Best Roof Repair in Cedarburg, WI — Top Roofers (2026)

Advanced Exteriors earns consistent praise for professional service and quality craftsmanship, with customers particularly appreciating Mike's clear communication and honest assessments that help them understand their repair needs. The team is known for prompt scheduling, reliable follow-through on projects like roof repairs and rotting wood replacement, and attention to detail such as matching shingles and siding. Multiple customers highlight their willingness to go above and beyond, from working with insurance companies to offering cost-saving suggestions.

West Bend Construction earns consistent praise from customers for their professionalism, meticulous attention to detail, and exceptional communication throughout every project phase. Homeowners particularly appreciate the team's responsiveness—from same-day scheduling to thorough explanations of work and options—along with their reliable, timely completion of both simple inspections and major roof replacements. The crew's friendly demeanor, organized approach, and commitment to leaving clean job sites make customers feel confident recommending them as an honest, customer-focused alternative to larger companies.

McCoy Contractors earns consistent praise for their meticulous, professional work and fair pricing on complex foundation and basement projects. Customers highlight the team's efficiency, expertise, and respect throughout the process—from thorough initial estimates by Bob to skilled execution by crew members like Mark and Bradd—along with transparent communication through daily updates and walkthroughs. Beyond technical excellence, clients particularly value the company's integrity, responsiveness, and honest approach to assessing what work is truly necessary.

Creative Construction earns consistent praise from customers for exceptional craftsmanship and meticulous attention to detail across carpentry, plastering, and stucco work. Clients particularly appreciate the team's professionalism, daily communication throughout projects, and ability to match textures and colors perfectly while completing work that blends seamlessly with existing structures. The company's transparent pricing, reliable follow-through on estimates, and pleasant, hardworking team members make them a trusted choice for home repairs and renovations.

Ideal Roofing Specialists consistently delivers exceptional service and quality workmanship, with customers praising their efficiency, professionalism, and attention to detail throughout every project. The team excels at managing the entire process from start to finish, including expert handling of insurance claims and advocating for customers to ensure comprehensive coverage of necessary repairs. Customers particularly appreciate the polite and respectful crew members, clear communication, timely completion, and thorough cleanup that characterize their work.

Milwaukee Chimney and Roof earns consistent praise from customers for their responsiveness, professionalism, and honest communication—with owners readily available by phone and crews arriving on time and prepared. Customers particularly value their problem-solving approach, fair pricing, and thorough explanations of recommended solutions, whether addressing leaks, chimney damage, or installations. The company's commitment to customer satisfaction extends beyond the job itself, with crews cleaning up after themselves and ensuring homeowners are satisfied before departure.

Feldco has earned strong customer loyalty through exceptional service and craftsmanship, with clients consistently praising the professionalism and personable nature of their sales representatives and installation teams. Customers highlight the quality of completed work—from flawless installations to noticeable improvements in window functionality and home insulation—along with the company's thorough communication and willingness to address concerns. Multiple long-term customers recommend the company for its reliable, efficient service and commitment to customer satisfaction.

Paul Davis Restoration is highly regarded for its professionalism, responsiveness, and exceptional craftsmanship across water damage mitigation, cleanup, and restoration projects. Customers consistently praise the team's clear communication, timely service, and meticulous attention to detail—from thorough documentation that satisfies insurance companies to flawless execution in demo, renovation, and finishing work. The company's knowledgeable staff and collaborative approach to managing complex projects make them a trusted choice for homeowners facing property damage emergencies.

Mr. Handyman earns consistent praise from customers for their professional, reliable service and meticulous workmanship across diverse projects from bathroom renovations to drywall repair. Clients particularly appreciate the team's responsiveness, transparent communication about project timelines and next steps, and thorough cleanup after completion. Their technicians—including Jacob, Steve, and Dwight—are noted for their expertise, punctuality, and personable approach, with several customers indicating they would hire them again for future work.

Advocate Construction earns consistent praise for their expertise in navigating insurance claims and their hands-on approach to customer service—multiple customers highlight how the team successfully secured full roof approvals and handled all insurance-related details on their behalf. Customers particularly appreciate the professionalism and efficiency of their crews, with work completed to high quality standards and clear communication maintained throughout each project from initial inspection through final walkthrough. The company's accessibility and responsiveness stand out, with customers noting they answer phones with real people and keep homeowners informed every step of the way.