Best Roof Repair in Eltingville, NY — Top Roofers (2026)
Top Roofers in Eltingville, NY
Filter by service:
Lema Roofing earns consistent praise for exceptional professionalism, clear communication, and meticulous attention to detail, with customers highlighting how the team keeps them informed throughout projects, arrives on time, and thoroughly cleans up after completion. Customers particularly appreciate David Lema's expertise in explaining materials and offering thoughtful recommendations, combined with the crew's commitment to quality workmanship on roofing, gutters, and related services. The company is repeatedly recommended for delivering reliable, fairly-priced work performed to the highest standards.
"I recently had the pleasure of working with Lema Roofing for a project, and I couldn't be happier with the service I received. From start to finish, they were trustworthy, on time, and fair in their pricing. The team was incredibly professional and ensured that the job was done efficiently and to the highest standards. Not only did they complete the work on schedule, but they also left the area clean and tidy afterward. I highly recommend Lema…" — Aza A.
+1 862-910-4588
Hernandez & Sons Roofing earns consistent five-star praise from Verona homeowners for their skilled craftsmanship, transparent communication, and honest approach to customer concerns. Customers particularly value the team's willingness to thoroughly explain each step of the process, provide temporary solutions, and offer expert guidance on cost-saving options like insurance claims and material upgrades. The company's reliability and attention to detail—combined with competitive pricing and friendly office staff—have made them a trusted recommendation among neighbors and first-time homeowners alike.
"My husband and I are extremely pleased with our experience working with Hernandez & Sons Roofing for our roof replacement in Verona. After seeing the great job they did for one of our neighbors, we decided to reach out. We had recently switched insurance companies and were hesitant to deal with insurance claims because of past issues with rate hikes. When we explained our concerns, Randall assured us they would only recommend filing a claim if…" — Isabelle S.
+1 551-317-4000
Penn Roofing
Penn Roofing is a full-service roofing contractor with over 25 years of experience handling both residential and commercial projects across New Jersey. Customers consistently praise owner Ron and his team for exceptional craftsmanship, transparent pricing with no surprises, attentive communication that addresses all concerns, and a professional work ethic that leaves job sites clean and complete. The company's reliability, accessibility, and commitment to quality—from roof installation and repairs to gutters, siding, and chimney work—has earned strong recommendations from homeowners who value trustworthy, detail-oriented service.
"Penn Roofing did a terrific job on my 3 family building. They re-did my flat roof, updated my chimmineys, replaced my gutter with gutter guards, replaced my awnings , redid my siding to a beautiful color along with replacing all the windows. Plus, other requests I had. Which I am very grateful that Ron was able to accomplish. All my concerns were heard and understood. They are accommodating. The employees are hard workers and perform…" — Rosa M.
+1 973-481-9319
This roofing company earns consistent praise for exceptional craftsmanship, meticulous attention to detail, and honest business practices—customers repeatedly highlight how the team completes quality work efficiently while leaving properties spotless. Beyond technical expertise, the company stands out for its customer-focused approach: rapid response times, thorough communication about what's actually needed rather than overselling unnecessary work, and genuine care in explaining options and guiding clients through insurance claims. Multiple customers specifically note receiving competitive pricing and outstanding value for comprehensive roofing projects, whether full replacements, repairs, or damage restoration.
"We were relieved to find out that a full roof replacement wasn't necessary. A lot of roofing companies in East Hanover might just push for a new roof right away, but this team gave us an honest inspection and only recommended what was really needed. I’ve worked with before, so I knew I could trust their advice. and came out to check for leaks and carefully explained what was causing the water issues. They gave us both the good and bad news, along…" — Virginia D.
+1 862-500-5750
This handyman service consistently earns praise for exceptional communication, punctuality, and professional workmanship across a variety of projects including plumbing, installations, and renovations. Customers particularly appreciate the team's reliability in meeting tight deadlines, attention to detail in cleanup, and friendly approach to service. The combination of experienced craftsmanship, affordable pricing, and responsive customer care makes them a trusted choice for homeowners seeking dependable home improvement solutions.
"Exclusive was the company I hired to install a new faucet for us and a water purifier system that turns faucet water to alkaline. That’s a whole separate convo on why that’s important but I have a lot of praise for this business. Super friendly, affordable & professional. Thank you gentlemen!" — ovan h.
+1 929-249-5253
Customers consistently praise Mustafa and his HMZ team for exceptional professionalism, reliable communication, and meticulous craftsmanship across renovation and roofing projects. Clients highlight his transparent pricing, clear timelines that he follows precisely, and proactive approach to problem-solving—qualities that prove especially valuable for first-time homeowners and out-of-state property owners alike. His commitment to listening to customer vision, offering thoughtful design recommendations, and maintaining an organized, respectful worksite has earned him strong repeat business and enthusiastic referrals.
"As first-time homeowners undertaking renovations, we were initially nervous about managing the process alongside our full time jobs . Working with Mustafa changed that completely. From the outset, he set clear expectations, offered thoughtful, practical recommendations, and mapped out a schedule that he followed to the letter. He renovated two bathrooms for us in roughly a week—an impressive turnaround without compromising on quality. Throughout,…" — Sudhir N.
+1 732-735-9737
Clark Brothers Roofing & Construction earns consistent praise for their knowledgeable, communicative team who guide customers through every step of the roofing process with transparency and professionalism. Customers particularly appreciate their fair pricing for quality workmanship, expert handling of insurance claims, and meticulous attention to detail—from respectful job site conduct to comprehensive follow-up. The company's reliability in meeting schedules, solving complex roofing challenges, and going above and beyond expectations makes them a trusted choice for homeowners seeking both immediate repairs and long-term maintenance solutions.
"After talking things over with my wife and thinking about what’s best for our home, we decided to get a new roof and some other updates. choosing this roofing company turned out to be the best move for us and really helped improve our home’s value. they truly went above and beyond for us, especially when it came to working with our insurance company. if you want a team you can trust and who makes sure you understand every part of the process, i…" — Peter E.
+1 551-320-4000
Clark Brothers Roofing & Construction earns consistent praise for their exceptional craftsmanship, attention to detail, and seamless customer experience from initial consultation through project completion. Customers particularly appreciate the team's professionalism and communication skills—from owner Gregory's thorough explanations and same-day estimates to crew members like Douglas and Chase who handle insurance coordination and deliver prompt, clean work. The company stands out for reliability and genuine customer care, with multiple clients reporting they've returned for additional projects or referred friends and family based on outstanding results and fair pricing.
"From my initial call, working with CLARK BROTHERS ROOFING & CONSTRUCTION was easy and professional. Gregory answered the phone, listened to my roofing concerns, and came out the same day to check on the work I needed. I had some large skylights and other roof openings that needed to be closed up for an engineer inspection, and Gregory made sure to walk me through the options. By the next morning, I received a detailed estimate by email. After…" — Tracy M.
+1 862-329-7000
Avishay Contractors LLC delivers exceptional craftsmanship and attention to detail on kitchen and bathroom projects, consistently completing work on tight timelines while maintaining meticulous job sites. Customers praise the team's professionalism, responsiveness, and reliability, along with their ability to source quality materials at reasonable costs without compromising on aesthetics. The company's licensed credentials in electrical and plumbing work, combined with their thorough communication and follow-through from start to finish, make them a trusted choice for home renovation projects.
"Avishay Contractors LLC were reasonable cost for a bathroom 5x8, in comparison to others, and his staff was extremely professional. They are licensed for electrical and plumbing and have insurance coverage. From the start to finish they would clean up after themselves and throw all the garbage out and send me video of lock up after they left the place, you would not even know they were there. Bathroom from demolition ( completely gutted…" — Branka P.
+1 973-558-0594
Garcia & Sons Roofing Company earns consistent praise from customers for their exceptional professionalism, clear communication, and meticulous attention to detail throughout every project stage. Homeowners highlight the team's expertise in handling complex situations—from navigating HOA requirements and managing insurance claims to addressing previous poor workmanship and intricate roof designs—while maintaining transparent explanations and reliable timelines. Customers emphasize that while pricing is fair rather than the lowest, the quality of workmanship, dependable crew behavior, and genuine care for both the job and the customer experience make the investment worthwhile.
"Where do i start? years ago, my mother had her roof replaced by this roofing company, and they really did an outstanding job. they were very courteous, gave an honest estimate, and showed real respect to my mother during the whole process, from start to finish. at a time when it was hard to find trustworthy roofers, their team stood out for their fair pricing and quality work, unlike others who did poor jobs and charged too much. we made the…" — angie g.
+1 551-270-9000
Why Hire a Local Roofer in Eltingville?
Local Climate Knowledge
Eltingville roofers understand New York's specific weather patterns and choose materials built to last in local conditions.
Building Code Compliance
Local contractors know Eltingville's permit requirements and code standards, ensuring your repair passes inspection.
Faster Response Times
A local company can respond to emergencies quickly and follow up easily if issues arise after the repair.
Typical Roof Repair Costs in Eltingville
| Repair Type | Typical Cost Range |
|---|---|
| Minor Leak Repair | $150 – $400 |
| Shingle Replacement (small area) | $300 – $900 |
| Flashing Repair | $200 – $600 |
| Gutter Repair / Replacement | $150 – $500 |
| Section Repair (large area) | $1,500 – $5,000 |
| Emergency Repair | $500 – $1,500 |
| Full Roof Replacement | $8,000 – $25,000+ |
* Estimates only. Actual costs vary by scope, materials, and contractor. Get at least 3 quotes.
FAQ: Roof Repair in Eltingville, NY
Roof repair costs in Eltingville typically range from $150–$400 for minor leak repairs to $1,500–$5,000 for extensive section repairs. Emergency repairs can cost more. The exact price depends on the extent of damage, roofing material, roof pitch, and the contractor you choose. Always get 3 quotes before committing.