Best Roof Repair in Eltingville, NY — Top Roofers (2026)

USA General Contractors is recognized by customers for their exceptional professionalism, responsiveness, and quality workmanship across all projects. Clients consistently praise the team's extensive knowledge, efficient completion timelines, and meticulous attention to detail, with particular appreciation for their communication and follow-up service. The company has earned strong loyalty through their combination of skilled technicians, knowledgeable supervisors, and a genuine commitment to exceeding customer expectations on every job.

Penyak Roofing earns consistent praise for delivering quality workmanship at competitive prices, with customers highlighting efficient project completion and thorough cleanup. The team is known for exceptional responsiveness in quotes and scheduling, along with professional communication from both field crews and office staff. The owner's commitment to standing behind their work and making things right has earned strong customer loyalty, with many recommending the company to friends and family.

Gikas Contracting has earned strong praise for exceptional craftsmanship and design expertise, with customers particularly highlighting the team's attention to detail, responsiveness, and ability to transform spaces—from kitchen renovations to hardwood floor restoration at competitive prices. Team members like Alex are frequently commended for their consultative approach, patience, and collaborative problem-solving throughout projects. However, potential customers should be aware that experiences vary significantly; while some clients report seamless, professional service and readily return for additional work, others have encountered substantial delays, unresponsiveness to warranty issues, and quality control problems that required hiring additional contractors for remediation.

Five Star Roofing Co. is a family-owned company known for exceptional communication, transparency, and customer-focused service, with owner Nick consistently praised for his honesty, professionalism, and hands-on involvement throughout projects. Customers appreciate their thorough assessments, detailed written estimates, and use of innovative tools like drone inspections to document roof conditions and alternatives. The team delivers superior craftsmanship with high-quality materials, meticulous attention to detail, and rapid emergency response, all backed by a commitment to customer satisfaction and reliable, precision work from start to finish.

Magnolia Home Remodeling consistently delivers high-quality craftsmanship and attention to detail, with customers praising the durability of completed projects and the professional appearance of finished work. The team excels at transparent communication throughout every phase, with responsive project managers who keep homeowners informed, address questions promptly, and work collaboratively to solve challenges—particularly valuing their ability to explain trade-offs and alternatives clearly to first-time renovators. Customers also appreciate Magnolia's commitment to staying on budget and timeline while respecting their financial constraints, with skilled trades who arrive punctually, maintain clean worksites, and approach each project with genuine care and professionalism.

Mr. Handyman Tri-County Wayne earns strong praise from most customers for professional, reliable service and skilled workmanship. Customers consistently highlight the company's punctuality, clear communication, fair pricing, and thorough cleanup, with office coordinator Maritza frequently noted for her helpfulness in scheduling and coordination. However, one customer reported a significant issue involving damaged materials that were not disclosed and poor follow-up communication, suggesting inconsistent service quality.

Northkit Roofing earns consistent praise from satisfied customers for their professional workmanship, attention to detail, and reliable project execution. Customers particularly appreciate the team's clear communication, prompt responsiveness to questions and concerns, and ability to complete projects on schedule—with several noting that work was finished in one to two days and sites were thoroughly cleaned up afterward. The company is also recognized for offering competitive pricing, transparent handling of unforeseen circumstances, and going above and beyond on details, making them a trusted choice for both straightforward and complex roofing projects.

American Home Remodeling earns consistent praise from customers for exceptional professionalism, meticulous attention to detail, and transparent communication throughout every project phase. Clients consistently highlight the expertise and responsiveness of team members like John, Nick, and George, who take time to understand their vision, explain options clearly, and address concerns promptly. The company delivers high-quality craftsmanship with fair pricing, reliable timelines, and thorough cleanup, creating stress-free experiences that consistently exceed customer expectations.

Bachman Roofing Company earns high praise for their knowledgeable, honest approach and exceptional attention to detail. Owner Nicholas Sangiuolo is recognized for taking time to clearly explain the process, answer questions thoroughly, and demonstrate genuine care for doing the job right. Customers consistently highlight the company's reliability, integrity, and commitment to quality workmanship. A-Top Roofing stands out for their comprehensive professionalism across all levels—from initial consultation through final inspection. The company excels at clear communication, efficient project execution, meticulous cleanup, and follow-up satisfaction checks, with customers particularly praising their on-time performance, skilled crews, and ability to handle complex projects with precision and care. Lighting Construction is valued for responsiveness, fair pricing, and reliable execution from start to finish. The crew consistently delivers professional, friendly service while maintaining a clean work environment and completing projects on schedule, resulting in high-quality

Majestic Exteriors is a family-owned company praised by customers for exceptional craftsmanship, meticulous attention to detail, and reliable project completion across roofing, siding, gutters, windows, and stonework. Clients consistently highlight the team's professionalism, clear communication, and responsiveness throughout the process, with leadership like owner Tania and team members like Zac K and Nick earning special recognition for their expertise and customer care. The company is known for efficient, well-organized work with thorough cleanup and a commitment to quality that leaves customers confident and satisfied.