Best Roof Repair in McFarland, WI — Top Roofers (2026)
Top Roofers in McFarland, WI
Filter by service:
Infinity Exteriors earns consistent praise from customers for exceptional quality workmanship, professional service, and transparent communication throughout every project phase. Customers particularly appreciate the team's responsiveness—from Anthony's thorough consultations and design expertise to Katelyn's helpful office support and Isaac's attentive project management—along with competitive pricing and reliable follow-through on warranties and concerns. The company's crews are noted for their skill, professionalism, and commitment to customer satisfaction, even when facing unexpected challenges or difficult weather conditions.
"When our roof was damaged by a hail storm recently we called Anthony who had come highly recommended by a friend who recently had their house damaged by a major hail storm. Anthony was professional and tried to help us get coverage from our insurance company- we were declined due to age of the roof - same thing happened to the two neighbors next door to me as well. We decided to go ahead with the roof from infinity exteriors due to their after…" — Kevin R.
+1 608-680-3070
Ace Handyman Services Madison West
Ace Handyman earns consistent praise for their meticulous craftsmanship, attention to detail, and professional communication throughout every project stage. Customers highlight the expertise and personable nature of their skilled technicians—including Todd, Michael, Kyle, Rob, and Robert—who take pride in their work and ensure client satisfaction from initial consultation through completion. With fully licensed and insured staff, a one-year warranty on all work and materials, and office support that efficiently manages project coordination, Ace Handyman delivers reliable, high-quality service across a wide range of home repair and renovation needs.
"Your searching for a handyman has ended. All you need to know is Ace Hardware Handyman service and the man you want Michael Thompson. They are fully licensed, insured, and bonded, and their craftsmen have been background checked. Also, all the work and materials, are backed by a 1-year warranty. Natasha did an impressive job of coordinating and managing my to-do list, thank you Natasha! My todo list: - advise: family room door seal - Repair…" — Vicki A.
+1 608-352-3138
SIMS Exteriors and Remodeling
Customers consistently praise Sims for exceptional professionalism, attention to detail, and responsive communication throughout every phase of their projects. The team—including designers, project managers, and subcontractors—is noted for taking time to understand client preferences, providing transparent cost breakdowns, maintaining organized schedules with regular updates, and going above and beyond to accommodate changes and unexpected issues. Reviewers highlight the quality craftsmanship, courteous and friendly service, and reliable execution, with multiple customers expressing their intention to hire Sims for future projects.
"These folks are absolutely OUTSTANDING! We have done a few large projects (finished a basement, redid flooring/doors throughout the house) and redesigning the bathroom has been the most fun with amazing results. First we connected to make sure what we wanted would be within the scope of what they could provide. It was an easy call that established a good rapport. Then we had a meeting at our home. They did a million measurements and discussed…" — C H.
+1 608-825-4500
Badgerland Exteriors
Badgerland Exteriors earns consistent praise for exceptional craftsmanship, professionalism, and personalized service throughout every project phase. Customers consistently highlight the team's seamless coordination with insurance companies, transparent communication, fair pricing, and willingness to go above and beyond—from managing complex claims to handling post-project follow-ups and unexpected repairs. The company's skilled crews deliver high-quality roofing, siding, and gutter work with meticulous attention to detail, leaving homeowners feeling their properties have been completely transformed.
""Exceptional Experience with Badgerland Exteriors - A 10/10 Recommendation!" We are absolutely thrilled with our experience with Badgerland Exteriors. We needed our house re-sided and re-roofed, and from the very start, they were incredibly professional, transparent, and supportive. They were upfront about the high quality of their materials and the project timeline, and they expertly guided us through the complexities of our insurance…" — Rob H.
+1 877-851-1402
Riedl and Son Exterior Specialists
Riedl & Son Exterior Specialists earns consistent praise for their professionalism, attention to detail, and quality craftsmanship across roofing, siding, and gutter projects. Customers particularly appreciate the knowledgeable sales consultants who provide personalized guidance and visualizations, skilled tradespeople like Travis Dunn and Don who work efficiently and respectfully, and owner Jessie's willingness to accommodate scope changes and add finishing touches. The company is also valued for its local Fort Atkinson presence, reliable timelines, thorough cleanup, and commitment to leaving properties in excellent condition.
"Riedl & Son did a fantastic job with our detached garage re-siding. The staff and sub-contractors were very easy to work with and never pressured me in any way. I needed the siding to match the cedar shingles on the main house. The house shingles are in decent shape, but the garage shingles had rotted away in places and needed to be replaced. I wanted to find a product that matched the house shingles. After meeting with several contractors, Riedl…" — Ellen C.
+1 920-696-9323
The Exteriors Company earns consistent praise for professional, detail-oriented work across roofing, windows, and siding projects, with customers highlighting the team's thoroughness, timely completion, and careful cleanup. Field managers and installers like Don, Bob, and Taylor stand out for their warm communication, willingness to explain work and address concerns promptly, and commitment to customer satisfaction—often going above and beyond expectations. While sales processes occasionally need improvement, customers consistently recommend the company for quality workmanship, competitive pricing, and reliable follow-through on projects.
"Jeremy Arrington, Branch Manager, came to my house, evaluated my needs and arranged for everything to be done. Several windows didn't have a drip cap, the exterior trim boards needed to be painted, re-nailed and caulked. The stucco had several holes in it and the subcontractor Cristian repaired those, even patiently waiting for over a week for the baby birds to leave the nest which was in one of the holes. I had problems with rain overflowing the…" — Steven C.
+1 608-960-7663
Rooster Roofing has earned consistent praise for exceptional craftsmanship, reliability, and professional communication throughout every phase of their projects. Customers highlight the team's responsiveness, attention to detail, thorough explanations of the work process, and meticulous job site cleanup, with multiple reviewers noting they deliver exactly what was promised without shortcuts or surprises. The company's knowledgeable crew takes pride in their work, treats each home as an investment, and offers competitive pricing—making them a trusted choice for roofing projects in the Janesville and La Crosse regions.
"I would like to express my sincere gratitude to Rooster Roofing for their fantastic work on a complex roofing project late last summer. From start to finish the process could not have gone any smoother. Rooster was able to work on my duplex whereby the other half was owned by another resident. My side of the duplex had some previous issues during heavy rain storms and his team was able to correct the issue at the time of install. …" — Bill S.
+1 608-631-0004
Storm Guard Roofing of Madison
Storm Guard Roofing earns consistent praise from customers for exceptional craftsmanship, responsiveness, and professional communication throughout projects. Clients particularly appreciate the team's reliability—from same-day emergency tarping during weather threats to daily progress updates and hands-on project management—as well as the technical expertise and friendliness of their crew members. The company delivers quality work at competitive pricing while maintaining close customer contact from initial consultation through project completion.
"We had a wonderful experience with Storm Guard for our siding project. The team managed to maintain the design of our custom house while using LP Smart materials. We received support from a team of Storm Guard through out the process: the installation crew led by Jose showed an impressive craftsmanship; Field Manager Kyle checked the progress everyday, and sometime twice a day, and discussed with me for concerns and questions; Gillian in the…" — Joe Z.
+1 608-889-9332
Dry Source Property Restoration earns consistent praise from customers for their professionalism, clear communication, and responsiveness throughout restoration projects—from initial consultation through completion. Customers particularly value the team's expertise in handling complex issues like mold remediation and unexpected complications, as well as their respectful, meticulous approach to both the work and customers' homes. The company is recognized for completing projects efficiently and on schedule while maintaining reasonable pricing and delivering exceptional customer service at every level of the organization.
"We really appreciate the excellent, professional service we received from Dry Source. Every member of the team was clearly invested in ridding our newly-acquired house of all mold and damage that mold had caused to floors and walls. They were meticulous about safety measures and stopping any leakage of hazardous mold or materials from our lower to upper level. The technicians were friendly, courteous, and responsible. They were always punctual…" — Elizabeth E.
+1 608-927-6493
Wisco is a family-owned roofing and home improvement contractor praised by customers for exceptional professionalism, transparent communication, and honest service practices. Clients consistently highlight the team's attention to detail—from thorough cleanup at job sites to patient explanations of options and next steps—along with competitive pricing and reliable scheduling. The company stands out for responsive customer service, prompt handling of issues like shipping damage, and willingness to work with customers facing financial constraints, earning strong recommendations from homeowners across multiple project types including roofing, siding, windows, and gutter replacement.
"I needed to have all my windows, trim, a storm door, and my sliding glass door replaced, so I got seven quotes. By a wide margin, Shane from Wisco was the most professional, least abrasive, and overall best in terms of customer service. I already knew exactly what I wanted, and Shane respected that. He didn’t use any pressure tactics to upsell me on things I didn’t need or want. I found their price, warranty, and installation scheduling to be…" — Criss D.
+1 608-563-0542
Why Hire a Local Roofer in McFarland?
Local Climate Knowledge
McFarland roofers understand Wisconsin's specific weather patterns and choose materials built to last in local conditions.
Building Code Compliance
Local contractors know McFarland's permit requirements and code standards, ensuring your repair passes inspection.
Faster Response Times
A local company can respond to emergencies quickly and follow up easily if issues arise after the repair.
Typical Roof Repair Costs in McFarland
| Repair Type | Typical Cost Range |
|---|---|
| Minor Leak Repair | $150 – $400 |
| Shingle Replacement (small area) | $300 – $900 |
| Flashing Repair | $200 – $600 |
| Gutter Repair / Replacement | $150 – $500 |
| Section Repair (large area) | $1,500 – $5,000 |
| Emergency Repair | $500 – $1,500 |
| Full Roof Replacement | $8,000 – $25,000+ |
* Estimates only. Actual costs vary by scope, materials, and contractor. Get at least 3 quotes.
FAQ: Roof Repair in McFarland, WI
Roof repair costs in McFarland typically range from $150–$400 for minor leak repairs to $1,500–$5,000 for extensive section repairs. Emergency repairs can cost more. The exact price depends on the extent of damage, roofing material, roof pitch, and the contractor you choose. Always get 3 quotes before committing.