Best Roof Repair in Lancaster, OH — Top Roofers (2026)
Top Roofers in Lancaster, OH
Filter by service:
Armor Exterior Solutions earns consistent praise for exceptional communication, fair pricing, and quality craftsmanship across roofing, siding, and exterior projects. Customers particularly appreciate the personable approach of owner Andrew Mast and team members like Sean Grossman and Victor, who respond promptly to inquiries, proactively address challenges, and often go above and beyond—from fixing additional issues at no charge to handling minor repairs without being asked. The company's combination of reliable, timely work, professional crews, and thorough cleanup makes customers confident recommending them for significant home exterior investments.
"I contacted a few contractors for new siding bids and had it down to 2. With similar product offerings & competitive bids between the 2, we ultimately chose Armor Exterior Solutions because of Andrew Mast! Andrew answered every email/text/call/question promptly & with a friendly & helpful nature (even when he was sick!). He was able to bring us samples to help with the color choice & pulled a few strings to get us a sample of the faux stone to…" — Kara E.
+1 614-318-2773
S&F Roofing earns consistent praise for their exceptional communication, professionalism, and expertise throughout the entire roofing process, from initial inspection through project completion. Customers particularly appreciate their ability to navigate insurance claims efficiently, handle complex damage assessments, and deliver high-quality work on tight timelines—often completing major projects in just 2–3 days. The team is noted for going above and beyond, offering competitive pricing, respecting customers' properties, and maintaining transparent updates every step of the way, making them a trusted choice for storm damage repairs and roof replacements.
"Had a tree fall on our house in January, called S&F along with a couple other contractors the next day. There's no doubt I made the right choice going with RJ and Jacob. They wasted no time coming out for an inspection and when the time came, got me in touch with the right people to guide me through the excruciating insurance process. Just a couple weeks after the insurance company settled we had all the material delivered and in 2 days the…" — Aaron w.
+1 740-415-4103
Ruffin Roofing earns consistent praise for superior craftsmanship, competitive pricing, and exceptional responsiveness—with crews completing large, complex projects quickly and handling insurance coordination seamlessly. Customers highlight the team's professionalism, attention to detail, and willingness to go above and beyond, including owner involvement in major projects and personalized communication throughout the work. The company's customer service stands out for its knowledgeable staff, punctual crews, and demonstrated commitment to making things right when issues arise.
"We had a massive hail storm roll through May of 2022 and before the storm had even finished it was apparent we needed to have a new roof installed and all new siding. I had heard good things about ruffin roofing and gave them a call instantly. The same day they were on the roof assessing the damage, boarded up our broken windows, and placed emergency tarp as needed. We have a large house over 6000 sq. ft. with a steep roof and plenty of tricky…" — Elisabeth H.
+1 614-398-1124
Innovative Roofing Systems earns consistent praise from customers for their professionalism, responsiveness, and quality workmanship. Clients appreciate the team's clear communication, attention to detail, and willingness to go above and beyond expectations, with most projects completed promptly at reasonable prices. The company's honest assessment of work needed and thorough approach to repairs consistently deliver results that exceed customer satisfaction.
"I recently hired Innovative Roofing Systems and was very pleased with their exceptional service. John was very responsive and relayed us to Wolf who came out the next morning. Wolf was very kind and knowledgeable and the entire process was a positive experience! He was very thorough and went above and beyond our expectations. We thought we needed more work done than was needed, but Wolf was honest and transparent in his communication about what…" — alyssa b.
+1 614-324-9797
Hi-5 Roofing earns consistent praise for delivering high-quality work completed efficiently, with customers highlighting the professionalism and competence of their crews who leave properties clean and spotless. The company excels at managing insurance claims and explaining the process thoroughly, though some customers note that clearer upfront communication regarding coverage details and job completion notifications would be beneficial. Multiple customers recommend Hi-5 Roofing for their reliable, skilled workmanship and customer-focused service.
"Definitely recommend Hi-5 Roofing! From the start to the end. We had initially started a claim ourselves & ran into some complications, but they stepped in and took on the mess! From all the paperwork, to dealing with insurance, to making sure the work flow ran smooth, cleaning up every single bit of mess and making sure we understood the processby explaining every detail to us. 100% reliable, friendly, efficient company" — Maritza S.
+1 614-313-7721
Dean's Roofing and Construction is known for exceptional craftsmanship and attentive customer service, with clients consistently praising the quality of work on roofing, siding, and remodeling projects. The team demonstrates strong communication skills and flexibility, working closely with homeowners to understand their vision while offering expert suggestions that enhance the final result. Customers appreciate their professionalism, efficiency in completing projects on schedule, and thorough cleanup, making them a trusted choice for both small repairs and large renovations.
"Dean Construction did a large remodel of 3 bathrooms. The team is amazing. The quality of their work is incredible and were able to tackle any changes I threw at them. I appreciate how they worked with me, listened to my ideas and also provided honest feedback. I trust them in my home and will use Dean Construction again. My bathrooms are beautiful. Thank you for all of your hard work!" — Dawn S.
+1 740-564-0001
Exterior Improvements earns consistent praise for their professional craftsmanship and exceptional customer service, with clients highlighting their quick response times, attention to detail, and fair pricing. Customers appreciate Jamie and Travis's hands-on approach, reliability in meeting deadlines, clear communication throughout projects, and willingness to go above and beyond—from same-day quotes to proactive problem-solving. Whether handling emergency repairs or complete exterior transformations, the team delivers quality workmanship while maintaining clean job sites and a courteous demeanor that keeps clients eager to return for future projects.
"Jamie and his crew did an amazing job not just improving, but transforming the exterior of our home. They replaced our siding, fascia, soffit, downspouts, and shutters, and even opened up the front porch, which I wasn't sure they would be able to do. They performed all the work right on schedule, for a fair price, and kept us updated every step of the way. The house looks fantastic and we couldn't be happier!" — Ed K.
+1 740-503-3501
Clark Brothers Roofing & Construction consistently earns praise from Columbus homeowners for exceptional craftsmanship, reliable project management, and transparent communication throughout the entire process. Customers particularly appreciate the team's punctuality, thorough cleanup, quick responsiveness to questions, and willingness to handle insurance claims and follow-up inspections. The company's owners remain actively involved in projects to ensure quality standards are met, and their fair pricing combined with high-quality materials like Class 4 shingles delivers strong value for roofing, gutter, and siding work.
"I have called on this roofing company to help with my home in Columbus several times since I moved in. Every time I needed repairs or had questions, they responded quickly and took care of my roofing needs right away. Before a big storm, Wyatt came out and fixed the flashing around my chimney, which stopped water from leaking inside and damaging my wall. He also put on leaf guards for my gutters, which has kept them clear. After the storm, Wyatt…" — Destiny V.
+1 380-333-6900
Hayes & Sons Roof Repair earns consistent praise from Columbus-area customers for exceptional professionalism, skilled craftsmanship, and thorough communication throughout every project stage. Customers particularly appreciate the team's efficiency—completing full roof replacements in a single day—combined with meticulous attention to detail, including proper ventilation installation, comprehensive cleanup, and prompt follow-up on minor issues. The company stands out for knowledgeable staff like Tanner and Oliver who patiently explain the process, offer financing options, handle insurance coordination, and back their work with solid warranties.
"After looking into different roofing companies for quite a while, I ended up meeting a representative from Hayes & Sons Roof Repair. From my first conversation, I could tell their team was truly professional and knowledgeable about roofing. Once I decided to move forward, their project manager reached out quickly to help schedule the job and assist me in picking the right shingles for my home. A dumpster and all the roofing materials were…" — C F.
+1 380-600-8181
RSG Systems Plus earns consistent praise for exceptional professionalism, attention to detail, and outstanding customer service, with owner Justin personally overseeing projects and following up thoroughly after completion. Customers highlight competitive pricing, quality workmanship across roofing, siding, gutters, and related services, and Justin's willingness to go above and beyond—from coordinating with insurance adjusters to providing expert guidance and even assisting customers with financing. The team is known for thorough cleanup, responsive communication, and treating customers like family while addressing complex issues like water damage and mold prevention with expertise and care.
"Wow, Justin saved our home from existing water damage and issues with mold from water getting underneath the siding and behind the windows. He was the 6th company I had come out for a quote and we definitely saved the best for last. I knew right away while he was out for the initial quote, that this was the guy I was going to hire. He is extremely knowledgeable, local to grove city, and down to earth. He went above and beyond throughout the…" — Lyndsey S.
+1 614-906-8069
Why Hire a Local Roofer in Lancaster?
Local Climate Knowledge
Lancaster roofers understand Ohio's specific weather patterns and choose materials built to last in local conditions.
Building Code Compliance
Local contractors know Lancaster's permit requirements and code standards, ensuring your repair passes inspection.
Faster Response Times
A local company can respond to emergencies quickly and follow up easily if issues arise after the repair.
Typical Roof Repair Costs in Lancaster
| Repair Type | Typical Cost Range |
|---|---|
| Minor Leak Repair | $150 – $400 |
| Shingle Replacement (small area) | $300 – $900 |
| Flashing Repair | $200 – $600 |
| Gutter Repair / Replacement | $150 – $500 |
| Section Repair (large area) | $1,500 – $5,000 |
| Emergency Repair | $500 – $1,500 |
| Full Roof Replacement | $8,000 – $25,000+ |
* Estimates only. Actual costs vary by scope, materials, and contractor. Get at least 3 quotes.
FAQ: Roof Repair in Lancaster, OH
Roof repair costs in Lancaster typically range from $150–$400 for minor leak repairs to $1,500–$5,000 for extensive section repairs. Emergency repairs can cost more. The exact price depends on the extent of damage, roofing material, roof pitch, and the contractor you choose. Always get 3 quotes before committing.