Best Roofing Companies Near You in Bay Shore, NY (2026)
Top Roofers in Bay Shore, NY
Filter by service:
Panther Home Improvements earns consistent praise for exceptional craftsmanship, transparent communication, and reliable project completion. Customers highlight owner Glenn's personal attention throughout projects, the team's meticulous attention to detail, fair pricing without upselling, and professional crews who arrive on time, clean up daily, and take pride in their work. The company's ability to handle complex exterior renovations—including roofing, siding, windows, gutters, and masonry—while managing customer concerns and delivering results that exceed expectations makes them a trusted choice for homeowners.
"Panther was recommended by a friend who had a great experience, and we’re happy to say we had the same. After a year of feeling overwhelmed by wildly different quotes & information from other companies, we were about ready to give up on our window and siding project. Glenn walked us through everything clearly, without any fluff or pressure. The quote came in right where we needed it to be, and they assured us they’d finish before a large…" — Cassandra
+1 516-895-8300
Victory Home Remodeling consistently earns praise from customers for their exceptional craftsmanship, transparent communication, and professionalism throughout every project phase. Customers particularly appreciate the knowledgeable and courteous team members who take time to explain products and processes, the meticulous attention to detail in both installation and cleanup, and the lifetime warranty on materials and labor that provides lasting peace of mind. The company's combination of high-quality materials, efficient project management, punctuality, and honest, no-pressure approach has made them a trusted choice for window and gutter renovations on homes ranging from historic properties to modern residences.
"I had a fantastic experience with Victory Home Remodeling. From the initial estimate to the final walkthrough, the entire team was professional, punctual, and transparent. The quality of craftsmanship is outstanding, and they finished the project right on schedule. I especially appreciated how clean they kept the workspace and their constant communication throughout the process. • Transparent Communication: They kept me informed every step of…" — Simon Y.
+1 888-204-7510
Abraham Roofing - #1 Roofing Contractor in Lynbrook
Abraham Roofing consistently delivers exceptional service that customers praise for professionalism, efficiency, and attention to detail—from reasonable upfront estimates and prompt communication to meticulous cleanup and work completed ahead of schedule. The team is known for their respectful approach to customers' homes, reliable scheduling, and commitment to fulfilling contracts exactly as promised. Customers appreciate the stress-free experience and skilled craftsmanship that has earned them strong recommendations for both routine repairs and complete roof replacements.
"Abraham Roofing gave me a very reasonable estimate, so I decided to move forward with them. The showed up on time and prepared to work. The employees were every respectful of our house. The job site was immaculately kept while ripping off all the debris. They were able to complete a two day job in one day. Everything in our contract was completed professionally and exactly as noted. After the Job was done I had a question about my roof and…" — David F.
+1 516-990-6548
D&S Roofing, led by owner Dominick, delivers exceptional service backed by meticulous workmanship and genuine care for customers. Clients consistently praise the professionalism and punctuality of the crew, the cleanliness of completed projects, fair pricing, and Dominick's hands-on involvement—from detailed estimates and transparent explanations to ongoing support with insurance claims. The company's commitment to quality and reputation has earned strong loyalty, with multiple customers recommending D&S Roofing to family and friends.
"After doing our research and getting a few quotes, I must say that first impressions do matter. Dominick was very kind and to the point when we first met and told me about their history as a company. You could tell doing a great job and keeping their reputation in good standing was more important than anything else. They were reasonably priced and when we discovered some issues with the roof after demo, they were flexible with their options for…" — Keven M.
+1 631-518-4465
Noah Construction and Builders consistently earns praise for their fair pricing, exceptional craftsmanship, and unwavering professionalism throughout every project phase. Customers highlight the team's clear communication, meticulous attention to detail, and responsiveness from the office staff through project completion, with project managers like Gonzalo, Felipe, and Mauricio earning special recognition for their expertise and hands-on support. The company's willingness to problem-solve creatively—such as adapting to unexpected structural challenges and offering cost-effective design improvements—combined with their honest, customer-centered approach, has made them a trusted choice for complex home renovations and additions.
"I had an outstanding experience with Noah Construction and Builders back in 2021 for a full dormer and interior renovation. After getting a few other quotes, we thought Noah Construction would be way out of our price range but decided to give them a shot. Not only did they do come in at a fair price, but they were giving us more for our dollar than the others. From start to finish, their team was professional, reliable, and truly dedicated to…" — Brian C.
+1 631-750-2837
Cloud 9 Roofing and Powerwashing earns consistent praise from customers for their professionalism, responsiveness, and quality workmanship. Clients particularly appreciate the team's respectful treatment of properties, timely communication, and ability to tackle specialized cleaning challenges. With multiple repeat customers highlighting their reliability and fair pricing, Cloud 9 has built a reputation for delivering results that exceed expectations.
"I used Cloud 9 a few times years ago and was very happy with their work. I called them 3 times to do gutter cleaning this year. First call I made, I never received a call back. I did receive a call back the second time I called them and was told I’d receive an estimate and they would come the week of 6/23 to do the work. Never heard back from them again. Called back a third time and again they never returned my call. Disappointed but will find…" — Sylvia S.
+1 631-575-9087
This roofing company earns consistent praise for exceptional customer service, with team members like Mike, Simon, and Joe recognized for making the ordering process seamless and seamless and providing knowledgeable guidance on products. Customers appreciate competitive pricing that allows them to pass savings to their own clients, as well as the reliability and professionalism demonstrated across both the showroom and warehouse staff. With decades-long relationships and a reputation for delivering quality service on projects of any size, this company is highly recommended for all building materials and home improvement needs.
"Excellent products and top notch customer service. Went in to purchase drop ceiling tiles and the associates in the office/showroom could not have been nicer and more helpful. Special thanks to Patterson in the warehouse who brought the product out to us and made sure everything was right. Highly recommended for all of your building materials and home improvement needs." — Matt D.
+1 516-561-2700
Responsible Remodeling consistently delivers exceptional results across roofing, siding, and window projects, with customers praising Andrew's responsive communication and professionalism throughout the process. The team is known for arriving on time, maintaining clean work sites, maintaining high-quality workmanship, and providing reliable warranty protection on their installations. Clients repeatedly recommend the company for their commitment to customer satisfaction and willingness to stand behind their work.
"Had the entire siding of my house redone by Responsible Remodeling. Andrew was on vacation while we were deciding, but he was super responsive and helped make the process so much easier. Workers showed up on time, was professional and did quality work. I recommend this company for any work needed in the future. They stand by quality work and great customer satisfaction. Very happy I chose them." — Stephen P.
+1 516-481-1723
Babe Roof earns high marks for professional workmanship, competitive pricing, and efficient project completion, with crews consistently finishing full roof replacements in a single day while maintaining meticulous job sites. Customers particularly appreciate owner Chris's thorough inspections, transparent communication during estimates without pressure tactics, and prompt responsiveness to questions and concerns throughout the process. The company's ability to coordinate additional services like gutter installation seamlessly and deliver quality results at rates significantly lower than competitor estimates makes them a trusted choice for Long Island homeowners.
"We had a full roof replacement done by Babe Roof and were very pleased with the job. Chris arrived for our estimate on time and thoroughly inspected the roof. He took a lot of time going over options for replacement with no high pressure sales tactics. On the day of install workers began workers began showing up before 7 AM. The entire job was completed in one day. We opted for new gutters, and this was coordinated by Chris. The day after…" — Cecile L.
+1 631-243-0333
Wagner Construction Co. Inc.
Wagner Construction earns consistent praise for their professionalism, attention to detail, and fair pricing on roofing and siding projects. Customers highlight the crew's respectful and clean work practices, thorough communication about project timelines and potential issues, and commitment to quality that preserves the character of older homes. The company also demonstrates reliability through responsive follow-up service, with one customer noting they addressed a gutter issue the next day at no additional cost.
"Back in 2019, I interviewed many companies to replace my roof. Wagner was my choice, and I’m so happy I went with them. They explained the whole process to me and walked me through all the possible issues that might arise so I’d be prepared. On the day of the work, the team was respectful, clean, honest, and fast. I couldn’t be happier. A year later, I had an issue with one gutter level, and they sent someone the next day—no questions asked—and…" — Jon M.
+1 516-461-2627
Why Hire a Local Roofer in Bay Shore?
Local Climate Knowledge
Bay Shore roofers understand New York's specific weather patterns and choose materials built to last in local conditions.
Building Code Compliance
Local contractors know Bay Shore's permit requirements and code standards, ensuring your repair passes inspection.
Faster Response Times
A local company can respond to emergencies quickly and follow up easily if issues arise after the repair.
Typical Roof Repair Costs in Bay Shore
| Repair Type | Typical Cost Range |
|---|---|
| Minor Leak Repair | $150 – $400 |
| Shingle Replacement (small area) | $300 – $900 |
| Flashing Repair | $200 – $600 |
| Gutter Repair / Replacement | $150 – $500 |
| Section Repair (large area) | $1,500 – $5,000 |
| Emergency Repair | $500 – $1,500 |
| Full Roof Replacement | $8,000 – $25,000+ |
* Estimates only. Actual costs vary by scope, materials, and contractor. Get at least 3 quotes.
FAQ: Roof Repair in Bay Shore, NY
Roof repair costs in Bay Shore typically range from $150–$400 for minor leak repairs to $1,500–$5,000 for extensive section repairs. Emergency repairs can cost more. The exact price depends on the extent of damage, roofing material, roof pitch, and the contractor you choose. Always get 3 quotes before committing.
Find Roofers in Other New York Cities
Top-rated contractors near Bay Shore, organized by city