Best Roof Repair in West Islip, NY — Top Roofers (2026)
Top Roofers in West Islip, NY
Filter by service:
One Call Construction, led by owner Mike and crew member Maycol, consistently delivers exceptional results across roofing and general contracting projects. Customers praise their attention to detail, punctuality, and efficiency—including completing a full roof replacement in just one and a half days—along with their professionalism, cleanliness, and excellent communication throughout projects. With years of satisfied customers and strong word-of-mouth recommendations, the team is known for being honest, trustworthy, and capable of handling diverse trades from roofing and electrical to plumbing and tile work.
"Mike and his team did a fantastic job repairing several rooms in our home. They paid close attention to detail and ensured each part of the job was completed to satisfaction. Communication was excellent and they were prompt. They made sure work areas were left clean and discarded all waste. I highly recommend One Call Construction and plan to use them for future projects." — Carol O.
+1 516-236-8891
Lucky Star Roofing consistently earns praise from customers for their professional workmanship, attention to detail, and transparent communication throughout every project phase. Owner Rob and his team are known for fair pricing, quick responsiveness, and meticulous cleanup, delivering high-quality results on roofing, gutter replacement, and waterproofing work. Customers repeatedly highlight their reliability and peace of mind, with multiple reviewers recommending them without hesitation for any roofing or waterproofing needs.
"I had an incredible experience with Lucky Stars Roofing! The entire process was seamless, from the initial consultation to the final inspection. Their team was friendly, professional, and highly skilled, ensuring that every detail of the job was handled with care. What really stood out was their dedication to quality and transparency. They kept me updated every step of the way, and there were no surprises when it came to the cost or timeline. My…" — Fiona C.
+1 646-767-6531
Customers consistently praise Brian and his team at Accessible Remodeling for exceptional craftsmanship, meticulous attention to detail, and genuine commitment to client satisfaction across diverse projects ranging from kitchens and bathrooms to custom carpentry and electrical work. Reviewers highlight their professionalism, reliability, and transparent communication—particularly Brian's practice of thoroughly explaining project scope, providing pros and cons of options, and remaining present throughout the work to ensure quality results. The team's trustworthiness, willingness to accommodate changes, and ability to deliver projects on time and often ahead of schedule make them a standout choice for homeowners seeking a contractor who treats their vision with care and precision.
"10/10. Brian and his team exceeded our expectations on a variety of projects, including installing new basement wood floors, updating ceilings, creating a custom reading nook, designing a beautiful custom library, adding a kitchen backsplash, and building a brand-new fireplace. Their craftsmanship and attention to detail are outstanding, and we wouldn’t trust anyone else for future projects. The electrical team, led by Keith and Alex, was…" — Carolyn V.
+1 631-505-3366
SWJ Siding and Roofing earns consistent praise for exceptional workmanship, with customers highlighting perfectly aligned siding, professionally finished details, and meticulous attention to cleanliness throughout projects. The team stands out for professionalism and reliability—from competitive, transparent estimates and punctual arrivals to efficient work and responsive follow-up service—making the entire process smooth and stress-free. Customers particularly appreciate the knowledgeable and honest sales team and crew members who take clear pride in customer satisfaction and quality results.
"I couldn’t be happier with the work this siding and roofing company did on my home. The whole process was smooth and professional from start to finish, with a fair and transparent estimate and very competitive pricing for the quality delivered. The crew showed up on time, worked efficiently, and paid close attention to detail — the siding looks perfectly aligned and the roof installation was done with real care. They kept the area clean…" — Daniel Y.
+1 631-913-5005
Customers consistently praise Solarroof NY for their knowledgeable team, quality workmanship, and competitive pricing on roofing and solar services, with several clients highlighting quick, clean installations completed on time without hidden costs or delays. Those satisfied with the company appreciate their professionalism and ability to explain the benefits of solar energy, with clients reporting noticeable reductions in power costs and projects completed to the highest standard. However, potential customers should be aware of communication concerns, as some have reported difficulty reaching promised follow-ups from specific departments despite initial responsiveness.
"Absolutely satisfied with Solaroof NY! The installation was quick and clean, and their customer service was outstanding. I love how they helped me understand the benefits of solar energy. I’m already seeing a reduction in my power costs — worth every penny!" — Ashok K.
+1 516-744-0300
Metro Roofing earns consistent praise from customers for Anthony's honest assessments, transparent communication throughout projects, and fair pricing that avoids unnecessary upselling. Clients appreciate the crew's professionalism, efficiency, and meticulous attention to detail—from keeping work areas spotless to providing photo updates and solving longstanding problems like hard-to-find leaks. The company's reliability and quality craftsmanship have made them customers' trusted, go-to roofing choice for both repairs and installations.
"Anthony and Metro Roofing were/are excellent. From our first meeting, he was going over my roofs condition and laying out all the options to repair it and up to the completion, he was always in contact and giving updates via text and pictures. Very honest and reliable. Never doubted his professionalism. Now, My roof looks perfect because of Anthony and his crew at Metro Roofing. I will definitely recommend them." — Auntara T.
+1 347-748-2500
Thomas James Roofing is a family-owned business renowned for exceptional craftsmanship, professionalism, and transparent communication throughout every project. Customers consistently praise owner Thomas James and his team for their meticulous attention to detail, timely completion, thorough cleanup, and personalized service—with Thomas often visiting job sites to ensure customer satisfaction and addressing concerns promptly. The company's reliability, fair pricing, and commitment to standing behind their work have earned strong recommendations, with many customers becoming repeat clients and referring friends and neighbors.
"My neighbor recommended Thomas James Roofing as she had extensive work done on her home and was overwhelmingly satisfied. A friend of hers recommended this company. We had seen the workers working on our neighbors home and observed that they were timely, neat, organized, focused and friendly (shout out to Hector). We inquired about our own possible roofing issue due to a perpetual ceiling leak on the top floor. We had received several estimates…" — Tziporah Z.
+1 718-416-5255
Ideal Siding earns consistent praise from customers for exceptional craftsmanship, attention to detail, and strong project management across jobs of all sizes. Clients particularly value the team's excellent communication, with responsive leadership from owner Ian and clear updates throughout projects, along with competitive pricing that reflects the quality of work delivered. Whether handling complete home re-siding, repairs, or custom work like porticos, Ideal Siding consistently exceeds customer expectations and builds lasting relationships through professionalism and genuine investment in each project's success.
"Update- March 2025 I recently worked with Ideal Siding again for another siding replacement project. This time, they also helped me design and build a modern portico for my home, and the results are incredible! From start to finish, Ian was truly invested in bringing my vision to life. He provided expert design guidance and explained what would and wouldn’t work for the new portico. The craftsmanship is top-notch, and the attention to detail…" — Tamika C.
+1 914-928-2631
J&D Construction earns consistent praise from customers for their professionalism, attention to detail, and reliable communication throughout projects of all sizes—from basement remodeling to major home renovations. Clients particularly appreciate the team's efficiency in meeting deadlines and budgets while maintaining high craftsmanship standards and respect for their properties. With a strong track record of keeping customers informed and accommodating to their needs, J&D Construction is a dependable choice for homeowners seeking quality construction work delivered with integrity and skill.
"I recently had the pleasure of working with J&D Construction for a major home renovation, and I could not be more impressed with their work. From the initial consultation to the final touches, the team was professional, efficient, and highly skilled. James was attentive and kept me updated throughout the entire process, ensuring that my vision was realized while keeping the project within budget and on schedule. The crew was always respectful of…" — Vanessa B.
+1 516-668-7488
Clearview Roof and Siding earns consistent praise from customers for their exceptional professionalism, quality craftsmanship, and fair pricing on projects ranging from repairs to full roof installations. Customers particularly appreciate the company's integrity and long-term reliability—the owner has honored warranties years after completion and stood by his word without hesitation. The team is known for being responsive, adaptable to unexpected issues, and respectful in their work, creating a stress-free experience that keeps customers coming back and recommending them to others.
"When you hire a contractor you hope that the job is done correctly and when it is you also hope if anything happens that the warranty is honored. We had Clearview install a full roof and shingles 11 years ago. Recently we had a problem with a large group of shingles. Thomas, the Field Manager came over and inspected the roof. He was a big help in the process. He told Chris, the GM about it. After Chris reviewed the photos and had conversations…" — Mike B.
+1 631-827-7088
Why Hire a Local Roofer in West Islip?
Local Climate Knowledge
West Islip roofers understand New York's specific weather patterns and choose materials built to last in local conditions.
Building Code Compliance
Local contractors know West Islip's permit requirements and code standards, ensuring your repair passes inspection.
Faster Response Times
A local company can respond to emergencies quickly and follow up easily if issues arise after the repair.
Typical Roof Repair Costs in West Islip
| Repair Type | Typical Cost Range |
|---|---|
| Minor Leak Repair | $150 – $400 |
| Shingle Replacement (small area) | $300 – $900 |
| Flashing Repair | $200 – $600 |
| Gutter Repair / Replacement | $150 – $500 |
| Section Repair (large area) | $1,500 – $5,000 |
| Emergency Repair | $500 – $1,500 |
| Full Roof Replacement | $8,000 – $25,000+ |
* Estimates only. Actual costs vary by scope, materials, and contractor. Get at least 3 quotes.
FAQ: Roof Repair in West Islip, NY
Roof repair costs in West Islip typically range from $150–$400 for minor leak repairs to $1,500–$5,000 for extensive section repairs. Emergency repairs can cost more. The exact price depends on the extent of damage, roofing material, roof pitch, and the contractor you choose. Always get 3 quotes before committing.