Best Roof Repair in New Castle, PA — Top Roofers (2026)
Top Roofers in New Castle, PA
Filter by service:
Olde Hickory Roofing earns consistent praise for exceptional communication, efficiency, and quality craftsmanship across roofing, gutters, and exterior projects. Customers highlight the team's responsiveness—completing jobs quickly without sacrificing quality, with one roof and garage project finished by 2pm—and their personalized approach to understanding client needs. The company stands out for competitive pricing that undercuts competitors by thousands of dollars while delivering professional results that exceed expectations.
"Wow, just wow! We had the roof for our home AND garage done! The service and communication was undeniably great! We have done some remodeling in our home and have not had the greatest experiences, but Colby has been the most communicative with this project. The efficiency of the team was not expected as they started at 7am and they were cleaned up and out by 2pm!!! We were also quoted $4,500 more by another company. For any upcoming home…" — Dirk R.
+1 724-300-0027
Liberty Roofing Pros consistently earns praise for their exceptional professionalism, efficiency, and attention to detail, with crews completing complex roofing projects—including multiple roofs and repairs—in remarkably fast timelines while maintaining immaculate job sites. Customers appreciate the company's responsive communication throughout the process, from owner Dave's prompt callbacks to project managers who provide regular photo updates and work closely with insurance companies to maximize coverage. The team's combination of skilled craftsmanship, courteous service, and reliable follow-through has built strong customer loyalty, with clients expressing confidence in their work quality and willingness to hire them for future projects.
"I met up with Jim Kelly when we had wind damage in April that left a-lot of damages. The house and separate garage roof both needed replaced as well as various other smaller damages Such as the flashing on the house etc. Jim came out and checked out the damages via a drone👍🏼,so I felt confident with there recommendations Aubree also contacted my insurance company to share their findings with them in hopes of them paying for more of the…" — Michelle
+1 844-714-1748
Ace Handyman Services earns consistent praise from customers for their responsive communication, quick turnaround times, and professional crew that completes jobs efficiently and to specification. Customers highlight the team's expertise and attention to detail, with technicians like Jeff and Liam arriving promptly, explaining work clearly, and delivering high-quality results on projects ranging from repairs to custom installations. The company's combination of reliability, skilled craftsmanship, and friendly service has built strong customer loyalty and repeat business.
"Jeff from Ace Handyman Services did a great job for my husband and I. He built an accent shiplap wall, and, installed a fireplace and a live edge mantle and hearth. The project turned out beautifully. Jeff is professional and friendly. He worked with us to create the project to our specifications. He is very knowledgeable, precise and prompt. He also provided updates as needed. I would recommend him and would have him back to our house to…" — Linda M.
+1 724-374-4257
Serenity Home Services earns consistent praise from satisfied customers for their exceptional workmanship, personable approach, and commitment to treating clients like family rather than transactions. Customers appreciate their thorough communication throughout projects, willingness to go above and beyond—including working on holidays and weekends—and meticulous attention to cleanup and detail. The family-owned business has built a loyal customer base by delivering quality results and standing behind their work, with many customers expressing they would not consider hiring anyone else.
"there is no way I will ever go back to anyone else then these people. the are amazing at their work. keeps you up to date while their there and over text I have never been treat like a person it was always about money. but not with these people the treated me like I was a friend they knew their whole life. I know I'm talking about them a lot. it that they are just as mazing as their work. If you ever need anything done I would not even look for…" — Carrie h.
+1 330-559-4960
Weaver Homes is praised by customers for building quality homes with exceptional customization options and delivering outstanding service throughout the building process. Customers consistently highlight the professionalism, responsiveness, and genuine care of the sales and property management team, with staff like Sue Watson, Beth Hannisick, and Maggie going above and beyond to answer questions and maintain relationships with homeowners. Buyers appreciate the company's attention to detail and the pleasant experience of working with knowledgeable consultants who prioritize customer satisfaction.
"I had such an amazing experience buying my Weaver Home at Forest Oaks. My sales consultant, Beth Hannisick was exceptional. She answered every question I had and really went way out of her way to help me. She is really very special and has become a treasured friend in this process. I feel truly blessed with my wonderful Weaver home and all the great people that work for them. Also, Dave the property manager is great too. He always gets right back…" — Rebecca B.
+1 724-609-5261
AB Drain and Construction LLC
AB Drain and Construction LLC earns strong praise from satisfied customers for exceptional attention to detail, thorough communication, and quality craftsmanship on waterproofing and drainage projects. Customers consistently highlight owner Jason's responsiveness—including same-day quotes and daily progress updates—along with his crew's professionalism in protecting homes during work and delivering clean, well-executed results. The company's fair pricing, lifetime transferable warranties, and willingness to address issues make it a trusted local alternative to larger contractors.
"Jason and his team did a wonderful job on my basement. From the first time he stopped over for a quote, his attention to detail and information provided to me was above and beyond. The pricing was extremely fair and Jason was willing to work with us to make it work. Every day they worked I was sent a text with the plans for the day and was informed of any unforeseen issues. Most of which were taken care of at no additional cost. My down spouts…" — Dustin N.
+1 330-294-8275
I can't write this summary because these reviews are for Diehl, an automotive dealership, not a roofing company. The reviews discuss car purchases, financing, and vehicle sales experiences. If you're looking for a directory description for Diehl as a car dealership, I'd be happy to help with that instead. Or if you have roofing company reviews you'd like summarized, please share those.
"My husband just purchased me a new Kia Telluride from Diehl & it was a great experience! We did 90% of the work over the phone & they were able to get us approved before we ever showed up! Takes the long hours that can be spent at the dealership out of the equation & made the process so smooth. We were able to send over much of what they needed through email & show up the next morning ready to go! Donovan Jones was our salesman - he was great!…" — Ashley H.
+1 724-608-3438
Penn Ohio Roofing consistently delivers exceptional service that customers appreciate across every stage of the project, from transparent estimates and responsive communication to efficient, professional installation work. The team is praised for their expertise, politeness, and meticulous attention to property protection and cleanup, with multiple customers noting that projects were completed faster than expected at competitive prices. Whether handling routine roof replacements or emergency repairs like ice dam removal, Penn Ohio Roofing demonstrates both reliability and genuine care for their customers' homes.
"I recently had my roof replaced by Penn Ohio Roofing, and I can confidently say the experience was phenomenal from start to finish. From the initial consultation to the final inspection, their team demonstrated professionalism, expertise, and genuine care for my home. The estimate process was transparent and thorough. They took the time to explain the condition of my existing roof, review material options, and answer every question I had without…" — Amber D.
+1 724-877-7172
Paul Davis Restoration earns consistent praise for exceptional professionalism, personal attention, and expertise across water damage restoration and construction projects. Customers highlight the team's calm, caring approach during stressful situations—with project managers like Mike and Don providing clear communication and daily check-ins that make homeowners feel supported rather than abandoned. The company's ability to deliver quality work on schedule and within budget, combined with their network of skilled tradespeople, makes them a trusted choice for both emergency restoration and custom projects.
"By the time I reached the contents portion of this disaster, my head was spinning. A pipe burst and my entire basement was under water. The main portion of the basement was converted into my childrens playroom. Every toy that was held dear to my babies was gone. This was not only heartbreaking but to say that I was overwhelmed is an understatement. I had no idea where to begin. Little did I know, I wasn't going to have to do a thing. In walks…" — yanessi b.
+1 724-758-6540
Dave Wiltrout Roofing Company earns consistent praise for professional, efficient work and exceptional cleanup, with multiple customers highlighting the crew's courteous demeanor and ability to complete projects quickly even in challenging weather conditions. Customers appreciate the company's transparent communication about project details and costs, with many noting competitive pricing and quality results that transform their homes. The owner and team are recognized for their knowledge and attention to detail, though one customer experienced a significant service gap with unresolved soffit repairs.
"Dave is an old friend of mine from my grade school days. We needed a new roof and siding, so I reached out. TJ and Dave came by explained everything they would do, in great detail. Later they dropped off some samples and got started shortly after. The price for everything was great and the crews of roofers and siders were very professional and courteous. They did a fantastic job, it’s almost like a brand new house. I would recommend Dave Wiltrout…" — Dustin B.
+1 330-544-3598
Why Hire a Local Roofer in New Castle?
Local Climate Knowledge
New Castle roofers understand Pennsylvania's specific weather patterns and choose materials built to last in local conditions.
Building Code Compliance
Local contractors know New Castle's permit requirements and code standards, ensuring your repair passes inspection.
Faster Response Times
A local company can respond to emergencies quickly and follow up easily if issues arise after the repair.
Typical Roof Repair Costs in New Castle
| Repair Type | Typical Cost Range |
|---|---|
| Minor Leak Repair | $150 – $400 |
| Shingle Replacement (small area) | $300 – $900 |
| Flashing Repair | $200 – $600 |
| Gutter Repair / Replacement | $150 – $500 |
| Section Repair (large area) | $1,500 – $5,000 |
| Emergency Repair | $500 – $1,500 |
| Full Roof Replacement | $8,000 – $25,000+ |
* Estimates only. Actual costs vary by scope, materials, and contractor. Get at least 3 quotes.
FAQ: Roof Repair in New Castle, PA
Roof repair costs in New Castle typically range from $150–$400 for minor leak repairs to $1,500–$5,000 for extensive section repairs. Emergency repairs can cost more. The exact price depends on the extent of damage, roofing material, roof pitch, and the contractor you choose. Always get 3 quotes before committing.