Best Roofing Companies Near You in New Carlisle, OH (2026)

Prime Roofing consistently delivers exceptional service backed by quality craftsmanship and genuine customer care. Customers praise the company's rapid response times—often same-day or within hours—combined with transparent communication throughout every stage of work, from detailed explanations and photo documentation to insurance claim assistance. The owner Esteban and his professional crew are known for their attention to detail, fair pricing, thorough cleanup, and commitment to ensuring complete customer satisfaction before payment is finalized.

Ohio Roof Masters earns consistent praise from homeowners across the region for their responsiveness, clear communication, and ability to complete projects efficiently—often in a single day despite complex conditions. Customers particularly value the team's professionalism, attention to detail, and willingness to go above and beyond, from handling insurance claims and unexpected obstacles to meticulous cleanup and safety practices on steep or difficult roofs. The company's patient approach to explaining roofing options, combined with their reliable scheduling and high-quality craftsmanship, makes them a trusted choice for metal roofing and roof replacement projects in Ohio.

Sidney Roof Masters is highly regarded by customers for their quick turnaround, fair pricing, and exceptional professionalism throughout every project stage. The team—led by experienced crew members—consistently earns praise for clear communication, detailed inspections, quality workmanship, and thorough attention to detail, including specialized expertise in metal roofing and complex repairs. Customers particularly appreciate their independent warranty coverage, respectful job site practices, and willingness to go above and beyond, such as correcting serious safety issues from previous contractors.

Renegade Roofing and Restoration earns consistent praise for exceptional professionalism, attention to detail, and honest assessments that protect customers from unnecessary expenses. Led by Jason Jones, the team excels at clear communication throughout the entire process—from initial estimates through project completion—and handles complex situations like insurance claims with a personal touch that makes customers feel valued. Customers consistently highlight the superior quality of workmanship, competitive pricing, and thorough cleanup, with projects frequently completed faster than expected and results that significantly enhance home aesthetics.

Van Martin Roofing earns consistent praise for their professionalism, responsiveness, and transparent communication, with customers highlighting how team members like Jeremy, Mike, Josh, and Shawn take time to thoroughly explain repairs and address concerns before beginning work. Clients appreciate their efficient, detail-oriented approach to both emergency repairs and installations—from leak fixes to skylights and solar tubes—along with their respect for homes and commitment to thorough cleanup. The company stands out for reliability and trustworthiness, particularly valued by customers managing repairs remotely or dealing with urgent water damage issues.

Xpert Roofing earns consistent praise from customers for their competitive pricing, fast turnaround times, and quality workmanship on both residential and commercial projects. Customers particularly appreciate the company's professionalism, reliability, and honest communication—they note that staff answer calls promptly, show up when scheduled, and avoid recommending unnecessary work. The team's thorough cleanup and attention to detail, combined with their willingness to help navigate insurance claims, make them a trusted choice for roofing and gutter services.

Copley Construction earns consistent praise from customers for their exceptional craftsmanship, attention to detail, and professional workmanship across diverse projects—from basement renovations to roofing repairs, fence installation, and outdoor work. Customers particularly appreciate the team's reliability, friendliness, and communication, with many noting their commitment to maintaining clean, organized job sites and coordinating schedules efficiently. With multiple repeat customers and strong recommendations across various project types, Copley Construction is recognized as a trustworthy, detail-oriented contractor that delivers high-quality results while providing a stress-free experience.

Schroer and Sons earns consistent praise for exceptional craftsmanship, professional installation, and meticulous attention to detail on both simple and complex roofing projects. Customers particularly appreciate the team's honest communication, proactive problem-solving, and respectful work practices, with many noting that their roofs have proven durable and reliable years after installation. The company's owner Ryan is frequently recognized for his integrity, competitive pricing, and willingness to go above and beyond to address customer concerns.

All Around Roofing, Siding and Gutters earns consistent praise from customers for their professionalism, thorough communication, and quality craftsmanship—with the owner personally stepping in to resolve issues and ensure customer satisfaction. Clients appreciate the team's attention to detail, swift project completion, competitive pricing, and willingness to go above and beyond, from discovering and addressing hidden problems to following through on commitments. The company's combination of skilled workmanship, polite crews, and responsive office staff has resulted in neighbors requesting referrals and customers expressing confidence in hiring them for future projects.

Scott Bauer Roofing & Siding delivers exceptional craftsmanship combined with outstanding customer service, earning consistent praise for attention to detail, professional installation crews, and transparent communication throughout every project. Customers consistently highlight competitive pricing, comprehensive warranties (including 20-year workmanship guarantees), and the team's dedication to understanding their needs and ensuring complete satisfaction. The company's reliability extends from initial estimates through final cleanup, with knowledgeable staff like Ken, Chloe, and project managers who keep homeowners informed and address concerns promptly, even navigating complex insurance claims with ease.