Best Roofing Companies Near You in New Carlisle, OH (2026)
Top Roofers in New Carlisle, OH
Filter by service:
Good Guys Home Improvements earns consistent praise for exceptional attention to detail, responsive communication, and genuine care throughout every project stage. Customers highlight the team's professionalism in managing complex jobs—from navigating insurance claims after storm damage to executing custom design visions with meticulous precision—while maintaining reasonable pricing and a respectful approach to homeowners' spaces. Joe and his crew are repeatedly recognized for going above and beyond, whether through quick estimates, on-site supervision, or seamlessly accommodating changes and special requests.
"I hired Good Guy Home Improvements to finish my 1,400 sq basement. I am extremely impressed with the quality of the work and the care that was taken throughout the process. I called Joe for an estimate and he came out within a day. I had a sketch of the layout that I wanted and talked with him about my vision for the space. He finished it nearly exactly to design. He made some suggestions about door locations and room sizes that I think made the…" — Keisha L.
+1 937-689-1635
Monster Roofing Construction earns consistent praise for their professionalism, quality craftsmanship, and exceptional attention to detail—from completing complex projects ahead of schedule with zero mess to proactively preventing water damage and explaining all options clearly to homeowners. Customers particularly appreciate the team's responsiveness and personable approach, with leadership like Carson known for being down-to-earth, engaged, and taking genuine pride in their work. The company delivers reliable service at competitive prices, with crews that work efficiently together and follow through with thorough cleanup and honest communication throughout every project.
"I recently had Monster Roofing Construction handle the replacement of my above-ground windows, and I couldn't be happier with the results! From the initial consultation to the final installation, their team was professional, punctual, and incredibly skilled. They took the time to explain all my options, ensuring the new windows matched my home's style perfectly while improving energy efficiency. The work was completed ahead of schedule with zero…" — JAMAR
+1 937-532-5645
Taylormade Renovations, led by owner Nick, earns consistent praise from customers for exceptional quality craftsmanship, thorough communication, and professional project management on full roof replacements and repairs. Customers particularly appreciate Nick's honest pricing, meticulous attention to detail—including damage prevention during tearoffs and transparent disclosure of any issues—and his commitment to keeping homeowners informed throughout the project with regular updates and documentation. The company's reliability, efficient crews, complete cleanup, and willingness to stand behind their work have made them a trusted choice for major roofing projects in their neighborhood.
"When it comes to roofing, there are a lot of choices. In fact, I interviewed five different contractors for this job. Taylormade was not the least expensive nor were they the most expensive. We picked Nick and his crew because we felt comfortable that all the details were discussed and written down and that we had a lot of references for the work. The A+ BBB rating was a plus too. There were some challenges but Nick was straightforward in…" — Joe M.
+1 937-744-7663
Fine Line Roofers consistently delivers quality workmanship and exceptional customer service, with clients praising owner James's responsiveness, clear communication, and honest assessments throughout every project stage. The crew demonstrates professionalism and efficiency—completing large roof replacements in one or two days while maintaining clean worksites—while offering competitive pricing that customers feel represents excellent value for the work performed. Long-term clients and referral partners trust Fine Line for their reliability, attention to detail, and willingness to accommodate scheduling needs.
"As a Realtor, James has been my go to roofing contractor that I refer clients to for years. We have had him make small repairs on, and assess our personal roof in the same time span. We finally decided that it was time for replacement on our older roofs on our house and detached garage. James and crew worked about 7am to 7pm and finished both tear-offs and new shingles with cleanup in one day. He is great to work with, easy to communicate with,…" — Jenny H.
+1 937-231-8008
Cultice Roofing consistently earns praise for owner Eric's honest, straightforward approach and expertise in navigating the insurance claims process, which has helped customers maximize their coverage. Customers appreciate the crew's professional craftsmanship, attention to detail, and commitment to cleanup, with projects typically completed efficiently in a single day. The company stands out for offering quality materials and fair pricing, backed by genuine pride in their work and a genuine commitment to customer satisfaction.
"We took some wind damage during a storm back in July and I ended up getting in touch with Andrew at Cultice. He came out and looked over the roof to see if there was more and, at his advice, I contacted my insurance. Unfortunately, my Allstate policy has an ACV clause, so they only would pay a part of the expense. Fortunately, Eric (as in, the company owner) worked with me to get me a great deal on a far better roof than the one that was put…" — Brian P.
+1 937-856-2281
Cardinal Roofing earns consistent praise from customers for their exceptional professionalism, responsiveness, and attention to detail on projects ranging from roof repairs to full replacements. Customers particularly appreciate the team's transparent communication—offering multiple options without pressure—combined with fair, competitive pricing and a genuine, caring approach to their work. The company's reliability in meeting timelines and their staff's willingness to go above and beyond have made them a trusted choice for both routine maintenance and major roofing projects.
"Cardinal Roofing did a fantastic job installing the roof, gutters, and gutter guards on my mother’s home. She’s elderly, and their compassion and attentiveness to her needs truly stood out. The entire staff was incredibly friendly, always returned phone calls, and completed everything in a timely and professional manner. I can’t think of a single complaint. Their customer service is outstanding—some of the best I’ve ever experienced. I highly…" — Rebecca T.
+1 937-576-6753
Northmont Roofing earns consistent praise for its exceptional professionalism, rapid response times, and transparent communication throughout every project stage. Customers particularly value owner Chris's hands-on involvement, honest assessments, and commitment to quality workmanship—with multiple jobs completed efficiently in a single day and fair pricing that reflects the outstanding results. The company's integrity, reliability, and willingness to go above and beyond customer expectations have built strong word-of-mouth recommendations throughout the community.
"Northmont Roofing is exceptional! Chris was great to work with! I woke up to major ceiling damage from a leaky roof. He was out to inspect it within hours. He was so friendly, thorough, and professional. He got me an estimate right away with a fair price. Because Chris was honest about what he found, it turns out the problem was still under my previous roof warranty from another company. So, they were the ones who came out to fix the issue…" — Karen H.
+1 937-234-7457
Triangle Exteriors earns consistent praise for exceptional craftsmanship and meticulous attention to detail, with owner Robert and his team delivering high-quality work on doors, windows, and exterior projects. Customers particularly value their prompt, professional service, clear communication throughout projects, and reasonable pricing. The company's commitment to protecting customer properties during installation and going above and beyond—such as painting trim and carefully managing work in historic homes—demonstrates the care and customer-focused approach that sets them apart.
"We had 22 windows, and 1 door installed, along with exterior and interior trim on the windows in our 100+ year old home. From the first time Robert came to measure and provide and estimate, through completion of the work by Robert and Tammy we could not be happier. I grew up in a family business where customer service was everything, and my wife and I carried that through in our respective careers. Robert and Tammy provide exceptional quality…" — Greg S.
+1 937-701-3273
Van Martin Roofing consistently delivers exceptional craftsmanship and thorough attention to detail, with customers praising their hard-working crews, professional installation process, and meticulous inspections that often uncover issues other contractors miss. The company stands out for responsive and knowledgeable sales representatives—including Matt, Ronnie, and James—who communicate clearly throughout the project, answer questions thoroughly, and help customers feel confident in their decisions. Customers particularly value Van Martin's long-term reliability and follow-up service, with one homeowner noting the company responded urgently to a leak more than five years after the initial installation and quickly resolved post-installation concerns.
"When random shingles started sliding off our roof, we knew something wasn’t right. Van Martin Roofing helped us quickly identify the root cause, poor installation by a previous contractor. Detailed photos from within the attic were proof (A good reminder to always double-check your roofer’s work!) We were looking for a long-term, low-maintenance solution, and James W. from Van Martin provided us with clear, detailed information about their Stone…" — Mats B.
+1 937-537-5440
Coveralls Roofing earns consistent five-star ratings for exceptional craftsmanship, meticulous attention to detail, and outstanding communication throughout every project. Owner Ken Harrison is personally involved in each job, demonstrating expertise in navigating insurance claims, using premium GAF-certified materials with extended warranties, and ensuring thorough cleanup with no hidden fees. Customers particularly appreciate the company's reliability, professionalism, and commitment to going above and beyond—from replacing rotted wood at no extra cost to providing daily updates and addressing any incidental damage caused during work.
"Wow! What a relief to find a good contractor for once. The owner, Ken Harrison, is really a great guy. He is punctual at every step of the way. He meets you personally and goes over all the options. He is a licensed journeyman and all of his workers are GAF certified. He writes out his contracts with all the necessary details with zero hidden fees during the process. Coverall's replaces 100% all rotted wood they find for free. You get new…" — Max S.
+1 937-293-5400
Why Hire a Local Roofer in New Carlisle?
Local Climate Knowledge
New Carlisle roofers understand Ohio's specific weather patterns and choose materials built to last in local conditions.
Building Code Compliance
Local contractors know New Carlisle's permit requirements and code standards, ensuring your repair passes inspection.
Faster Response Times
A local company can respond to emergencies quickly and follow up easily if issues arise after the repair.
Typical Roof Repair Costs in New Carlisle
| Repair Type | Typical Cost Range |
|---|---|
| Minor Leak Repair | $150 – $400 |
| Shingle Replacement (small area) | $300 – $900 |
| Flashing Repair | $200 – $600 |
| Gutter Repair / Replacement | $150 – $500 |
| Section Repair (large area) | $1,500 – $5,000 |
| Emergency Repair | $500 – $1,500 |
| Full Roof Replacement | $8,000 – $25,000+ |
* Estimates only. Actual costs vary by scope, materials, and contractor. Get at least 3 quotes.
FAQ: Roof Repair in New Carlisle, OH
Roof repair costs in New Carlisle typically range from $150–$400 for minor leak repairs to $1,500–$5,000 for extensive section repairs. Emergency repairs can cost more. The exact price depends on the extent of damage, roofing material, roof pitch, and the contractor you choose. Always get 3 quotes before committing.
Find Roofers in Other Ohio Cities
Top-rated contractors near New Carlisle, organized by city