Best Roofing Companies Near You in New Berlin, WI (2026)

Smart Roofing has earned consistent five-star praise for their honest, knowledgeable approach and exceptional craftsmanship across roof replacements, repairs, and related services. Customers consistently highlight owner Dale's trustworthiness and fair pricing, along with his crew's professionalism, meticulous work quality, and attention to cleanup and property protection. The company is particularly noted for responsive service, clear communication throughout projects, and the ability to accommodate urgent timelines, including weekend work to address weather-related deadlines.

Four Leaf Roofing & Windows earns consistent praise for owner Joe O'Brien's responsive communication, friendly demeanor, and willingness to address emergencies quickly—customers highlight his availability even during severe weather. The skilled crews are noted for their efficiency, professionalism, meticulous cleanup, and attention to detail across roofing, gutters, and siding projects, with customers appreciating both the quality of workmanship and reasonable pricing. Multiple customers express strong loyalty, recommending the company without reservation and indicating they return for repeat projects.

Infinity Exteriors earns consistent praise for exceptional craftsmanship, meticulous attention to detail, and professional execution across siding, roofing, windows, and restoration projects. Customers particularly value the team's clear communication, responsive project management, and ability to guide them through the planning process while maintaining their vision and expectations. From complex Victorian home restorations to insurance claim coordination, the company is recognized for seamless project delivery, reliable follow-through, and crews that treat properties with respect.

Guardian Home Improvements earns consistent praise for exceptional project management and attention to detail, with customers highlighting how managers like Josh Moore and Nick promptly address concerns and ensure complete satisfaction. The team is recognized for professionalism throughout every phase—from knowledgeable salespeople like Andy who avoid pressure tactics, to installers who deliver quality workmanship while maintaining clean job sites. Customers value Guardian's reliability, clear communication about the process, and commitment to standing behind their work, making them a trusted choice for roofing, siding, and home improvement projects.

Elite Exteriors is highly regarded for exceptional craftsmanship and attention to detail, with customers consistently praising the quality of their James Hardie siding, trim work, and gutter installations that maintain a flawless appearance years after completion. The company stands out for its professional and responsive team—including project managers like Jeremie and skilled crews led by experienced foremen—who communicate clearly throughout the process and complete projects efficiently, often within a week. Customers also appreciate competitive pricing that delivers excellent value, with many noting that Elite's costs are comparable to or lower than competitors while using higher-quality materials and delivering superior workmanship.

Billy Goat Roofing earns consistent praise for responsive, professional service and quality craftsmanship across residential and commercial projects. Customers appreciate the team's knowledge, attention to detail, and ability to complete complex jobs efficiently—from emergency repairs completed within hours to full roof replacements finished in a single day with thorough cleanup. The company stands out for clear communication, reasonable pricing, flexible scheduling, and a commitment to customer satisfaction that extends to addressing concerns on-site and ensuring work meets expectations before completion.

Absolute Home Improvements earns consistent praise for rapid response times, clear communication, and high-quality craftsmanship across roofing, siding, and exterior work. Customers particularly appreciate the team's professionalism, efficiency, and attention to detail—from quick assessments of damage to timely project completion at reasonable prices. The company's reliability and courteous crew have made them a trusted choice for homeowners, including those handling significant storm damage and urgent repairs.

Windlickers Roofing and Exteriors, owned by Mike Fabian, consistently earns praise from customers for exceptional craftsmanship, attention to detail, and knowledgeable, hands-on leadership. Clients appreciate the company's competitive pricing, efficient project completion, professional crew, and thorough cleanup, with the owner known for daily check-ins and responsiveness to questions via phone and text. The team's meticulous work, respect for customers' homes, and willingness to go above and beyond have made Windlickers a trusted choice for roofing and siding projects.

ZP Construction LLC consistently earns five-star reviews for exceptional craftsmanship, transparent communication, and meticulous attention to detail on roofing and construction projects. Customers praise owner Zach's honesty and willingness to find cost-effective solutions—such as recommending a ventilation system instead of a full roof replacement—along with his crew's professionalism, punctuality, and thorough cleanup practices including protective screening and debris containment. The company's commitment to customer satisfaction extends from initial consultation through final walkthrough, with Zach personally overseeing key project milestones to ensure quality work that exceeds expectations.

New Roofs Inc. consistently earns praise for their exceptional workmanship, reliability, and clear communication throughout every project phase. Customers particularly appreciate the team's professionalism, fair pricing, and ability to solve complex roofing problems that other companies couldn't resolve. With a strong track record of on-time completion and responsive customer service, New Roofs Inc. is highly recommended for residential roofing, siding, and gutter projects.