers highlight the friendly and helpful customer service team, noting that the staff goes above and beyond to ensure complete satisfaction on every project.
"My husband already left a review, but we are so pleased that I feel compelled to leave my own! We are new to the area and bought a house that basically needs to be fixed/replaced from top to bottom (we did not do this on purpose 😏). I am not being overdramatic when I say Ace has saved our sanity! Whomever my husband speaks to when he calls is always friendly, helpful, and concerned about us being 100% happy. Their customer service is off the…" — That's S.
+1 717-660-0934
Home Genius Exteriors earns consistent praise from customers for their professional, detail-oriented approach and exceptional communication throughout every project phase. Clients highlight the responsiveness of project manager Dylan, the expertise and work ethic of installation crews, and the quality of finished results—from roofing and siding to gutters and windows. Customers repeatedly describe the team as reliable, trustworthy, and genuinely invested in customer satisfaction, making them a dependable choice for exterior home improvements.
"I recently used home genius for a roofing replacement and I can't speak highly enough of the process and final product. The roof looks amazing and I am so pleased with the process from inspection to installation. The whole team was professional and I felt like they truly cared i will be using them for new windows in the future. Thank you Dylan and home genius" — Donna M.
+1 717-905-4844
Customers consistently praise First Choice Exteriors for their honest, professional approach and quality craftsmanship, with several reviewers highlighting the integrity of inspectors like Chris Guillen who provide transparent assessments and fair pricing without pressure tactics. The installation teams are noted for efficient, detailed work completed quickly with thorough cleanup, and project managers like Brandon Martinez have earned recognition for exceptional customer care and going above and beyond—including personal support during difficult times. However, some customers have experienced significant delays and poor follow-up communication regarding property damage or project completion, indicating inconsistency in reliability and accountability across different service experiences.
"After a terrible storm that recently happened around the area where I live. I desperately needed a new roof but was very skeptical about reaching out to ANY company, (Too many scammers nowadays). I’m old school and the process seemed way too stressful and complicated but after speaking to my neighbors they recommended the project manager Brandon Martinez and mentioned that they had also had their roof,siding,gutters,downspouts and gutter guards…" — John H.
+1 717-321-0596
Caliber Roofing, led by Justin, consistently delivers high-quality exterior work with exceptional attention to detail and thorough cleanup that leaves customers impressed. Customers praise the team's professionalism, responsiveness to concerns, and reliability, with many returning for additional projects and recommending the company to others. The company stands out for competitive pricing, quick turnaround times, and a stress-free experience from start to finish.
"Caliber did an incredible job from start to finish! Justin was very responsive and professional for a small siding job. The guys came out and got it done in one day and it was like they were never even there, they cleaned up every little piece of wood and material. The price was also substantially less then other local companies had quoted, would highly recommend and would definitely use Caliber again in the future!" — Kristina R.
+1 717-542-8456
Why Hire a Local Roofer in Carlisle?
Local Climate Knowledge
Carlisle roofers understand Pennsylvania's specific weather patterns and choose materials built to last in local conditions.
Building Code Compliance
Local contractors know Carlisle's permit requirements and code standards, ensuring your repair passes inspection.
Faster Response Times
A local company can respond to emergencies quickly and follow up easily if issues arise after the repair.
Typical Roof Repair Costs in Carlisle
| Repair Type | Typical Cost Range |
|---|---|
| Minor Leak Repair | $150 – $400 |
| Shingle Replacement (small area) | $300 – $900 |
| Flashing Repair | $200 – $600 |
| Gutter Repair / Replacement | $150 – $500 |
| Section Repair (large area) | $1,500 – $5,000 |
| Emergency Repair | $500 – $1,500 |
| Full Roof Replacement | $8,000 – $25,000+ |
* Estimates only. Actual costs vary by scope, materials, and contractor. Get at least 3 quotes.
FAQ: Roof Repair in Carlisle, PA
Roof repair costs in Carlisle typically range from $150–$400 for minor leak repairs to $1,500–$5,000 for extensive section repairs. Emergency repairs can cost more. The exact price depends on the extent of damage, roofing material, roof pitch, and the contractor you choose. Always get 3 quotes before committing.