Best Roof Repair in Bay Shore, NY — Top Roofers (2026)
Top Roofers in Bay Shore, NY
Filter by service:
Elite Restoration earns consistent five-star praise for their quick response times, professional expertise, and transparent communication throughout water damage, mold remediation, and restoration projects. Customers particularly appreciate the team's thorough attention to detail, efficiency, and genuine care in treating homes as their own, with named team members like Dawid, David, and Chris going above and beyond—including cost-saving advice and after-hours support. From initial inspection through final completion, the company consistently delivers high-quality workmanship while maintaining a courteous, knowledgeable approach that leaves customers with peace of mind and homes restored to excellent condition.
"I am extremely happy that I chose to go with Elite Restoration. Their entire team from start to finish was knowledgeable, professional, and treated my home with care. Chris did our initial inspection and made sure the overall project went smoothly. He went out of his way to walk us through our various options and help us save money, as our insurance wasn't covering the project. He even showed up late one evening to help with a surprise…" — David F.
+1 631-567-0070
Life Restoration Inc, led by owner Walter Maldonado, is praised by customers for exceptional professionalism, quality craftsmanship, and transparent communication throughout every project. Reviewers consistently highlight the company's attention to detail, reliable execution, and willingness to go above and beyond—from providing video documentation of roof damage to collaborating extensively on design choices and working efficiently to complete jobs on schedule. Licensed in Westchester County, the company has earned a reputation for reasonable pricing, friendly service, and standing behind their work on roofing and siding projects.
"Life Restoration Inc is one of the best Their material is pristine, the workers are excellent The leader Mr Walter Maldonado is by far one of the best I have ever seen This company works with people for people They stand by their name Life Restoration Inc live up to their name! Hire them to do roofing and siding you will not regret it!! They are licensed in Westchester County!!!!" — Monique J.
+1 516-205-7287
All Island Pro Roofing & Chimney earns consistent praise from Long Island customers for exceptional craftsmanship, professionalism, and responsiveness. Clients particularly appreciate their quick turnaround times (often completing jobs same-day), transparent communication, fair pricing without hidden costs, and meticulous attention to detail—from quality workmanship to thorough cleanup. The team's combination of reliability, pride in their work, and genuine care for customer satisfaction sets them apart in a competitive market.
"Joe from All Island Pro was exceptional! Very responsive and reasonably priced, the crew from All Island Pro did a great job repairing a portion of my roof that was leaking. The crew was neat, efficient and did a quality job - all within one day. Within 48 hours of my calling, Joe had a crew on site to begin and complete the job - same day. After the work was done, clean-up was very thorough with not a stitch of debris left on the lawn. I highly…" — Vincent S.
+1 631-874-6100
Sunrise Roofing and Chimney earns consistent praise for exceptional craftsmanship, professionalism, and responsive customer service. Customers highlight the company's efficiency, attention to detail, and clean work practices, along with transparent communication and fair pricing throughout projects. The team's friendly, hardworking approach and willingness to address questions without unexpected upsells make them a trusted choice for roofing, chimney, and deck work.
"Fantastic Deck construction: My wife and I decided to contract Sunrise Roofing to replace our 30 year old deck at our home in Nesconset. Shefield was a “No Nonsense” sales person and did a great job explaining the process and detailing the costs so we could easily understand. He gave us a start date and 3 days before that date, we received a courtesy call to let us know that the crew will be coming as scheduled. Ramush and his crew were very…" — Russell G.
+1 631-657-5059
Spray Foam Insulation USA earns consistent praise for its professionalism, expertise, and quality craftsmanship across every phase of projects—from initial consultation through completion. Customers particularly value the company's knowledgeable team, competitive pricing, and meticulous attention to detail, with multiple reviewers noting spotless work sites and outstanding results even on complex jobs. Owner Jake and team member Davona are highlighted for their client-first approach, responsiveness, and ability to deliver exceptional service that customers enthusiastically recommend to others.
"I vetted three different companies and met with each of their executives before deciding to go with Jake and Spray Foam Insulation USA to do the attic of our house. While cost was an important consideration, so was competency, and Jake was both the most cost effective and competent of all three potential suitors. This was not an easy job. We have a very, very large house and an exceptionally large attic with many crawl spaces that his guys…" — Demetri
+1 516-216-4222
True Restorations is a water damage restoration company that earns consistent praise for their rapid response, expert handling of complex situations, and exceptional professionalism from initial assessment through completion. Customers particularly appreciate their thorough communication—including detailed insurance documentation, direct coordination with insurance companies, and follow-up support during stressful situations. The team is noted for their reliability, cleanliness, and knowledgeable approach, with staff members who demonstrate genuine care in helping homeowners navigate emergencies and achieve quality repairs.
"Over the New Years holiday my newly purchased home endured a sewage overflow blockage causing water in my finished basement damaging carpets, padding, walls, closets, and personal items. Not knowing what to I do rushed to purchase a shock vac, in my underperforming attempt to self mitigate. Needless to say, I needed professional help. I was highly refered to True Restoration, to my surprise Elias and Josh representing the company showed on a…" — Michael A.
+1 631-757-0212
Payless Roofing and Gutters is consistently praised by customers for meticulous craftsmanship, attention to detail, and efficient project completion. Clients appreciate the owner Geni's expertise and clear communication throughout the process, from initial estimates to final inspection, as well as the crew's professionalism and thorough cleanup. The company is noted for responsiveness, reliable scheduling, and delivering high-quality results that meet or exceed building codes while transforming properties inside and out.
"Geni the owner knows his stuff and is very nice to work with. He explains everything that needs to be done and how it should work. We had the entire roof replaced. New plywood, shingles, and a new chimney housing installed. They came 7am sharp and finished at 3pm. Crew worked efficiently and cleaned up after. Roof is now up to code and looks great." — Mike Z.
+1 631-572-7070
Total Home Construction earns consistent five-star praise for delivering high-quality workmanship and outstanding professionalism across roofing, siding, renovations, and kitchen remodeling projects. Customers particularly appreciate owner Paul's clear communication and responsiveness throughout projects, along with his team's efficiency, courtesy, and commitment to completing work exactly as agreed—with several reviewers noting the company's dedication to customer care extends well beyond project completion. The combination of meticulous attention to detail, premium materials, and reliable follow-up service has made Total Home Construction a trusted choice for homeowners seeking contractors who stand behind their work.
"We hired Total Construction to replace the siding on our home, and they exceeded all expectations. The team was professional, courteous, and efficient—they got the job done quickly without cutting any corners. The quality of the work is outstanding, and our home looks fantastic. What really stood out was their commitment to service even after the project was completed. I had a few follow-up questions and minor concerns, and they continued to be…" — Sung L.
+1 631-421-4747
Handymen Express is a highly regarded contractor known for exceptional craftsmanship and responsive communication throughout every project. Customers consistently praise the team's professionalism, reliability, and ability to deliver quality work on time and within budget, from complex renovations involving masonry and structural work to specialized installations. John and his team stand out for their responsiveness, attention to detail, and willingness to go above and beyond—earning repeat customers who trust them with everything from outdoor kitchens to comprehensive home restoration projects.
"I had an amazing experience working with John Keffas and his team. The team did the following for us over a 10 day period: - Made our decrepit broken front stoop look like new, including a new railing - Performed impeccable brick pointing work on the side/back of our house of our house - Made a water-damaged den with moldy sheetrock, holes in the wall, etc look brand new - Replaced a cracked window with a new Andersen picture frame window -…" — G V.
+1 516-924-2400
Clearview Roofing Services consistently earns high marks for the professionalism, knowledge, and personable approach of its team, particularly leadership that takes time to understand each customer's needs and answer questions thoroughly. Customers praise the crew's reliability and efficiency, noting that projects run smoothly from start to finish with punctual, organized work and thorough cleanup. The company stands out for its honest recommendations, fair pricing, and genuine commitment to quality—with team members going above and beyond to ensure customer satisfaction and long-term peace of mind.
"We were recommended to look into Clearview Roofing Services, and we’re very glad we did. Eric was a pleasure to work with from the start. His recommendations were invaluable in helping my wife and me feel comfortable moving forward with the project. He was never pushy and was always available to answer any questions we had along the way. On the day of the project, George, the foreman, was fantastic. He managed the entire process—from preparation…" — Rijo M.
+1 516-767-2000
Why Hire a Local Roofer in Bay Shore?
Local Climate Knowledge
Bay Shore roofers understand New York's specific weather patterns and choose materials built to last in local conditions.
Building Code Compliance
Local contractors know Bay Shore's permit requirements and code standards, ensuring your repair passes inspection.
Faster Response Times
A local company can respond to emergencies quickly and follow up easily if issues arise after the repair.
Typical Roof Repair Costs in Bay Shore
| Repair Type | Typical Cost Range |
|---|---|
| Minor Leak Repair | $150 – $400 |
| Shingle Replacement (small area) | $300 – $900 |
| Flashing Repair | $200 – $600 |
| Gutter Repair / Replacement | $150 – $500 |
| Section Repair (large area) | $1,500 – $5,000 |
| Emergency Repair | $500 – $1,500 |
| Full Roof Replacement | $8,000 – $25,000+ |
* Estimates only. Actual costs vary by scope, materials, and contractor. Get at least 3 quotes.
FAQ: Roof Repair in Bay Shore, NY
Roof repair costs in Bay Shore typically range from $150–$400 for minor leak repairs to $1,500–$5,000 for extensive section repairs. Emergency repairs can cost more. The exact price depends on the extent of damage, roofing material, roof pitch, and the contractor you choose. Always get 3 quotes before committing.