Best Roof Repair in Tallmadge, OH — Top Roofers (2026)

Pro Con Exteriors consistently earns praise from customers for their reliability, professionalism, and quality craftsmanship across roofing and exterior projects. Clients particularly appreciate their responsive communication, punctual scheduling, thorough cleanup, and reasonable pricing, with multiple customers returning for additional projects. The company's crews are noted for working efficiently, paying meticulous attention to detail, and maintaining a courteous, helpful approach throughout the job.

Winding River Construction earns consistent praise for exceptional customer service and reliability. Customers particularly appreciate the team's expertise in navigating insurance claims—with staff like Kyle and Tom handling adjuster meetings, documentation, and negotiations on their behalf—as well as their transparent communication throughout the entire process, from material selection to installation timelines. The crew is noted for efficient, high-quality workmanship, meticulous cleanup, and genuine care in treating each home as their own.

Customers consistently praise Steve and his crew for their exceptional professionalism, punctuality, and thorough communication throughout every project phase—from initial estimates to final cleanup. Reviewers highlight the quality craftsmanship of their insulation work, noting that the team goes above and beyond expectations by identifying and addressing issues customers weren't aware of, all at reasonable prices. The company earns strong recommendations for treating customer satisfaction as a priority while maintaining the personable service of a trusted small business.

Division 1 Roofing earns consistent praise for their expert handling of insurance claims, with owners Andrew and David Sabota personally guiding customers through every step of the process with transparency and support. Customers appreciate the team's professionalism, quality workmanship, and efficiency—completing most roofs in a single day while maintaining meticulous cleanup standards, including magnetic nail sweeps. Their commitment to customer service shines through in their willingness to accommodate appointments at customers' homes, answer detailed questions, and provide follow-up visits to ensure quality, making them a trusted choice for both storm damage and new roof installations.

Landmark Construction earns consistent praise for their professionalism, reliability, and honest communication throughout the roofing and siding process. Customers particularly appreciate owner Cory and Amanda's prompt service, fair pricing, and genuine care for their work—with many noting they address issues that other contractors overlooked. The team's integrity, trustworthiness, and attention to customer service details have earned them numerous referrals from satisfied clients who value their straightforward, hassle-free approach to home improvement projects.

Radiant Roofing earns consistent praise for its honesty, reliability, and clear communication throughout every project stage. Customers particularly appreciate the company's straightforward pricing without upsells, meticulous attention to detail, and professional crew that leaves properties spotless after completion. The team is known for exceptional responsiveness with remote clients, working flexibly within budgets, and delivering quality craftsmanship that customers trust for all their roofing needs.

Customers consistently praise Mateosgutters for their responsiveness and professionalism, with multiple reviewers highlighting same-day or next-day service availability and thorough communication throughout the process. The team is noted for their expertise in identifying issues like wood rot, explaining work clearly to homeowners, and delivering quality results on gutter cleaning and maintenance jobs. However, one customer reported significant concerns with a coping installation project, citing poor workmanship, lack of follow-up, and unresponsive customer service when issues arose.

Rob Walsh and his roofing team consistently earn praise for exceptional communication, reliability, and meticulous attention to detail throughout every project phase. Customers appreciate their professional craftsmanship, competitive pricing, proactive recommendations (such as proper ventilation solutions), careful property protection, and thorough cleanup—all backed by the owner's commitment to standing behind his work as a local business. The crew's punctuality, efficiency, and genuine respect for customers' homes have made them a trusted choice for roof replacements and repairs.

Topline Roofing consistently delivers high-quality work at competitive prices, with customers praising their detailed quotes, superior materials (such as thicker sheeting), and efficient project completion. Owner David and his crew are noted for exceptional professionalism, responsiveness, and clear communication throughout every phase of the project, from initial estimate to final inspection and cleanup. Customers across residential and commercial projects recommend Topline for their reliability, attention to detail, and willingness to work with financing options to meet client needs.

Hershberger Brothers Roofing consistently delivers exceptional craftsmanship and professionalism, with customers praising their attention to detail, efficient teamwork, and ability to complete projects in a single day. The company stands out for competitive pricing, transparent communication about potential costs, and thorough cleanup—including magnetic nail sweeps and meticulous site restoration. Clients repeatedly recommend them for their reliability, quality workmanship, and the care taken to protect landscaping during projects.