Best Roof Repair in Lake Mills, WI — Top Roofers (2026)
Top Roofers in Lake Mills, WI
Filter by service:
Smith Roofing consistently earns praise for exceptional professionalism, quick turnaround times, and responsive communication—with owner Matt personally addressing customer needs and following through on timelines with precision. Customers highlight the quality of workmanship, thorough cleanup, and willingness to guide clients through complex processes like insurance claims and scheduling constraints. The company's reliability and attention to detail, combined with competitive pricing and flexible payment options, make them a trusted choice for residential and commercial roofing projects.
"Having Smith Roofing replace my roof on my house and my garage was a wonderful experience. Matt is so professional with his business and makes sure the job gets done right. They showed up at my house at 7:00 a.m. and the job was complete by 2:00. They're clean up procedure is exceptional there was not one nail or roof shingle in my yard when they left. I would recommend Smith Roofing to anyone who is in need of a new roof, they don't…" — marianne y.
+1 608-577-6501
Windlickers Roofing and Exteriors, owned by Mike Fabian, consistently earns praise from customers for exceptional craftsmanship, attention to detail, and knowledgeable, hands-on leadership. Clients appreciate the company's competitive pricing, efficient project completion, professional crew, and thorough cleanup, with the owner known for daily check-ins and responsiveness to questions via phone and text. The team's meticulous work, respect for customers' homes, and willingness to go above and beyond have made Windlickers a trusted choice for roofing and siding projects.
"I totally would recommend Windlickers to anyone in need of a new roof or siding. I had an excellent experience from beginning to end working with this company on my new roof and siding. First, I got several quotes from other companies and their pricing was good using the best quality products. The owner was knowledgeable , very attentive and truly seemed like he cared that I was happy with the result. He listened to me, checked in daily and made…" — Julie H.
+1 414-531-1729
Oliwill Construction earns consistent praise for exceptional professionalism, clear communication, and competitive pricing throughout every project stage. Customers highlight the company's skilled in-house crew, meticulous attention to detail, and willingness to work with insurance claims and address any concerns that arise after completion. From roof replacements and siding to skylights and gutters, clients consistently report satisfaction with both the quality of workmanship and the straightforward, pressure-free experience from initial consultation through final cleanup.
"Go with Oliwill brothers! From start to finish Oliver was amazing! Great communication, the crews were very professional, hard working and respectful of our property. Pricing was better than any other estimate we received. Oliver or William stopped by to check on everything as each job was completed. I can’t say enough about how happy we are with our ‘new’ home. Three new roofs, beautiful graphite siding with a silver gable, gutters, new…" — Jame A.
+1 608-576-0075
Isthmus Roofing earns consistent praise for exceptional professionalism, reliable communication, and swift project completion, with customers particularly appreciating the team's responsiveness and attention to detail throughout the job. The company stands out for delivering high-quality workmanship at competitive prices, with expertise in navigating insurance claims for damage repair—a service that has proven invaluable for customers dealing with hail damage and complex restoration projects. Crews are consistently noted as punctual, respectful, and thorough in cleanup, making Isthmus Roofing a trusted choice for both straightforward roof replacements and challenging multi-property assignments.
"New project in Evansville for my son to repair due to hail damage. Beau Murray was willing to take over the job left hanging by the prior owner's contractor (hail damage occurred before closing) so my son could not get a loan till work done. Seller's choice of roofers did not follow up. Beau, having experience in the insurance industry knew how to deal with the seller's insurance company and stepped in to complete the siding and window work.…" — Dave W.
+1 608-949-0533
Adonis Roofing, led by owner Mike Sparks, consistently delivers exceptional quality workmanship and professionalism that exceeds customer expectations. Customers praise the team's clear communication, attention to detail, efficient project completion, thorough cleanup, and willingness to accommodate special requests—all while offering competitive pricing and honest assessments. Mike's humble, competent approach and genuine commitment to customer satisfaction make Adonis a trusted choice for residential roofing projects of all sizes.
"We had a new roof installed this week, and the Adonis team did a fabulous job on the project. The entire process from start to finish was efficient and smooth, with the install crew paying attention to every detail and delivering a quality roof install. We got quotes from 9 different companies in the area and ended up going with Mike, as interacting with him during the sales process gave us a lot of confidence. Mike is a highly experienced…" — Anil R.
+1 262-420-4542
Miltown Exterior LLC, led by Jose, consistently earns praise from customers for thorough inspections, detailed explanations of roofing solutions, and high-quality installations completed efficiently with meticulous cleanup. Customers particularly appreciate Jose's professionalism, responsiveness, and willingness to address underlying issues like ventilation problems and attic moisture, along with his helpful guidance on product selection and design choices. The company delivers strong value, with multiple clients noting reasonable pricing, energy savings from new roofs, and reliable follow-up service to ensure customer satisfaction.
"I have so many compliments to give Jose and he crew at Miltown Exterior llc! First, I want to start by saying how thorough he was with explaining that our roof needed repair. He even offered us a solution to help protect our roof and attic during a November storm. He not only explained his product very well, he offered samples and showed us pictures of jobs he and his team completed. Next, the workers at Miltown were very clean and picked up any…" — Rieth F.
+1 414-326-0049
Thiele Roofing & Construction earns consistent praise for their professionalism, attention to detail, and exceptional communication throughout every project stage. Customers particularly appreciate their responsiveness to questions, expertise in material selection, meticulous cleanup, and seamless coordination with insurance companies on damage claims. The team's punctuality, competitive pricing, and respectful approach to property care have made them a trusted choice for roof replacements and repairs across the Janesville and Rock County area.
"Todd, Jacob, and the team at Thiele Roofing & Construction did a great job for me and my roof replacement. They made the process so easy after the hail damage claim. From coming out quickly to survey the damage & prepare the estimate, to working with my insurance company to complete the claim. They were so professional, and exceptionally tidy on the job. I recommend them to anyone in Janesville or the Rock County area. Thank you Thiele Roofing &…" — Debra C.
+1 608-563-5969
Modern Exterior/Exterior Renovations LLC earns consistent five-star praise for exceptional craftsmanship, professional communication, and meticulous attention to detail. Customers highlight the team's responsiveness, quick scheduling, competitive pricing, and thorough cleanup after projects—from roof replacements to siding and chimney work. The company stands out for prioritizing employee safety, managing weather-related delays transparently, and delivering projects efficiently while maintaining a friendly, professional demeanor from initial quote through completion.
"I absolutely loved working with them. They were able to quickly come out to diagnose the issue and worked with me on a date to start the project. Pricing was wonderful, and they were upfront with all potential complications. I knew going in that the weather would impact how quickly the project could be done, but I wasn't worried in the slightest because they communicated so well. We had scheduled the repair and a few days before, we were hit…" — Eg F.
+1 608-705-7965
Rodriguez Exteriors earns consistent praise for exceptional responsiveness and reliability, with customers highlighting rapid turnaround times—including same-day and next-day service even in challenging conditions like snow and high winds. Clients particularly appreciate Orlando and his crew's professionalism, expertise with complex projects like skylight installations, and proactive handling of insurance claims, along with their commitment to quality materials and thorough cleanup. The team's combination of skilled workmanship, friendly demeanor, and efficient project completion has made them a highly recommended choice for roofing and exterior work.
"After contacting several contractors, I saw the Rodriquez Exterior post on FB. The estimate was within our budget and materials reviewed were high quality. We hired Rodriguez Exteriors to remove the current Tudor style siding on the front of our house and replace it with vinyl and stone veneer. The crew was prompt on the first day, worked 12 hours to remove the old siding. Working 12 hour days, they completed the project in 4 days and it…" — S E.
+1 608-572-1568
MBA Exteriors, Inc. earns consistent praise from customers for completing projects with impressive speed—many roof installations finished in just one day—while maintaining meticulous workmanship and cleanliness. Customers highlight the crew's professionalism, friendliness, and seamless communication throughout the process, from quick estimates to thorough documentation for insurance claims. The company's efficiency and attention to detail across roofing, gutters, siding, and windows have made customers confident recommending them for exterior home work in Wisconsin.
"Highly recommend to anyone! Everyone is great to work with... had roof & gutters installed in 1 day, we were very impressed! Was there with our insurance adjuster to make sure everything was pointed out & our adjuster was very confident with the images given to her on the roof. Next step is to have the siding installed after new windows are in, we are confident we will have the same great quality done when they do! Above & beyond A+…" — K S.
+1 920-253-9144
Why Hire a Local Roofer in Lake Mills?
Local Climate Knowledge
Lake Mills roofers understand Wisconsin's specific weather patterns and choose materials built to last in local conditions.
Building Code Compliance
Local contractors know Lake Mills's permit requirements and code standards, ensuring your repair passes inspection.
Faster Response Times
A local company can respond to emergencies quickly and follow up easily if issues arise after the repair.
Typical Roof Repair Costs in Lake Mills
| Repair Type | Typical Cost Range |
|---|---|
| Minor Leak Repair | $150 – $400 |
| Shingle Replacement (small area) | $300 – $900 |
| Flashing Repair | $200 – $600 |
| Gutter Repair / Replacement | $150 – $500 |
| Section Repair (large area) | $1,500 – $5,000 |
| Emergency Repair | $500 – $1,500 |
| Full Roof Replacement | $8,000 – $25,000+ |
* Estimates only. Actual costs vary by scope, materials, and contractor. Get at least 3 quotes.
FAQ: Roof Repair in Lake Mills, WI
Roof repair costs in Lake Mills typically range from $150–$400 for minor leak repairs to $1,500–$5,000 for extensive section repairs. Emergency repairs can cost more. The exact price depends on the extent of damage, roofing material, roof pitch, and the contractor you choose. Always get 3 quotes before committing.