Best Roof Repair in New Berlin, WI — Top Roofers (2026)

Elegant Exteriors earns consistent praise for comprehensive project planning, responsive communication, and skilled craftsmanship across roofing, siding, and exterior work. Customers particularly value the team's ability to listen to their needs, offer cost-saving solutions without compromising quality, and manage large, complex projects with professionalism and attention to detail. The company's dedication to cleanup, timely completion, and follow-up work has made them a trusted choice for homeowners undertaking significant exterior renovations.

All About Insulation earns consistent praise for exceptional professionalism, reliability, and attention to detail across every phase of their work. Customers—including experienced contractors and engineers—repeatedly highlight the team's prompt scheduling, on-time arrival, thorough inspections, clear communication about scope and costs, and meticulous cleanup. The company's fair pricing, honest assessments, and quality workmanship make them a trusted choice for insulation projects of all sizes.

Immortal Exteriors is praised by customers for exceptional craftsmanship, attention to detail, and thorough quality inspections that ensure work is completed to the highest standards. Clients consistently highlight the efficiency, professionalism, and personable nature of owner Mark and his team, along with their commitment to cleanliness and going above expectations with added features and touches. The company offers solid materials, reasonable pricing, and reliable warranty coverage that gives homeowners peace of mind—though some customers note that communication and project timeline clarity could be improved.

Fox River Home Improvements consistently earns praise from customers for their expertise, transparency, and attentive communication throughout every project stage. Homeowners appreciate Mark's team's detailed explanations, progress updates via photos, and honest assessments that often provide cost-effective alternatives to unnecessary replacements. The company's commitment to quality workmanship, respectful customer service, and reliable scheduling—even in challenging circumstances like weather delays—makes them a trusted choice for roofing, chimney, and related home improvement needs.

Expert Exteriors LLC consistently earns praise for their professional, straightforward approach and exceptional communication throughout the roofing process. Customers particularly appreciate their skilled workmanship, reasonable pricing, efficient project completion, and meticulous attention to detail—from protecting landscaping to comprehensive cleanup. The team's responsiveness to concerns and commitment to customer satisfaction has made them a trusted choice for homeowners in the Menomonee Falls area, with clients enthusiastically recommending them to others.

This roofing company, led by Joe, consistently earns praise for exceptional craftsmanship and professional execution across multiple project types. Customers highlight Joe's reliability, excellent communication, and willingness to tackle complex jobs that other contractors decline, while delivering results that exceed expectations. His commitment to staying on schedule, managing costs transparently from estimation through completion, and treating both clients and subcontractors with care makes him a trusted choice for homeowners and commercial clients alike.

This company earns high marks from customers for professionalism, transparent communication, and skilled workmanship on HVAC and electrical projects. Technicians consistently take time to thoroughly explain diagnoses, options, and pricing so customers understand their choices, and they complete work promptly while maintaining clean job sites. Customers particularly value the company's reliability, fair pricing that matches estimates, and the peace of mind that comes with quality installations backed by warranties.

Infinity Exteriors earns consistent praise for exceptional craftsmanship, meticulous attention to detail, and professional execution across siding, roofing, windows, and restoration projects. Customers particularly value the team's clear communication, responsive project management, and ability to guide them through the planning process while maintaining their vision and expectations. From complex Victorian home restorations to insurance claim coordination, the company is recognized for seamless project delivery, reliable follow-through, and crews that treat properties with respect.

SemperFi Roofing earns consistent praise for exceptional communication at every project stage, with customers highlighting knowledgeable team members who take time to explain options and keep homeowners informed throughout the process. Customers are impressed by the company's efficiency—completing full roof installations with additional work in a single day—and the professionalism of their crew, who approach each job with expertise and care. The veteran-owned company stands out for its reliability, integrity, and commitment to customer satisfaction, with many reviewers noting that the team goes above and beyond to deliver quality results and make customers feel valued.

TightSeal delivers exceptional craftsmanship and professionalism across all projects, with customers consistently praising the quality of their products and flawless installations completed in minimal time. The crew is known for their efficiency, punctuality, thorough cleanup, and genuine friendliness, even going above and beyond by checking on customers after job completion. From initial consultation through follow-up visits, TightSeal prioritizes clear communication and customer satisfaction, making them a trusted choice for windows, doors, and home improvement projects.