Best Roof Repair in New London, WI — Top Roofers (2026)

Home Pro Roofing earns consistent praise from customers for their professionalism, responsiveness, and quality craftsmanship, with Tim and his crew delivering complete roof replacements in a single day while maintaining meticulous cleanup standards. Customers particularly appreciate their knowledgeable assessments, willingness to address any issues promptly at no extra charge, and transparent pricing without pressure tactics. The company's reputation for being properly insured, certified, and reliable has made them a trusted choice for homeowners seeking roof replacements, gutter installations, and related roofing services.

Customers consistently praise Andrea and her team at Roof Enforcements for exceptional communication, professionalism, and unwavering commitment—from promptly returning calls and providing transparent estimates to personally advocating through complex insurance claims. The crew is known for efficient, high-quality workmanship on both small and large projects, treating every job with equal care while maintaining a friendly demeanor and thorough cleanup. Clients appreciate the stress-free experience, reliable follow-through, and the sense that Andrea genuinely prioritizes their satisfaction and outcomes.

The Firehouse Handyman, led by Adam, consistently delivers exceptional craftsmanship and attention to detail on bathroom and kitchen remodels, with customers praising the quality of workmanship and professional execution. Adam is highly responsive and communicates clearly throughout each project, keeping clients informed at every step and ensuring the final result matches their vision. His team takes genuine pride in their work, going the extra mile to exceed expectations and build long-term relationships with satisfied customers who enthusiastically recommend his services.

Everdry consistently earns five-star reviews for its combination of expert workmanship, transparent communication, and exceptional customer service. Customers repeatedly praise the crew's professionalism, punctuality, and meticulous attention to detail—from protecting belongings and explaining each step of the waterproofing process to thorough daily cleanup and going above expectations. The team's friendly, patient approach to answering questions and educating homeowners about their basement issues creates a stress-free experience that builds trust and confidence in the quality of the final results.

Keeney Home Services earns consistent praise from customers for exceptional professionalism, attention to detail, and genuine care in their work. Clients repeatedly highlight the team's clear communication throughout projects, willingness to go above and beyond to honor commitments, and meticulous cleanup—with team members demonstrating pride in their craftsmanship even on challenging jobs like older homes. From initial consultation through project completion, customers appreciate the personalized service, helpful attitude, and thoughtful gestures that set the company apart.

Infinity Exteriors earns consistent praise for their professionalism, expertise, and exceptional communication throughout every project phase. Customers particularly appreciate their competitive pricing, efficient timelines—often completing whole-home projects in just days—and meticulous attention to detail, especially on challenging older homes. The team is known for their friendly, respectful approach, thorough follow-up, honest recommendations, and commitment to leaving properties clean and perfectly finished.

JG Restoration earns consistent praise for their fast response times, clear communication, and compassionate approach to customer care, with reviewers highlighting the professionalism and knowledge of team members like Ryan, Rylan, Anthony, and Damian. Customers appreciate the company's willingness to educate homeowners on processes and explain each step thoroughly, creating a sense of trust during stressful situations. As a local, family-owned independent company, JG Restoration is recognized for genuinely caring about their customers and community.

Hickey Roofing earns consistent praise from customers for their professional workmanship, honest communication, and reliable service. Clients appreciate the team's efficiency—completing large projects quickly without compromising quality—along with their attentiveness to detail and responsiveness to follow-up requests. With multiple five-star reviews highlighting affordability, thorough cleanup, and a courteous approach throughout the job, Hickey Roofing has built strong customer loyalty, including repeat clients.

Freedom Restoration and Remodeling earns consistent praise for their rapid emergency response, professional team, and exceptional communication throughout projects—whether handling water damage mitigation, roof replacement, or remodeling work. Customers appreciate their knowledgeable staff who work efficiently, explain processes clearly, and maintain a helpful attitude even during stressful situations. The company's combination of quality craftsmanship, reliability, and customer-focused service makes them a trusted choice for both urgent restoration needs and planned home improvements.

Feldco earns consistent praise for their responsive communication, professional work crews, and ability to work within customers' budgets on siding and window replacement projects. Customers appreciate their knowledgeable product specialists who provide same-day consultations with detailed options and transparent pricing. The company's attention to thorough cleanup and follow-through on customer requests has made them a recommended choice for home improvement projects.