Best Roof Repair in New Holland, PA — Top Roofers (2026)

98 Verified Contractors 4.7 Avg Rating 2,292 Total Reviews AI-Analyzed Reviews

Top Roofers in New Holland, PA

Filter by service:

Sort by:

Weaver's Orchard Inc

4.7(853 reviews)
Open Weekends
AI Review Summary

Weaver's Orchard is a beloved family destination offering fresh, high-quality produce and a full range of seasonal offerings, from premium fruits and vegetables to baked goods and deli items. Customers consistently praise the welcoming staff, festive fall activities including hayrides and live entertainment, and well-maintained facilities that appeal to families with young children. The orchard serves as a one-stop shop for quality local products, though some customers note that lunch options could be expanded.

"Have been a handful of times for the fall festivities and it’s a great time, especially for families with preschool and elementary school age children. Plenty of activities, the hayride is great for the entire family, and the market is wonderful! Fresh fruits and veggies, baked items, and various great finds from smaller businesses. It would be awesome if they had a few more local food trucks as options for lunch are pretty limited, but…" — Super (.
40 Fruit Ln
Licensed - Not confirmedInsured - Not confirmedYears - Not confirmed

+1 610-856-7300

Middle Creek Roofing

4.7(743 reviews)
24/7 EmergencyOpen Weekends
AI Review Summary

Middle Creek Roofing is praised by customers for their thorough initial consultations, efficient project completion, and meticulous cleanup work. Clients consistently highlight the professionalism and teamwork of the installation crews, as well as the clear communication throughout the process—from detailed cost breakdowns to step-by-step updates during work. The company has earned strong recommendations for both roof replacements and gutter work, with customers appreciating the quality craftsmanship and attention to detail.

"Middle Creek Roofing recently completed a project for us, and we’re extremely pleased with their work. They replaced the roof in just a few hours, and while a few pieces needed minor adjustments, the overall job was outstanding. The crew worked efficiently yet carefully, and the cleanup was exceptional—they left no mess behind and even cleared the dirt from the installation process. I highly recommend this company. Property location was 414 -…" — Starlin
336 Stricklerstown Rd
Licensed - Not confirmedInsured - Not confirmedYears - Not confirmed

+1 717-864-8382

Mike Evangelist Roof Leak Specialist

4.7(177 reviews)
24/7 EmergencyOnline EstimatesOpen Weekends
AI Review Summary

Mike Evangelist Roof Leaks earns consistent praise for their responsive, professional service and honest approach to repairs. Customers appreciate that the team addresses specific roof issues promptly—often arriving the next day—rather than recommending unnecessary full replacements, and they provide transparent communication by presenting multiple solutions tailored to each customer's budget. The crew, particularly John, is noted for their courteous demeanor, attention to detail, and patience in handling complex situations like insurance and HOA approvals.

"I live in a townhouse development. The builder did a horrible roofing insulation job. I had to call the HOA to get approval for work to be reimbursed. It was a tough battle, but the HOA agreed to reimburse me. John was extremely helpful and patient with the process. Grateful to have Mike Evangelist Roof Leaks to do repairs." — Debbie H.
1358 Kauffman Rd
Licensed - Not confirmedInsured - Not confirmed✓ 45 yrs in business

+1 610-948-8174

Choice Home Remodeling, Inc.

4.7(160 reviews)
Open Weekends
AI Review Summary

Choice Home Remodeling delivers exceptional craftsmanship and professionalism across door, window, and skylight installations, with customers consistently praising their skilled, experienced teams for meticulous work that leaves properties clean and finished to specification. The company stands out for its transparent, pressure-free sales process and responsive service management, with staff who take pride in customizing solutions to meet individual homeowner needs. Customers repeatedly recommend Choice for their reliability, attention to detail, and commitment to standing behind their work.

"Replaced front door with double doors and rear patio doors with double doors. Choice Home Remodeling was our contractor to do the work. Had 2 door specialists working for 3 days. I call them specialists due to their years of experience and the pride they took in making sure everything was right. Plan on having more work done by them and highly recommend their services." — John F.
550 E Main St
Licensed - Not confirmedInsured - Not confirmed✓ 31 yrs in business

+1 717-354-2003

RAW Exteriors

4.7(108 reviews)
24/7 EmergencyOnline EstimatesOpen Weekends
AI Review Summary

RAW Exteriors consistently earns five-star reviews for their exceptional professionalism, meticulous craftsmanship, and outstanding customer service on roof replacements and exterior projects. Customers particularly appreciate the team's expertise in navigating insurance claims, their responsiveness and clear communication throughout projects, and their commitment to going above and beyond—whether through same-day repairs, thorough worksite cleanup, or personalized attention to customer concerns. The company's combination of high-quality work, timely project completion, and genuine care for customer satisfaction has made them a trusted choice for homeowners dealing with storm damage and new roof installations.

"I did a review on their website but I had such a great experience that I wanted to put one on here also. Anthony was so wonderful to do business with. He made sure we were 100% satisfied and he went above and beyond and worked so hard for us. He was very patient and kind (since I had such a hard time choosing a roof and siding color). Rich, who did our siding and gutters was absolutely amazing. He also went above and beyond and was so thorough.…" — Ta D.
5646 Mt Pleasant Rd
Licensed - Not confirmedInsured - Not confirmed✓ 9 yrs in business

+1 610-568-8836

ABC Supply Co. Inc.

4.7(94 reviews)
AI Review Summary

ABC Supply is a roofing materials and tools distributor that earns consistent praise for its knowledgeable and professional team, with customers highlighting staff members who go above and beyond to answer questions and solve problems. The company maintains a well-stocked showroom with quality products and demonstrates exceptional customer service across all employees, from sales staff to warehouse workers. Customers appreciate the team's reliability, helpfulness, and genuine care in serving their roofing and construction needs.

"Excellent customer service. The folks who work at this supply house make a great team!! when I first walked in I gathered information about some of their products. The gentleman who helped me was very professional and answered all my questions. Second time I met Alan. He also took the time to go over all my questions. If it is important to you to trust a service and have a Go-To then you must do business with this company. Their knowledge and…" — denise b.
2591 Centre Ave
Licensed - Not confirmedInsured - Not confirmedYears - Not confirmed

+1 610-921-9600

Klausmair Construction

4.7(92 reviews)
Online Estimates
AI Review Summary

Klausmier Construction consistently earns praise for their professional, detail-oriented approach to roofing, gutter, and exterior work. Customers particularly appreciate the crew's thoroughness—from meticulous cleanup to clear communication about each step of the project—as well as their efficiency in diagnosing and resolving issues like roof leaks. The company's willingness to work directly with insurance companies and their commitment to quality workmanship make them a trusted choice for homeowners seeking reliable roofing solutions.

"We absolutely loved Klausmair. Mike was so kind and like thorough with explaining every step. The crew that installed our new roof did a great job. We didn’t find any nails or anything in our yard. I also really appreciated that they worked with our insurance directly. They made the whole process easy. We highly recommend !!!!" — Abigail P.
3543 Marietta Ave Suite C
Licensed - Not confirmedInsured - Not confirmedYears - Not confirmed

+1 717-587-3876

Trailway Construction

4.7(65 reviews)
Open Weekends
AI Review Summary

Trailway Construction consistently delivers exceptional craftsmanship and meticulous attention to detail across diverse projects, from roofing and siding to custom additions and built-ins. Customers praise the team's professional communication, responsive leadership, and collaborative approach—particularly project leads who listen to client needs and offer valuable suggestions throughout the building process. With a strong reputation for quality workmanship completed to the highest standard and a track record of customer satisfaction, Trailway Construction earns repeated recommendations and return business.

"Outstanding workmanship and attention to detail! Trailway Construction built an in-law suite (for my wife and I to move to rather than downsizing) with a dining area, a beautiful bathroom and a bedroom. They also rebuilt our deck, replaced two sliding Pella doors, built an outdoor patio for our grills and a second outdoor patio under the new addition. We also had two kitchen cabinets and a gorgeous vanity for the bath custom built. Ephraim…" — Ed D.
2464 Cambridge Rd
Licensed - Not confirmedInsured - Not confirmedYears - Not confirmed

+1 610-273-2328

Why Hire a Local Roofer in New Holland?

Local Climate Knowledge

New Holland roofers understand Pennsylvania's specific weather patterns and choose materials built to last in local conditions.

Building Code Compliance

Local contractors know New Holland's permit requirements and code standards, ensuring your repair passes inspection.

Faster Response Times

A local company can respond to emergencies quickly and follow up easily if issues arise after the repair.

Typical Roof Repair Costs in New Holland

Repair TypeTypical Cost Range
Minor Leak Repair$150 – $400
Shingle Replacement (small area)$300 – $900
Flashing Repair$200 – $600
Gutter Repair / Replacement$150 – $500
Section Repair (large area)$1,500 – $5,000
Emergency Repair$500 – $1,500
Full Roof Replacement$8,000 – $25,000+

* Estimates only. Actual costs vary by scope, materials, and contractor. Get at least 3 quotes.

FAQ: Roof Repair in New Holland, PA

Roof repair costs in New Holland typically range from $150–$400 for minor leak repairs to $1,500–$5,000 for extensive section repairs. Emergency repairs can cost more. The exact price depends on the extent of damage, roofing material, roof pitch, and the contractor you choose. Always get 3 quotes before committing.