Best Roof Repair in New Holland, PA — Top Roofers (2026)
Top Roofers in New Holland, PA
Filter by service:
Soft Wash Exteriors of Downingtown, led by owner Brian, earns consistent praise from customers for exceptional results at fair pricing, with clients noting that soft-washing restores aging exteriors to like-new condition without the cost of replacement. Customers particularly value Brian's professionalism, responsiveness, and knowledge—he provides quick estimates, shows up promptly, and communicates reliably throughout the job. The company's thorough work and genuine customer service have built a strong base of repeat clients and neighborhood referrals.
"In getting ready to put my house on the market I wanted to clean the dirt, mold and mildew built up over the years on the siding, gutters, chimney and sidewalks. Being on a budget, I went back and forth between doing it myself or going with a third party. After pricing out some options I went with Soft Wash because of their professionalism, great pricing, knowledge and thoughtfulness. Brian with Soft Wash was quick to provide me with an…" — Chris R.
+1 484-206-5197
Mighty Dog Roofing earns consistent praise from customers for their hands-on professionalism, exceptional craftsmanship, and transparent communication throughout every project—from roof replacements and skylight installations to siding and gutter work. Owners Jim and Erin are known for overseeing jobs personally, solving complex problems that other contractors have failed to address, and treating customers like family while maintaining expert-level workmanship. Customers consistently note the company's reliability, prompt service, detailed estimates, and commitment to leaving properties spotless, making them a trusted local choice for roofing and exterior work.
"When I first met Jim and Erin, they told me that their goal was to "serve their community". Their price was on point, their knowledge and expertise was impressive and they made a promise to be hands on. For some reason, I trusted them even though I had heard that before (haven't we all). I'm usually disappointed because that is the last time I usually see those who make that promise. Jim and Erin followed through on each and every one of their…" — sarah m.
+1 610-801-1462
Praxis Exterior Wash earns consistent praise for professional, communicative service and high-quality results. Customers appreciate the team's responsiveness—from same-day estimates to timely communication about scheduling—and their willingness to work within budgets and preferences. The company excels at transforming homes with thorough cleaning and expert problem-solving, with Hector and his team regularly going the extra mile, including before-and-after documentation and follow-up walkthroughs to ensure customer satisfaction.
"If you appreciate excellent work and excellent customer service, this is the company for you! Hector, Brian, and David provided superior service! We requested gutter cleaning, and they were on time, and followed up with before and after photos to show us what had been accomplished. We will be seeing them in the spring for a full exterior wash on our home! Update: April 2022 We just had the full exterior wash on our home and our house looks…" — Glenna H.
+1 484-796-3791
Armor Roofing and Renovations, LLC
Armor Roofing & Renovations earns consistent praise for exceptional craftsmanship, transparent pricing that undercuts competitors, and outstanding communication throughout every project stage. Customers highlight the professionalism and personable nature of owner Dan and his team, who manage complex jobs efficiently while maintaining a commitment to cleanup and customer satisfaction. The company's reliability—including willingness to address urgent issues and accommodate scheduling challenges—combined with fair, honest estimates and no surprise charges, makes them a trusted choice in the Lancaster community.
"I usually don't leave reviews for contractors, but, in this case, I felt like I had to. Dan, and his crew, we incredily great to work with! They communicated every step of the way, they got the work done on time (even in freezing weather), they cleaned everything up, and they were all very friendly and accommodating. My neighbors even commented on how nice everyone was. The quote was more than fair (and less than all of the competition in this…" — Bob M.
+1 717-574-2789
Integrity Roofing has earned consistent praise from customers for their professionalism, prompt response times, and thorough communication throughout projects. Customers consistently highlight the quality of their work across multiple services—including shingle and rubber roofs, windows, and siding—along with fair pricing and meticulous cleanup. Led by owner Alex and his crew, the company has built a strong reputation for reliability, with multiple customers becoming repeat clients and enthusiastically recommending their services.
"I had Integrity Roofing out to replace shingles twice that had blown off in high wind. I was so impressed with them that I decided to have them just replace the whole roof since I had another skylight leaking. They gave me a very fair estimate, showed up promptly to do the work and cleaned up when finished. I HIGHLY recommend them and will use them for other projects." — Wendy B.
+1 717-490-2665
Home Genius Exteriors consistently delivers exceptional roofing installations with skilled craftsmen who demonstrate superior workmanship and attention to detail. Customers praise the company's professionalism throughout the entire process—from thorough sales consultations and transparent communication to punctual project completion and meticulous cleanup—with project managers who remain accessible and responsive to any concerns. The combination of quality work, competitive pricing, flexible financing options, and respectful treatment of customers' homes has earned the company strong recommendations across all reviews.
"Home Genius did an excellent job with our roof from start to finish. They came out to inspect the roof and, within less than a week, the entire project was completed—in just one day. We were walked through every step of the installation process, which made everything easy to understand and stress-free. Our project manager, Josh, was great with communication and kept us informed throughout the entire project. The crew was professional and…" — Amanda F.
+1 610-624-8005
Proactive Roofing is a family-owned company praised by customers for exceptional craftsmanship, professional service, and fair pricing on roofing and outdoor projects. Reviewers consistently highlight their responsiveness—including same-day emergency service and proactive communication during projects—along with their willingness to work with customers on material selection and insurance claims. The Stoltzfus siblings are known for delivering quality work that exceeds expectations while maintaining reasonable costs and meticulous attention to cleanup and detail.
"Best roofing company. We had leaking from roof into our bedroom and were in such a bind to get it fixed during the July rainy days. Other roofing companies were quoting $1000-2000 just to throw a tarp on there to stop the leaking. ProActive came out the next day and patched the roof at no charge. They gave me the most reasonable quote for a total roof replacement and we just got it done in November after all HOA approvals. They worked with me on…" — Micah M.
+1 223-264-8237
Priority Roofing & Exteriors consistently earns praise for exceptional communication, responsiveness, and reliability—with owner Dan personally managing projects and responding quickly to inquiries, providing detailed explanations, and delivering work exactly on schedule. Customers highlight the professionalism and efficiency of the crew, who arrive on time, complete jobs with minimal disruption, and perform meticulous cleanup that leaves no trace of the work. The company is equally valued for quality workmanship at competitive pricing and their commitment to customer service, including proactive follow-up with drone inspections and rapid response to weather-related damage, making them a trusted choice for roof replacements and repairs throughout the area.
"Overall experience Priority Roofing & Exteriors delivered an outstanding experience from start to finish and absolutely earned a 5-star review. This is exactly the kind of contractor a homeowner hopes to find when dealing with something as important as a roof. Communication and expertise From the very first outreach, communication was instant and consistent – every call and message was returned quickly, with clear answers instead of vague…" — John B.
+1 484-369-7663
5 Star Exterior earns consistent praise for their professionalism, responsiveness, and quality craftsmanship across roofing, siding, and gutter work. Customers particularly appreciate owner Justin's expertise in navigating insurance claims and his team's ability to complete projects quickly—often in one to two days—while maintaining meticulous attention to detail and cleanliness. The company stands out for taking on challenging jobs that other contractors declined and for their willingness to go beyond the scope of work, all at reasonable prices.
"This past week, we had a surprise major leak inside our house caused by exterior issues during a big rain storm. Justin and his team were recommended to me by a mutual contact. Justin replied to me immediately and began helping us to understand our issue and how it could be fixed with a stone ledge gap / siding issue on our house that caused the leak. Within 2 days, he had Douglas and his team out to fix our exterior issues. Douglas was…" — Rebecca B.
+1 484-699-9453
Five Star Contractors
Five Star Contractors earns consistent praise for exceptional craftsmanship and deep expertise in moisture management and water damage remediation, with customers noting that their work remains pristine years after completion. Clients consistently highlight the company's professionalism, responsiveness, and personalized attention—owners and project managers regularly visit job sites, specialized crews handle distinct tasks, and the team prioritizes customer satisfaction throughout multi-month projects. The family-run business combines meticulous attention to detail with transparent communication about scope and quality, earning recognition from independent third-party inspectors as a top regional contractor for exterior renovation and remediation work.
"We had significant moisture/mold penetration issues throughout the exterior of our home (all sides including the roof). We met initially with Michal Zelubowski from Five Star to align on the scope of work. Michal offered good advice and proposed valuable improvements that we hadn’t considered. Robert, his brother, was our day-to-day contact. Robert was onsite to address any concerns and to schedule and oversee the work described in the…" — CBNS
+1 610-827-1797
Why Hire a Local Roofer in New Holland?
Local Climate Knowledge
New Holland roofers understand Pennsylvania's specific weather patterns and choose materials built to last in local conditions.
Building Code Compliance
Local contractors know New Holland's permit requirements and code standards, ensuring your repair passes inspection.
Faster Response Times
A local company can respond to emergencies quickly and follow up easily if issues arise after the repair.
Typical Roof Repair Costs in New Holland
| Repair Type | Typical Cost Range |
|---|---|
| Minor Leak Repair | $150 – $400 |
| Shingle Replacement (small area) | $300 – $900 |
| Flashing Repair | $200 – $600 |
| Gutter Repair / Replacement | $150 – $500 |
| Section Repair (large area) | $1,500 – $5,000 |
| Emergency Repair | $500 – $1,500 |
| Full Roof Replacement | $8,000 – $25,000+ |
* Estimates only. Actual costs vary by scope, materials, and contractor. Get at least 3 quotes.
FAQ: Roof Repair in New Holland, PA
Roof repair costs in New Holland typically range from $150–$400 for minor leak repairs to $1,500–$5,000 for extensive section repairs. Emergency repairs can cost more. The exact price depends on the extent of damage, roofing material, roof pitch, and the contractor you choose. Always get 3 quotes before committing.