Best Roofing Companies Near You in New Holland, PA (2026)

Customers consistently praise this roofing company for skilled, efficient work completed in a timely manner, with crews who are pleasant, professional, and knowledgeable. The sales and customer service team receives particular recognition for their honesty, thorough explanations of options, and genuine care in addressing customer concerns. However, some customers have experienced significant delays on larger projects and communication gaps that impacted their overall satisfaction, though management has shown willingness to resolve issues when escalated.

Greenawalt Roofing earns consistent praise from customers for their exceptional communication, reliability, and professional execution. Clients appreciate their transparent pricing with no surprise costs, quick project timelines (often 2-3 weeks versus competitors' 3+ months), and meticulous attention to coordination—from permitting and supply delivery through installation and cleanup. The company's competitive rates, generous transferable warranties (50 years on shingles, 30 years on labor), and courteous, knowledgeable team members make them a trusted choice for both roof replacements and gutter work.

Rutter Roofing & Exteriors earns consistent praise for exceptional craftsmanship, attention to detail, and reliable project management across roofing, siding, and window installations. Customers highlight the professionalism and responsiveness of the team—particularly project managers like Shawn McClellan and Chris Edwards—who maintain clear communication throughout each project and handle unexpected issues promptly. The company delivers strong value through quality workmanship, competitive pricing, and a commitment to protecting customers' properties and meeting timelines, even in challenging weather conditions.

Helm Construction earns consistent five-star reviews for exceptional value, offering significantly lower pricing than competitors without compromising quality or materials. Customers consistently praise the company's professionalism and communication throughout the entire process—from detailed estimates and scheduling coordination to daily job updates and thorough cleanup—with foreman Leon and his crew earning particular recognition for their work ethic and customer care. The company backs its work with comprehensive warranties including both shingle and craftsmanship coverage that extend well beyond industry standard, delivering complete roof replacements efficiently while maintaining meticulous attention to detail.

Wright Restoration Services is praised by customers for their professionalism, transparency, and responsive communication throughout restoration projects, with multiple clients highlighting quality workmanship that passes independent inspection and timely project completion. Customers particularly appreciate their honest approach, attention to detail, and ability to coordinate multiple contractors while keeping clients informed with daily status updates. General contractors and homeowners alike recommend their services for mold remediation, fire restoration, and air duct cleaning work.

This company consistently earns praise for professionalism, thoroughness, and attention to detail—from comprehensive inspections and fair pricing to meticulous job site management where crews protect customers' homes with protective coverings and careful cleanup. Customers particularly appreciate the team's willingness to go above and beyond, including responsive communication, knowledgeable representatives like Frank and Joe who take time to explain work and answer questions, and efficient crews that complete projects quickly without compromising quality. Reviews highlight both the quality of the finished work and the respectful, considerate approach the company takes throughout the entire process.

Modify Home Improvements earns consistent praise from customers for their meticulous attention to detail, strong communication throughout projects, and professional team coordination from initial estimate through completion. Clients highlight the crew's efficiency and expertise, along with their commitment to fixing underlying issues—such as electrical and plumbing problems—while maintaining clean work sites and delivering finished projects within weeks rather than months. The company's friendly, knowledgeable crew and comprehensive approach to home renovations, including custom work and thoughtful additions like accessibility features, have made them a trusted choice for kitchen, bathroom, and exterior projects.

B&E Roofing earns consistent praise from customers for their expert craftsmanship, professionalism, and efficient project completion, with multiple clients highlighting the team's politeness, attention to detail, and willingness to go above and beyond expectations. Homeowners appreciate the thorough evaluation and estimate process, as well as clear communication throughout the job, with reasonable pricing and quality work that often leads to repeat business for additional home improvements. While most customers recommend B&E highly for full roof replacements and related services, prospective clients in outlying areas should confirm permitting procedures upfront to avoid unexpected costs.

Elmer's Roofing earns consistent praise for their exceptional craftsmanship, reliability, and customer service—with clients repeatedly noting meticulous attention to detail, thorough cleanup, and willingness to go beyond the scope of work. The team is recognized for their efficiency, completing full roof replacements in a single day while maintaining professionalism and courtesy, even in challenging weather conditions. Customers particularly appreciate their fair pricing, prompt warranty service, and the dramatic improvement their work brings to home appearance and value.

Middle Creek Roofing is praised by customers for their thorough initial consultations, efficient project completion, and meticulous cleanup work. Clients consistently highlight the professionalism and teamwork of the installation crews, as well as the clear communication throughout the process—from detailed cost breakdowns to step-by-step updates during work. The company has earned strong recommendations for both roof replacements and gutter work, with customers appreciating the quality craftsmanship and attention to detail.