Best Roof Repair in Lake Mills, WI — Top Roofers (2026)
Top Roofers in Lake Mills, WI
Filter by service:
Resistance Exteriors earns consistent praise from customers for their professionalism, attention to detail, and exceptional execution on complex projects. Clients particularly value Tom's knowledgeable guidance, transparent communication, and the team's ability to complete large jobs efficiently while maintaining meticulous cleanup and care for surrounding property. The company's commitment to working through challenges, accommodating customer schedules, and delivering quality craftsmanship has made them a trusted choice for roofing, siding, and exterior renovation projects.
"Our home roof had hail damage. Resistance Exteriors was initially referred to me by Builder in whom I have great respect for. Then a neighbor insisted that I call his roofer. I was delighted to discover it was Resistance Exteriors again! Dallas Schafer was easy to work with. He present multiple options and helped me dial in a roof system that best fit our budget and aesthetic taste. Once we gave him the go ahead materials and equipment were…" — Scott B.
+1 262-951-0875
The Exteriors Company earns consistent praise for professional, detail-oriented work across roofing, windows, and siding projects, with customers highlighting the team's thoroughness, timely completion, and careful cleanup. Field managers and installers like Don, Bob, and Taylor stand out for their warm communication, willingness to explain work and address concerns promptly, and commitment to customer satisfaction—often going above and beyond expectations. While sales processes occasionally need improvement, customers consistently recommend the company for quality workmanship, competitive pricing, and reliable follow-through on projects.
"Jeremy Arrington, Branch Manager, came to my house, evaluated my needs and arranged for everything to be done. Several windows didn't have a drip cap, the exterior trim boards needed to be painted, re-nailed and caulked. The stucco had several holes in it and the subcontractor Cristian repaired those, even patiently waiting for over a week for the baby birds to leave the nest which was in one of the holes. I had problems with rain overflowing the…" — Steven C.
+1 608-960-7663
Rooster Roofing has earned consistent praise for exceptional craftsmanship, reliability, and professional communication throughout every phase of their projects. Customers highlight the team's responsiveness, attention to detail, thorough explanations of the work process, and meticulous job site cleanup, with multiple reviewers noting they deliver exactly what was promised without shortcuts or surprises. The company's knowledgeable crew takes pride in their work, treats each home as an investment, and offers competitive pricing—making them a trusted choice for roofing projects in the Janesville and La Crosse regions.
"I would like to express my sincere gratitude to Rooster Roofing for their fantastic work on a complex roofing project late last summer. From start to finish the process could not have gone any smoother. Rooster was able to work on my duplex whereby the other half was owned by another resident. My side of the duplex had some previous issues during heavy rain storms and his team was able to correct the issue at the time of install. …" — Bill S.
+1 608-631-0004
Paragon Exteriors consistently delivers exceptional roofing work backed by strong craftsmanship, quality materials, and impressive durability—with customers citing roofs that remain intact after 15 years. The team stands out for outstanding communication and responsiveness throughout every project, from prompt quotes and clear expectations to efficient scheduling and thorough follow-up. Customers particularly appreciate owner Jake's professionalism, honest assessments, competitive pricing, and hands-on involvement, combined with a hardworking crew that respects properties and handles cleanup meticulously.
"I was extremely pleased with Jake (the owner) and his crew. From the prompt replies, fast quote and reasonable pricing to the quick turnaround and install, everything was what I hoped it would be. It is a large investment and I am glad we went with Paragon. They showed up on time and were able to complete my roof in one day which was incredible in my opinion. The crew was respectful and worked very hard during the process. They hung around to…" — Owen S.
+1 262-565-8282
Storm Guard Roofing of Madison
Storm Guard Roofing earns consistent praise from customers for exceptional craftsmanship, responsiveness, and professional communication throughout projects. Clients particularly appreciate the team's reliability—from same-day emergency tarping during weather threats to daily progress updates and hands-on project management—as well as the technical expertise and friendliness of their crew members. The company delivers quality work at competitive pricing while maintaining close customer contact from initial consultation through project completion.
"We had a wonderful experience with Storm Guard for our siding project. The team managed to maintain the design of our custom house while using LP Smart materials. We received support from a team of Storm Guard through out the process: the installation crew led by Jose showed an impressive craftsmanship; Field Manager Kyle checked the progress everyday, and sometime twice a day, and discussed with me for concerns and questions; Gillian in the…" — Joe Z.
+1 608-889-9332
Dry Source Property Restoration earns consistent praise from customers for their professionalism, clear communication, and responsiveness throughout restoration projects—from initial consultation through completion. Customers particularly value the team's expertise in handling complex issues like mold remediation and unexpected complications, as well as their respectful, meticulous approach to both the work and customers' homes. The company is recognized for completing projects efficiently and on schedule while maintaining reasonable pricing and delivering exceptional customer service at every level of the organization.
"We really appreciate the excellent, professional service we received from Dry Source. Every member of the team was clearly invested in ridding our newly-acquired house of all mold and damage that mold had caused to floors and walls. They were meticulous about safety measures and stopping any leakage of hazardous mold or materials from our lower to upper level. The technicians were friendly, courteous, and responsible. They were always punctual…" — Elizabeth E.
+1 608-927-6493
Tip Top Roofing & Gutters
Tip Top Roofing, led by owner Tom Pirelli, consistently delivers exceptional results through meticulous planning, superior craftsmanship, and outstanding communication from initial consultation through project completion. Customers praise the team's efficiency—completing complex projects in one to two days—along with their attention to detail, use of modern technology like drone photography, and thorough property cleanup. The company's reliability and responsiveness, combined with their commitment to treating every project with care, have earned them strong recommendations from satisfied clients across residential and investment properties.
"⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ I can’t recommend Tom Pirelli’s TipTop Roofing Company enough! Two years ago, they tackled a complex project on my 1865 barn—a massive, intricate job that they completed in just two days. Their team handled all necessary woodwork and left the site spotless with impeccable cleanup. Fast forward to a month ago when my rental property’s roof sustained damage. Without hesitation, I called TipTop again, and they exceeded expectations once…" — thomas t.
+1 262-269-9400
Wisco is a family-owned roofing and home improvement contractor praised by customers for exceptional professionalism, transparent communication, and honest service practices. Clients consistently highlight the team's attention to detail—from thorough cleanup at job sites to patient explanations of options and next steps—along with competitive pricing and reliable scheduling. The company stands out for responsive customer service, prompt handling of issues like shipping damage, and willingness to work with customers facing financial constraints, earning strong recommendations from homeowners across multiple project types including roofing, siding, windows, and gutter replacement.
"I needed to have all my windows, trim, a storm door, and my sliding glass door replaced, so I got seven quotes. By a wide margin, Shane from Wisco was the most professional, least abrasive, and overall best in terms of customer service. I already knew exactly what I wanted, and Shane respected that. He didn’t use any pressure tactics to upsell me on things I didn’t need or want. I found their price, warranty, and installation scheduling to be…" — Criss D.
+1 608-563-0542
Ryen and his team at Accurate Insulation Solutions consistently deliver excellent workmanship with exceptional professionalism and attention to detail. Customers praise their responsiveness, punctuality with specific arrival times, thorough cleanup after each day's work, and fair pricing that reflects higher-quality permanent solutions rather than cheaper alternatives. The owner's direct involvement in inspections, quotes, and project completion—combined with the crew's courteous demeanor and reliable follow-through—has earned strong recommendations from satisfied customers who plan to use the company again.
"I've had Ryen and his team out to upgrade my bathroom fan and properly vent it though the roof, resolve some mold in the attic, and do an insulation and ventilation upgrade in the attic and they've done a great job every time. They we're responsive and quick to schedule. When giving a time when they'd show up I was given a specific time instead of a half-day window and when they finished for the day they always cleaned up before leaving. I…" — R S.
+1 262-347-1010
A-A Exteriors (also known as Accurate-Airtight) earns consistent praise from customers for their professionalism, thorough communication, and high-quality workmanship on insulation and energy efficiency projects. Clients consistently highlight the team's responsiveness—from detailed initial inspections and clear explanations to prompt follow-ups—as well as their ability to problem-solve unexpected challenges while maintaining a collaborative, respectful work environment. Customers appreciate the fair pricing, accommodating scheduling, and tangible results, with many noting significant improvements in home comfort and energy performance, particularly on older homes.
"The warmer summer nights of climate change were pushing my 1909 arts and crafts bungalow to the point of uninhabitability, particularly on the second floor, by making it impossible to air out the house overnight. Cue A-A Exteriors coming to the rescue. Hunter P. worked with associates to design a comprehensive tune up for my home, top to bottom, with insulation, air sealing, and proper ventilation. Derek and James led the plan’s execution with…" — A B.
+1 608-467-2008
Why Hire a Local Roofer in Lake Mills?
Local Climate Knowledge
Lake Mills roofers understand Wisconsin's specific weather patterns and choose materials built to last in local conditions.
Building Code Compliance
Local contractors know Lake Mills's permit requirements and code standards, ensuring your repair passes inspection.
Faster Response Times
A local company can respond to emergencies quickly and follow up easily if issues arise after the repair.
Typical Roof Repair Costs in Lake Mills
| Repair Type | Typical Cost Range |
|---|---|
| Minor Leak Repair | $150 – $400 |
| Shingle Replacement (small area) | $300 – $900 |
| Flashing Repair | $200 – $600 |
| Gutter Repair / Replacement | $150 – $500 |
| Section Repair (large area) | $1,500 – $5,000 |
| Emergency Repair | $500 – $1,500 |
| Full Roof Replacement | $8,000 – $25,000+ |
* Estimates only. Actual costs vary by scope, materials, and contractor. Get at least 3 quotes.
FAQ: Roof Repair in Lake Mills, WI
Roof repair costs in Lake Mills typically range from $150–$400 for minor leak repairs to $1,500–$5,000 for extensive section repairs. Emergency repairs can cost more. The exact price depends on the extent of damage, roofing material, roof pitch, and the contractor you choose. Always get 3 quotes before committing.