Best Roof Repair in Shelbyville, IN — Top Roofers (2026)
Top Roofers in Shelbyville, IN
Filter by service:
Beeson Construction earns consistent praise from customers for their exceptional craftsmanship, attention to detail, and thorough daily cleanup on projects ranging from roofing to siding and gutters. Clients particularly appreciate the company's responsive communication, with team members like Brian and Phil regularly checking in, addressing concerns promptly, and keeping homeowners informed throughout the project. The combination of quick turnaround times, reasonable pricing for high-quality materials, and willingness to work with insurance companies makes Beeson Construction a trusted choice for comprehensive home renovation work.
"Beeson Construction replaced my roof, skylight as well as the drywall around the skylight. They did an amazing job. They were quick to get the job started. They completed the work quickly once they started. They cleaned up the mess afterwards and it’s like they were never here. They communicated with me throughout the entire process and handled working with the insurance company as well. I was very satisfied with the end result and would use them…" — Bryson
+1 317-788-9353
Wes Knox and Sons Roofing and Gutters consistently delivers impressive efficiency, completing full roof replacements—including tear-offs—in a single day while maintaining meticulous cleanup standards. Customers praise the company's fair pricing, excellent communication, and professional crew work, with multiple reviews highlighting the spotless condition of yards upon project completion. The team's reliability and quality craftsmanship have earned strong recommendations from homeowners across their service areas.
"We had a very positive experience with Wes Knox and Sons Roofing and Gutters. Our roof was completely replaced in one day! Old shingles were torn off and new shingles put back on by the time I returned home from work! All of the trash was picked up and the crew was gone when I returned home! Thanks Wes and the guys!" — Blair B.
+1 765-346-3679
Paradigm Construction and Development earns consistent praise for their exceptional professionalism, attention to detail, and reliable communication throughout projects of all sizes—from complete renovations and new builds to specialized work like bathrooms and custom features. Customers appreciate their punctuality, clean job sites, honest pricing, and commitment to meeting deadlines, with team members consistently delivering quality craftsmanship that exceeds expectations. The company is also recognized for their integrity and community values, including their willingness to support nonprofit projects and guide clients through complex permitting and building requirements.
"Paradigm Construction and Development is second to none. Whether it’s a complete tear-down and new build or a detailed remodel, their quality and professionalism stand out every step of the way. Their team is friendly, responsive, and truly committed to delivering exactly what’s needed. They recently played a major role in helping a non-profit by assisting with land location, demolition, and building a facility tailored perfectly to the mission,…" — Gene W.
+1 317-674-5031
Holmes Construction and Roofing earns consistent praise for exceptional craftsmanship, meticulous attention to detail, and owner-involved project management—with Ed Holmes personally supervising and performing work rather than subcontracting. Customers particularly appreciate their responsiveness, clear communication through progress photos and updates, thorough cleanup, and ability to work efficiently with insurance companies to expedite repairs. The team is noted for using premium materials, completing jobs quickly without cutting corners, and treating both customers and their properties with genuine respect and care.
"Ed and his crew are fantastic! Ed replaced 5 (yes you read that right!) of my roofs and gutters after a hail storm in late June. He has a ton of experienceand is very detail oriented! He worked with my insurance and was able to convince them to cut me a check to start repairs on the spot. His company uses higher quality GAF shingles than other companies for the included price, and he was able to manage all of the work while my wife and I were on…" — Nick M.
+1 317-432-1465
Bauerle Roofing is highly valued by customers for its quality craftsmanship, reliability, and fair pricing on roofing and siding projects. Customers consistently praise owner Bob's professionalism, accessibility, and willingness to streamline the insurance claim process while completing work quickly and thoroughly—often finishing major projects in just days. The company comes highly recommended for storm damage repairs, roof replacements, and comprehensive home restoration work, with customers noting that Bob is easy to reach and remains involved throughout each project.
"I used Bauerle Roofing many years ago to fix a leaking low slope/flat roof. Bob and crew did amazing work, commented on by many other renovation contractors as impressive. More recently we had a tree fall on our house. Bob has been amazing in helping us with the process; including meeting with the insurance claims agent, and tarping the damage as we decide how to proceed with repairs. Highly recommend and definitely consider this local company…" — Nick R.
+1 317-985-2344
Hoosier Masonry Solutions
Hoosier Masonry consistently earns praise for their expert craftsmanship in masonry and chimney work, with customers highlighting their ability to handle complex projects like historic restorations and complete chimney rebuilds. Clients particularly appreciate the team's professionalism, personable communication, and proactive service—from progress photos and flexible pricing to quick responses on unexpected issues. The company is known for meticulous attention to detail, reliable project completion, and thorough cleanup, making them a trusted choice for homeowners seeking quality masonry work.
"Great local company. Needed a new concrete patio with a historic foundation match for my home in Woodruff Place. Lalo and Erin were able to help me quickly source the matching foundation stones and he and his team took great care while propping up my porch and removing the historic columns brick by brick before demolition of the old porch and foundation. The new porch and foundation look amazing as well as the rebuilt porch columns, to which…" — Frank S.
+1 317-483-0556
Peter brings skilled craftsmanship and reliability to every project, consistently delivering work on time while maintaining a professional demeanor that customers trust. His thorough approach, combined with his willingness to recommend cost-effective solutions, demonstrates both expertise and genuine care for customer satisfaction. Clients repeatedly praise his efficiency, trustworthiness, and friendly service, making him a dependable choice for home improvement needs.
"Peter arrived on time (actually, a few minutes early), and provided a free estimate and assessment of the work. He ultimately recommended a more affordable remedy than what I anticipated. Throughout his visit, he demonstrated knowledge and professionalism." — Rod B.
+1 317-417-3761
Parsley Exteriors
Parsley Exteriors, led by owner Tyler, consistently earns five-star reviews for exceptional professionalism, transparent communication, and meticulous craftsmanship across roofing, gutters, and flooring projects. Customers particularly appreciate Tyler's expertise in navigating the insurance claim process, his daily on-site presence during projects, and his team's attention to detail—from ensuring no debris is left behind to scheduling thorough final walkthroughs. The company is recognized for delivering quality work on schedule, maintaining honest pricing without pressure tactics, and building trust through clear explanations and reliable follow-through.
"I wanted to take a moment to share our wonderful experience with Parsley Exteriors, specifically our interaction with Tyler. When we decided to replace our roof, we knew we had to do our due diligence, and Tyler made that process incredibly smooth from the get-go. From the moment he stepped into our home, Tyler was the epitome of professionalism. He took the time to sit us down and thoroughly explain every aspect of the roofing and gutter…" — Kristin H.
+1 765-698-7516
Above the Cut Restoration earns consistent praise for Adam's knowledgeable, patient approach to helping customers understand their roofing needs and navigate insurance claims, particularly valued by first-time homeowners. Customers appreciate the company's thorough, honest workmanship and willingness to advocate with insurance companies on their behalf, along with their follow-up quality assurance after completion. The team is recognized for prioritizing customer satisfaction and taking genuine pride in their work rather than upselling unnecessary services.
"I cannot say enough how pleased I am with the service Adam and his crew provided. After going through 1 roofing company who left me out to dry before even getting the roofing process started I found Adam and his company through a friend. The patience he took with explaining the roofing process and breaking down my insurance claim (1st time homeowner here), was very professional. At no point did I feel rushed in making decisions on roof shingles…" — Richard G.
+1 317-919-3518
Curry Construction and Roofing earns consistent praise from customers for exceptional quality workmanship paired with competitive, honest pricing—often significantly lower than competing bids without compromising results. Owner William Curry is personally involved in projects, demonstrating strong oversight and professionalism, with his crew known for reliability, punctuality, and meticulous attention to detail. Customers particularly appreciate the company's customer-first approach, responsive communication, and commitment to aftercare service, with many becoming long-term clients who trust them for all their construction and roofing needs.
"Another very happy customer. A huge thank you to Curry Construction and Roofing for the installation of my new window. After speaking with other contractors, I ultimately went with Curry Construction for my install. My decision was based on price and quality of work. After physically seeing some of Curry’s work, along with pictures of other jobs, and the reviews much like the one I’m leaving here, it was a simple choice. My window was installed…" — Wayne F.
+1 317-846-9480
Why Hire a Local Roofer in Shelbyville?
Local Climate Knowledge
Shelbyville roofers understand Indiana's specific weather patterns and choose materials built to last in local conditions.
Building Code Compliance
Local contractors know Shelbyville's permit requirements and code standards, ensuring your repair passes inspection.
Faster Response Times
A local company can respond to emergencies quickly and follow up easily if issues arise after the repair.
Typical Roof Repair Costs in Shelbyville
| Repair Type | Typical Cost Range |
|---|---|
| Minor Leak Repair | $150 – $400 |
| Shingle Replacement (small area) | $300 – $900 |
| Flashing Repair | $200 – $600 |
| Gutter Repair / Replacement | $150 – $500 |
| Section Repair (large area) | $1,500 – $5,000 |
| Emergency Repair | $500 – $1,500 |
| Full Roof Replacement | $8,000 – $25,000+ |
* Estimates only. Actual costs vary by scope, materials, and contractor. Get at least 3 quotes.
FAQ: Roof Repair in Shelbyville, IN
Roof repair costs in Shelbyville typically range from $150–$400 for minor leak repairs to $1,500–$5,000 for extensive section repairs. Emergency repairs can cost more. The exact price depends on the extent of damage, roofing material, roof pitch, and the contractor you choose. Always get 3 quotes before committing.